In Crust We Trust

In Crust We Trust Locally baked sourdough with unique flavors. Conveniently located in Lake Peekskill, NY.

05/15/2026

⚠️ Reports are coming in from Putnam Valley Market of dangerously fresh sourdough on the premises.

Witnesses describe:
🥖 crackly crusts
🥖 warm, bakery-fresh aroma
🥖 uncontrollable butter application
🥖 people “just grabbing one” and somehow leaving with three

Today’s loaves were baked fresh THIS MORNING and quantities are very limited. Once the shelves are cleared, that’s it until the next bake.

We cannot legally guarantee happiness… but we can strongly suggest grabbing a loaf before your neighbor does. 👀🔥

Experimenting with bold flavors is a favorite pastime here!
04/14/2026

Experimenting with bold flavors is a favorite pastime here!

We might not win any awards for our social media skills… but we will win you over with our sourdough 😄We’ve been a littl...
04/10/2026

We might not win any awards for our social media skills… but we will win you over with our sourdough 😄

We’ve been a little quiet on here because we’ve been busy behind the scenes doing what we do best: baking up beautiful, delicious loaves just like this one for our amazing customers.

If you’ve been craving one (or three), send us a message to grab yours! Or you can find our loaves at Putnam Valley Market this weekend.

Fresh bread > perfect posts… every time 🥖✨

11/15/2025

🍞✨ Fresh-baked alert! ✨🍞
Your favorite sourdough loaves are out of the oven, crusty, and impossible to resist. Swing by and grab your fresh-baked goodies before they disappear — because they will disappear. 😅

🦃 Thanksgiving Orders
Make sure your holiday table is complete with the magic of In Crust We Trust!
All Thanksgiving orders must be placed by November 23 and picked up by November 26 by 6pm to guarantee a spot at your feast.

Thank you for supporting our tiny-but-mighty microbakery — every order, share, and kind word keeps us rising. 💛

11/09/2025

The Putnam Valley Market is open until 7 with a few of our tasty loaves left! Grab some tonight to have with dinner or breakfast tomorrow! 😋

11/03/2025

🦃✨ Thanksgiving is flying into view, and In Crust We Trust would be grateful to land on your holiday table!

From cozy loaves for stuffing and sandwiches to our signature flavored favorites, let us bring a little sourdough magic to your feast. 💛

🥖 Thanksgiving Order Details:
🗓️ Orders due by Thursday, November 23
📦 Pickup on Wednesday, November 26 (by 6pm)

We’re so thankful for every bit of support — your orders, your kind reviews, and the way you spread the word about our little microbakery. You’re the reason we get to keep baking love (and carbs) into every loaf.

Let’s make this Thanksgiving extra delicious — message us to reserve your bread! 🍞💛

In Crust We Trust won first place at the Yorktown Grange Fair!
09/05/2025

In Crust We Trust won first place at the Yorktown Grange Fair!

Fresh out of the oven! Our golden, crackling sourdough boules just hit the cooling rack and they won’t last long once th...
08/22/2025

Fresh out of the oven!

Our golden, crackling sourdough boules just hit the cooling rack and they won’t last long once they arrive later today at Putnam Valley Market!

Each loaf is handcrafted, long-fermented, and baked to perfection with that rustic, blistered crust you can only get from real sourdough.

Perfect for sandwiches, dunking into soups, or just tearing apart while it’s still warm.

08/11/2025

It’s too hot to cook. 🥵

You wander to your garden, pick a sun-warmed tomato, slice it thick, and toast up two slices of our fresh, rustic style sourdough. A swipe of mayo, a sprinkle of salt & pepper… and suddenly you realize… this isn’t lunch, this is a love story. ❤️🍞🍅

Make it real. Order your loaf now before you miss out on the best sandwiches of your life! 🥖✨

OR swing by Putnam Valley Market this weekend to snag a fresh loaf and some of their house-made mozzarella—your tomato sandwich will thank you. 🧀🍅

🚨 Bread Alert 🚨We’re back, the ovens are hot, and the loaves are lookin’ dangerously irresistible. Later today at the Pu...
08/08/2025

🚨 Bread Alert 🚨
We’re back, the ovens are hot, and the loaves are lookin’ dangerously irresistible. Later today at the Putnam Valley Market, you can try to snag one… but fair warning — bread bandits move fast around here. 🏃‍♂️💨

If you miss out, don’t cry into your empty bread basket — just slide into our DMs and we’ll bake you your very own loaf.

08/04/2025

Guess who’s back and smellin’ like fresh bread? 🥖👃

We took a little time off to relax, recharge, and definitely not forget how to post on social media (🫣)… but now we’re back in the kitchen, floured up and fired up!

If you’ve been dreaming of chewy crusts, tangy centers, and loaves so good they disappear before the butter hits the table — you’re in luck. Your favorite sourdough microbakery is open for orders again!

💌 Slide into our messages to claim your loaf — these sell out fast. We might be a little rusty at posting…
But trust us — we never forget how to bake.

Let’s get this bread. Literally. 🔥🥖

Address

Putnam Valley, NY
10537

Telephone

+19142826904

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when In Crust We Trust posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category