The Cookie Jar Girls

The Cookie Jar Girls We are a small at-home bakery. We make custom cakes, cookies, bread, Potica, pies, candy and more!

We work mostly by special order, cookies, cakes, Potica, breads, snack mix, gourmet Christmas cookies... if you don’t see your favorite posted, message us! We love special orders
Just bring your ideas and we will create the perfect cake or cookies for your special day whether its a wedding, shower, birthday, holiday or cookies for lunchboxes!

Irises and mums
06/01/2026

Irises and mums

Congratulations to all of the 2026 graduates! 🎓 🎉
06/01/2026

Congratulations to all of the 2026 graduates! 🎓 🎉

Cross cookies
06/01/2026

Cross cookies

Birthday Cookies! 🥳
06/01/2026

Birthday Cookies! 🥳

I forgot to take pictures of all the cookie orders this week, but here are a few!
05/10/2026

I forgot to take pictures of all the cookie orders this week, but here are a few!

Elsa’s snowflakes headed to Dare To Dream Theatre’s Frozen. Your last chance to see it is today at 2:00 at Lutheran High...
05/10/2026

Elsa’s snowflakes headed to Dare To Dream Theatre’s Frozen. Your last chance to see it is today at 2:00 at Lutheran High School.

04/22/2026
12/23/2025

I have an order for a Leah Bartley, but no other contact information. If you are Leah Bartley, your cookie order is ready 😄 Send me a PM.

Address

W3068 Cty Road C
Sheboygan Falls, WI

Telephone

+19206271165

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Jar Girls posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cookie Jar Girls:

Shortcuts

Share

Category