In Crust We Trust

In Crust We Trust Locally baked organic sourdough with unique flavors. Conveniently located in Lake Peekskill, NY.

08/19/2026

A Small Business Reminder ❤️

This isn’t our usual type of post, but we feel it’s important to say this.

Behind every loaf of sourdough is a small business; real time, real ingredients, and a lot of hard work. We take pride in providing a top-tier, handcrafted product, and we work hard to make sure every order is prepared with the same care we would expect for ourselves.

Because of that, payment is required to confirm and secure your order. This policy isn’t about being difficult or distrustful—it’s simply one of the ways we protect our small business, our ingredients, and the time that goes into every loaf.

Unfortunately, attempts to defraud or scam our business will not be tolerated. Any fraudulent activity will be documented, reported to the appropriate platforms/authorities, and the individual will be blocked from placing future orders.

We truly appreciate everyone who supports our little bakery, respects our policies, and continues to choose locally made, small-batch sourdough. ❤️

Thank you for helping us keep our small business growing! 🍞

The shelves at PVM are stocked with fresh sourdough! Don’t wait—these handmade loaves are available in limited quantitie...
08/07/2026

The shelves at PVM are stocked with fresh sourdough! Don’t wait—these handmade loaves are available in limited quantities and tend to disappear quickly.

07/31/2026

✨ Fresh sourdough has officially been dropped off at PVM! ✨

This week’s loaves are looking extra special. ❤️ Each one is beautifully decorated with our bakery logo and now proudly carries a new stamp:

“Baked with love in the kitchen of Michelle.”

It’s a little reminder that every loaf is handcrafted, slow-fermented, and made with care from start to finish.

If you’ve been waiting for fresh sourdough, now’s the time! Our loaves are made in small batches, and once they’re gone, they’re gone until the next bake.

Stop by PVM, grab your favorite loaf, and treat yourself to fresh, homemade sourdough while supplies last. 🍞✨

Thank you for supporting our little microbakery—it truly means the world to us. ❤️

07/27/2026

To continue providing the freshest handmade sourdough, In Crust We Trust requires payment at the time your order is placed to reserve your loaf.

Because each loaf is made from scratch, sourdough takes 2–3 days to ferment, shape, and bake. Once we begin preparing your order, the ingredients, time, and space in our baking schedule are committed just for you.

Requiring payment upfront helps reduce last-minute cancellations and food waste, allowing us to focus on baking delicious bread for customers who have reserved their orders.

Thank you so much for understanding and for supporting our small business. ❤️🥖

06/04/2026

🍞 Bread Friends, We’re Taking a Short Break! 🍞

No loaf drop at Putnam Valley Market this week as we’re taking a little time to recharge.

The good news? We’ll be back next week with fresh sourdough loaves straight from the oven and headed to the shelves.

See you soon—and save room for sourdough! ❤️🍞

🚨 BREAKING BREAD NEWS 🚨The shelves at PVM just got dangerously delicious.Today’s sourdough drop is officially in the wil...
05/29/2026

🚨 BREAKING BREAD NEWS 🚨
The shelves at PVM just got dangerously delicious.

Today’s sourdough drop is officially in the wild — fresh baked, crackly crusted, and smelling like the kind of decision-making your diet warned you about.

Limited loaves. No backups. No secret stash hidden in the trunk of our car. Once they’re gone, they’re gone-gone.

If you’ve been thinking about “stopping by later,” this is your sign that later is how heartbreak happens.

🏃‍♀️ Fresh loaves now at Putnam Valley Market
✨ Small batch
✨ Baked today
✨ Likely to disappear suspiciously fast

Tag the person who always says “just one slice” and then eats half the loaf standing at the counter.

05/15/2026

⚠️ Reports are coming in from Putnam Valley Market of dangerously fresh sourdough on the premises.

Witnesses describe:
🥖 crackly crusts
🥖 warm, bakery-fresh aroma
🥖 uncontrollable butter application
🥖 people “just grabbing one” and somehow leaving with three

Today’s loaves were baked fresh THIS MORNING and quantities are very limited. Once the shelves are cleared, that’s it until the next bake.

We cannot legally guarantee happiness… but we can strongly suggest grabbing a loaf before your neighbor does. 👀🔥

Experimenting with bold flavors is a favorite pastime here!
04/14/2026

Experimenting with bold flavors is a favorite pastime here!

We might not win any awards for our social media skills… but we will win you over with our sourdough 😄We’ve been a littl...
04/10/2026

We might not win any awards for our social media skills… but we will win you over with our sourdough 😄

We’ve been a little quiet on here because we’ve been busy behind the scenes doing what we do best: baking up beautiful, delicious loaves just like this one for our amazing customers.

If you’ve been craving one (or three), send us a message to grab yours! Or you can find our loaves at Putnam Valley Market this weekend.

Fresh bread > perfect posts… every time 🥖✨

Address

Putnam Valley, NY
10537

Telephone

+19142826904

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when In Crust We Trust posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category