Sugar Plum bakeshop

02/10/2026

Wedding cake for Paul and Sheena 🌹🫐

Red velvet cake (colored with beets) with cream cheese buttercream.
Drove from Idaho to North Carolina to spend the weekend baking and making frosting then putting it all together for my brother-in-law and his bride at their wedding reception. After not putting enough cocoa in one batch, and completely forgetting the sugar in another, I eventually got it right and assembled and decorated the two tier cake at the venue, before putting together and frosting a full sheet cake (there was supposed to be two, but I didn’t realize just how big a full layered sheet cake is and ran out of ingredients, this bad boy took 4 batches of batter!)

While I’m so happy I could do this for these two love birds, i definitely do not have plans to make another wedding cake for a good, long while 😅

09/03/2024

RIP Mom’s Youth 🪦🥀

My Mom turned 50 on Friday and I was surprised she said yes to my suggestion of a tombstone cake (a lot of my siblings and I are very macabre and she is not a fan lol)
Yellow cake with chocolate American buttercream, that I also made gluten free so I could enjoy some myself 😋

Send a message to learn more

08/26/2024

Chocolate raspberry birthday cake

This fudgy chocolate cake (which is gluten free btw) is filled with raspberry jam, frosted with raspberry Swiss meringue buttercream and topped with dairy-free chocolate ganache and a bit of vanilla buttercream piping.
My husband’s birthday was on Saturday and we celebrated yesterday with a couple friends and this cake he requested

08/09/2024

Woodland Cake 🪵🍄🦋🌼

I made this cake back in September 2022 for my birthday and I love all things woodland, fairy and cottagecore so that was my inspiration. The mushrooms are made with toothpicks, strawberries and buttercream spots and the moss is gluten free graham crackers crushed and mixed with green food gel.
I used a mold for the fondant flowers and butterflies then painted them, and the yellow mushrooms I shaped and painted by hand.
The flavor was probably just vanilla with chocolate buttercream but no dairy, eggs or gluten because of my allergies

08/07/2024

“I thought of something funnier than 24…
25!” 🧽🪸🫧

Another cake from the archives, this one was last year for my husband’s 25th birthday.
If I’m remembering correctly, I believe it was pineapple cake with coconut buttercream, but I could totally be wrong 😅
Just don’t look too close at the piping around the rim, I was trying a new technique and it didn’t turn out very uniform lol

08/07/2024

07/25/2024

“Sweet One” smash cake I made for my baby’s 1st birthday back in March. Isn’t it just adorable?
I chose donuts for the theme because I took his monthly milestone photos with donuts until he hit 12 months. it was so fun!
The cake is sugar free (made with real maple syrup, bananas and whole wheat), covered in whipped cream (also flavored with maple syrup). The donuts are also on the healthier side but have a tiny bit of real cane sugar in the glaze and dye free sprinkles on top.
I also semi recreated the cake for his birthday party since the photoshoot was a couple weeks before his actual birthday

07/24/2024

Wedding cake for my sister-in-law’s special day 🤍🩵

It’s been a hot minute since I’ve posted in this account 😅 (I think around 2 years?! How the time flies!)
I’ve been busy moving to Utah, being pregnant, having a baby, and then moving back to Rexburg so I’m wanting to get back to posting my creations, though I’m still not really in a position to get back to selling anytime soon.

03/31/2022

NEW FLAVOR ALERT 🚨
✨Funfetti✨

You might think these are a bit too sweet, but you’d be pleasantly surprised! They’re light, buttery and perfectly balanced in flavor. Plus, who can resist sprinkles?

03/29/2022

Easter is quickly hopping up!
🐰💐🥕
Celebrate with these adorable themed cupcakes, mix and match your dozen for everyone’s preferences.
Pictured we have: carrot cake (with walnuts, cream cheese buttercream and hand-painted fondant carrots) triple chocolate nest (Devils food, chocolate cream cheese buttercream and Hershey’s eggs), chocolate peanut butter or Sunflower butter nest, and floral bunny ears (chocolate, vanilla floral buttercream and white chocolate bunny ears).

As always, each flavor and decoration is customizable, and as someone who is gluten, egg and dairy free, I make sure to take into account your food allergies!

$15 per dozen, pickup in Rexburg Idaho