Caribbean Pie Company

Caribbean Pie Company Home of the award-winning key lime pie and other tasty pies, cheesecakes, and tarts you can enjoy in our shop or in local businesses! Pier

Our pies and fudge are also available online. WE DELIVER TO SURROUNDING AREAS.

Celebrate Easter Sunday with us! We're open from 10am to 2pm. Hop on by and enjoy our delicious pies and more!
03/27/2024

Celebrate Easter Sunday with us! We're open from 10am to 2pm. Hop on by and enjoy our delicious pies and more!

Happy New Year from everyone at Caribbean Pie Company! Thank you, everyone, for a record-breaking year, we are excited a...
12/31/2023

Happy New Year from everyone at Caribbean Pie Company! Thank you, everyone, for a record-breaking year, we are excited about what 2024 has to offer! We will be open today, December 23rd, from 10-4, so stop on in for any last-minute New Years party deserts!

Thank you to and for having us on again this morning! We discuss our seasonal pies and have the crew give them a try! ...
11/10/2023

Thank you to and for having us on again this morning! We discuss our seasonal pies and have the crew give them a try! Thanksgiving is under two weeks away, so get those Thanksgiving orders in ASAP! The link to the segment will be in our Instagram bio.

With fall now here, so brings the season to bring back out our Apple Crumb Pie! Here's some pictures of today's batch! ...
10/09/2023

With fall now here, so brings the season to bring back out our Apple Crumb Pie! Here's some pictures of today's batch! Come on in and pick yours up at our store or for order at the farmers markets! Stay tuned for our other seasonal pies over the coming days and weeks.

Stop in at the Sarasota or Venice Farmers Markets today to taste our Award Winning Key Lime Pie! Visit our retail loca...
09/23/2023

Stop in at the Sarasota or Venice Farmers Markets today to taste our Award Winning Key Lime Pie!

Visit our retail location at 2245 Bee Ridge Rd. Sarasota on Tuesday and mention National Keylime Pie Day (Sept. 26) to receive $1 off any Key Lime Pie.

Don't forget to stop at our retail location, 2245 Bee Ridge Rd Sarasota, and pick up some delicious pies for Easter! Ca...
04/03/2023

Don't forget to stop at our retail location, 2245 Bee Ridge Rd Sarasota, and pick up some delicious pies for Easter! Call to order ahead (941)-882-4589

http://caribbeanpieco.com

11/30/2022
Looking for a great gift idea this holiday? We have GIFT CARDS!!! Treat your family and friends to their choice of a swe...
11/30/2022

Looking for a great gift idea this holiday?
We have GIFT CARDS!!!
Treat your family and friends to their choice of a sweet treat - stop at our retail location or find us at the local Farmer's Markets to purchase gift cards that everyone will love!

Bite Into Something Good…. Try our Key Lime Bites!!! 🤤
09/21/2022

Bite Into Something Good…. Try our Key Lime Bites!!! 🤤

Address

2245 Bee Ridge Road
Sarasota, FL
34239

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 4pm
Tuesday 11am - 4pm
Wednesday 11am - 4pm
Thursday 11am - 4pm
Friday 11am - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Caribbean Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Caribbean Pie Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Our Story

In 1993, the Caribbean Pie Company began crafting a delicious key lime pie that would go on to become one of the most loved key lime pies in Florida. All these years later, and our now award-winning key lime pie and our other tasty pies, cheesecakes, and tarts have continued to satisfy dessert lovers of all ages. Come by to visit our store or stop by our table at the farmer’s market -- you’ll always be greeted by welcoming people and friendly conversation from a team that cares about building connections with our customers and our community.