The Butterstick Bakery

02/15/2026

Young, wild & THREE! 🦁✨
Safari sweetness for a roaring good birthday celebration 🐘🦒
These hand-decorated sugar cookies are almost too cute to eat… almost 😉

Butter makes everything better 💛
📍Prairie du Chien, WI
DM to order your custom set!

02/04/2026

Mischief managed in the kitchen ✨🧁
These house-inspired cakes were pure magic to create!

From wand details to hand-painted crests, every inch is edible and handcrafted with butter, sugar, and a little bit of wizardry.

Which house would you choose? 🦁🦅🐍🦡

01/01/2026

Could this cake BE any cuter? ☕🛋️

A little nostalgia, a lot of butter, and one iconic couch later—this FRIENDS cake was ready to steal the spotlight.
Custom cakes are my specialty, and I love bringing your favorite shows and memories to life 💛

DM to order ✨

12/04/2025

Soft ombré buttercream, chocolatey drips, and peanut buttery swirls… yes please!
Our Peanut Butter Ombre Cake features chocolate cake, chocolate + peanut butter buttercream, dark chocolate ganache, a peanut butter drizzle, and a crown of peanut butter cups.
Buttery, dreamy, and made with love. ✨

11/11/2025

🎂✨ Sweet, colorful, and made with love! ✨🎂

This rainbow lollipop cake was crafted in the most vibrant way possible 🌈🍭 Layers of color, creamy buttercream, and a touch of candy magic — all from The Butterstick Bakery 💕

Because every celebration deserves a little extra sweetness!

10/19/2025

10/05/2025

Nothing makes us happier than making a bride’s vision come to life!

09/29/2025

09/20/2025

That’s right! It’s pumpkin spice season and we’re rolling it out with some PUMPKIN SPICE CUPCAKES!