Wooden Spoon Bakery NY

05/25/2026

05/17/2026

While I do not take custom sugar cookie orders, sometimes a special cause pops up and I just can’t say no. May be slightly obsessed with these 💜

05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day to all the Mom’s, Bonus Mom’s, Grandma’s, Fur-Baby Mom’s and all other Moms out there! Enjoy your day!

05/06/2026

**ORDERING HAS CLOSED***
Order by noon today (Wednesday)!

For Mother’s Day, for pickup Saturday, May 9th at 9:30 at Tractor Supply.

Mini Heart Cake, $8
(Vanilla or Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream
Flowers; equivalent to 2.5 cupcakes in size)

Cupcakes, mix and match flavors, 6/$20

Chocolate Raspberry
(Chocolate cupcake topped with our raspberry buttercream)

Triple Chocolate
(Chocolate cupcake, Milk chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache… chocolate!)

Boston Cream
(Vanilla cupcake, vanilla pudding, chocolate ganache and rich chocolate buttercream)

Chocolate Oreo
(Chocolate cupcake with Oreo buttercream, topped with an Oreo and Oreo crumbs)

Lemon Drop
(Vanilla cupcake with scratch made lemon curd filling topped with lemon buttercream)

Lemon Blueberry
(Vanilla cupcake, lemon curd filling, topped with fresh blueberry buttercream)

Fresh Strawberry
(vanilla cupcake filled with fresh strawberry compote, topped with strawberry buttercream)

Chocolate Peanut Butter
(Possibly our most popular favorite flavor-our chocolate cupcake topped with our peanut butter buttercream)

Chocolate Sundae
(chocolate cupcake topped with a scoop of vanilla buttercream, chocolate ganache, rainbow sprinkles and a cherry)

05/04/2026

**ORDERING HAS CLOSED***

For Mother’s Day, please order by Wednesday, May 6th at noon for pickup Saturday, May 9th at 9:30 at Tractor Supply.

Mini Heart Cake, $8
(Vanilla or Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream
Flowers; equivalent to 2.5 cupcakes in size)

Cupcakes, mix and match flavors, 6/$20

Chocolate Raspberry
(Chocolate cupcake topped with our raspberry buttercream)

Triple Chocolate
(Chocolate cupcake, Milk chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache… chocolate!)

Boston Cream
(Vanilla cupcake, vanilla pudding, chocolate ganache and rich chocolate buttercream)

Chocolate Oreo
(Chocolate cupcake with Oreo buttercream, topped with an Oreo and Oreo crumbs)

Lemon Drop
(Vanilla cupcake with scratch made lemon curd filling topped with lemon buttercream)

Lemon Blueberry
(Vanilla cupcake, lemon curd filling, topped with fresh blueberry buttercream)

Fresh Strawberry
(vanilla cupcake filled with fresh strawberry compote, topped with strawberry buttercream)

Chocolate Peanut Butter
(Possibly our most popular favorite flavor-our chocolate cupcake topped with our peanut butter buttercream)

Chocolate Sundae
(chocolate cupcake topped with a scoop of vanilla buttercream, chocolate ganache, rainbow sprinkles and a cherry)

04/05/2026

Happy Easter to all who celebrate!

03/28/2026

Easter ordering is now open ☺️
Order by Tuesday, March 31st for pickup between 10:00-10:30 on Saturday, April 4th at the Tractor Supply/Starbucks Plaza in the Town of Ulster.

Customized Bunny sugar cookie bag, $8
One color per bag, please. Colors available are pink,
orange, yellow, green, blue and purple.

Sugar Cookie Box, $30
12 decorated sugar cookies, mixed designs

Cookie Kit, $20
9 cookies, icing and decorations

Mix and Match cupcakes, 6 for $20

Lemon Drop
Vanilla cake, scratch made lemon curd, lemon
buttercream
Boston Cream
Vanilla cake, vanilla pudding, chocolate
ganache and rich chocolate buttercream
Carrot Cake
Complete with walnuts and raisins
Chocolate Sundae
Chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream,
chocolate ganache, sprinkles and a cherry
Birthday Cake
Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream, sprinkles
Chocolate Raspberry
Chocolate cake and raspberry buttercream

03/24/2026

***ORDERING HAS CLOSED***

Order by Tuesday, March 31st for pickup between 10:00-10:30 on Saturday, April 4th at the Tractor Supply/Starbucks Plaza in the Town of Ulster.

Customized Bunny sugar cookie bag, $8
One color per bag, please. Colors available are pink,
orange, yellow, green, blue and purple.

Sugar Cookie Box, $30
12 decorated sugar cookies, mixed designs

Cookie Kit, $20
9 cookies, icing and decorations

Mix and Match cupcakes, 6 for $20

Lemon Drop
Vanilla cake, scratch made lemon curd, lemon
buttercream
Boston Cream
Vanilla cake, vanilla pudding, chocolate
ganache and rich chocolate buttercream
Carrot Cake
Complete with walnuts and raisins
Chocolate Sundae
Chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream,
chocolate ganache, sprinkles and a cherry
Birthday Cake
Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream, sprinkles
Chocolate Raspberry
Chocolate cake and raspberry buttercream