Macy Cakes

Macy Cakes Making custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes and more for all occasions!

01/31/2026

cannot wait for spring weather

Aaaand a follow up for my ✨favorite/gorgeous✨ goodies that I did and forgot to post (but deserve their own post)😂🥹
11/10/2025

Aaaand a follow up for my ✨favorite/gorgeous✨ goodies that I did and forgot to post (but deserve their own post)😂🥹

A JUMBO post of all the orders Ive done the last few months but haven’t posted🥲
11/10/2025

A JUMBO post of all the orders Ive done the last few months but haven’t posted🥲

I have about a dozen left! Grab yours before they’re gone😋🤠🍪
09/29/2025

I have about a dozen left! Grab yours before they’re gone😋🤠🍪

Happy Sunday! They’re baaaaack🤪🍪🐎🤠Joyce’s COWBOY COOKIES🤠🐎🍪These are ORDER ONLY (while supplies last!) & will be PORCH P...
09/28/2025

Happy Sunday! They’re baaaaack🤪

🍪🐎🤠Joyce’s COWBOY COOKIES🤠🐎🍪

These are ORDER ONLY (while supplies last!) & will be PORCH PICK UP! The Sweet Spot stand will NOT be out!!

$4/ea
Cash, Venmo (-Pettis), Apple Pay (317-654-6253), or Zelle (317-654-6253)

All orders will be handed out my by gorgeous assistant/porch goose Gwendolyn (pictured below). Just look for the baggie with your name🤗

IM CAPPED OUT GUYS HOLY COW😂🥹🫶🏽 orders are closed for now!! Lemme catch up and they’ll be back soon👀You asked, so here t...
09/11/2025

IM CAPPED OUT GUYS HOLY COW😂🥹🫶🏽 orders are closed for now!! Lemme catch up and they’ll be back soon👀

You asked, so here they are👀
Straight from the OG recipe…from a direct descendant of the legend herself who brought them to SHS decades ago…
🍪🐎🤠Joyce’s COWBOY COOKIES🤠🐎🍪

These are ORDER ONLY & will be PORCH PICK UP! The Sweet Spot stand will NOT be out!!

$4/ea
Cash, Venmo (-Pettis), Apple Pay (317-654-6253), or Zelle (317-654-6253)

ETA: all orders will be handed out my by gorgeous assistant/porch goose Gwendolyn (pictured below). Just look for the baggie with your name🤗

🎀Come grab some goods before they’re gone!🎀I’m down to:2 lemon blueberry cookies5 kitchen sink cookies7 apple blondies w...
08/29/2025

🎀Come grab some goods before they’re gone!🎀
I’m down to:
2 lemon blueberry cookies
5 kitchen sink cookies
7 apple blondies w/ maple glaze
And a fresh batch of triple chocolate espresso cakes (5)!

Don’t forget to grab your pup a cookie too! We don’t forget the pups around here☺️🐾

🎀The Sweet Spot is up and open, bright and early🌤️🎀Dont be the fox…come grab a lil somethin👀😋**Im currently out of the c...
08/28/2025

🎀The Sweet Spot is up and open, bright and early🌤️🎀
Dont be the fox…come grab a lil somethin👀😋

**Im currently out of the chocolate espresso cakes but will get more baked this afternoon!**

🍌 Chocolate Chip topped Banana Bread 🍌
☕️ Triple Choc. Espresso Poke Cake w/ Caramel Icing ☕️
🍁🍎 Apple Blondies w/ Maple Glaze 🍎🍁
🍋🫐 Lemon Blueberry Cookies 🫐🍋
🎉 Kitchen Sink Cookies 🎉

📍6029 e. 100 n.
Shelbyville, IN 46176

How about a mid-week pick-me-up!?🎀The Sweet Spot is up and open!!🎀Listen, I am a FALL GIRLIE through and through. When I...
08/27/2025

How about a mid-week pick-me-up!?
🎀The Sweet Spot is up and open!!🎀

Listen, I am a FALL GIRLIE through and through. When I felt the temps drop, the crisp morning chill and the light breeze roll in, I just HAD to bring out some warm and cozy fall vibes for the menu this round!😍🍂
(It’s also taking everything in my power to not go into pumpkin overload for the rest of the season. Ya girl LUVS her some pumpkin😂 I digress.)

🍌 Chocolate Chip topped Banana Bread 🍌
☕️ Triple Choc. Espresso Poke Cake w/ Caramel Icing ☕️
🍁🍎 Apple Blondies w/ Maple Glaze 🍎🍁
🍋🫐 Lemon Blueberry Cookies 🫐🍋
🎉 Kitchen Sink Cookies 🎉

📍6029 e. 100 n.
Shelbyville, IN 46176

I realized the other day that I’ve never really posted or explained who I am on here!😅 So for those who may not know…My ...
08/10/2025

I realized the other day that I’ve never really posted or explained who I am on here!😅
So for those who may not know…

My name is Macy Pettis and I am the face (& name) behind Macy Cakes!
Macy Cakes is a cozy, personalized, home-based bakery where every treat is made with love, care, and a dash of homemade magic.
I offer a wide variety of baked sweets. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply have a craving for a sweet treat, I specialize in all of the above! I not only work one-on-one with customers for specialized orders, I also have a self-serve roadside stand where I offer different goodies each weekend! No matter what you’re feeling- my end goal is to spread pure joy one homemade, delicious bite at a time.

I grew up loving to bake and create in the kitchen. It wasn’t until I worked at a bakery in high school (~2014) that my love really took off and I thought, “hey, I could do this on my own!” Once that bakery closed its doors a few years later, I knew it was my time to shine. Macy Cakes was officially founded in 2017.

I have taken the last 10-ish years to perfect my craft and recipes and to grow my skills and confidence. Of course, life has happened during that time but I have always stayed true to my love of baking which has brought me here today! I am now a toddler boy mom of one who left her dream job as a Surgical Tech to spend more time at home. Having this small business has not only allowed me to spend these irreplaceable early years with my son (without drowning financially), but it has also allowed me to do something else that I have always loved. For that, I will be forever grateful.

I thank you for stopping by to read about me and my love for caking and baking! I appreciate your support of my small, local, momma run business.
If you ever have a hankering for a sweet treat, you know where to find me!🩷🧁🍪

I have 5 mini sugar cookie sets ($5) left and 9 packs of pretzels (2 for $5)! We can meet or I can porch/mailbox drop of...
08/05/2025

I have 5 mini sugar cookie sets ($5) left and 9 packs of pretzels (2 for $5)!
We can meet or I can porch/mailbox drop off!

Cash, Venmo (-Pettis), Apple Pay (317-654-6253), or Zelle (317-654-6253)
🥨🍫☀️🍦🎉🍪

Its a wonderful Monday for some treats🌤️Swing by and treat yoself😋• Brookies 🍫🍪• Kitchen sink cookies 🎉🍪• Chocolate dipp...
08/04/2025

Its a wonderful Monday for some treats🌤️
Swing by and treat yoself😋

• Brookies 🍫🍪
• Kitchen sink cookies 🎉🍪
• Chocolate dipped pretzels 🍫🥨
• Iced sugar cookies 🍦☀️

📍6029 e. 100 n.
Shelbyville

Address

Shelbyville, IN
46176

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Macy Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Macy Cakes:

Shortcuts

Share

Category