Buttercup's Dairy Store

Buttercup's Dairy Store "Wow, you like, have a little of everything in here! I never knew, it's like a mini super market!"

"Yea! we have our own bakery, try our fresh breads!"

We are open from 8 am to 2 pm today for Memorial Day!
05/25/2026

We are open from 8 am to 2 pm today for Memorial Day!

Looking for a great treat for a great price??? We've got our Apple Crumb Pies on sale for $4.99 Each all week long!!!
04/20/2026

Looking for a great treat for a great price??? We've got our Apple Crumb Pies on sale for $4.99 Each all week long!!!

It's OFFICIAL!!! Buttercup Day is less than 1 Month Away!!!!!!
04/19/2026

It's OFFICIAL!!! Buttercup Day is less than 1 Month Away!!!!!!

Thanksgiving is right around the corner!
11/17/2025

Thanksgiving is right around the corner!

Fall is here and so are our seasonal savings!Large Carving Pumpkins - 2/$10Corn Stalks - $9.99Sunflowers - $8.99 per bun...
09/27/2025

Fall is here and so are our seasonal savings!

Large Carving Pumpkins - 2/$10
Corn Stalks - $9.99
Sunflowers - $8.99 per bunch
8" Pumpkin Pie - $4.99 (through 9/30)
8" Apple Crumb Pie - $5.99 (through 9/30)

Fresh Baked Cookies OVER 20 VARIETIES!!!!

Just a reminder - we are open until 4 pm Today!
09/01/2025

Just a reminder - we are open until 4 pm Today!

07/04/2025

July 4th we are closing at 2 pm.

Happy Independence Day!

We've got fantastic options for this rainy Father's Day weekend Saturday! from 11 am - 2 pm the Boar's Head Team will be...
06/14/2025

We've got fantastic options for this rainy Father's Day weekend Saturday! from 11 am - 2 pm the Boar's Head Team will be serving up a Free Hotdog to all of our guests!

We also have a fantastic special Father's Day Pie Sale! For every pie you purchase you get One (1) Free Chocolate Chip Cookie!!!!

Not sure what to surprise your Father with??

We have over 25 different pies to choose from! EVERYONE LOVES PIE!!! ESPECIALLY FATHERS!

Check out all the pies we have on our website at:
https://buttercupdairy.com/shop/

See you soon! Happy Father's Day!

We are closed for Easter Sunday. Make sure to stop in by 6 pm today for all your goodies!!
04/19/2025

We are closed for Easter Sunday. Make sure to stop in by 6 pm today for all your goodies!!

BEST PART OF PI DAY..... PIE FOR $3.14!!!!THE WORST PART??? IT'S ONLY ONE DAY!!!!BUT WAIT!!! WHAT IF.... WE CELEBRATE PI...
03/14/2025

BEST PART OF PI DAY..... PIE FOR $3.14!!!!

THE WORST PART??? IT'S ONLY ONE DAY!!!!

BUT WAIT!!! WHAT IF.... WE CELEBRATE PI DAY ALL WEEKEND?!?!?!!??

OK!!!! WE'LL DO IT!!!!

IN HONOR OF MATH.... OUR FRESH BAKED 8" DUTCH APPLE & 8" CHERRY PIES ARE ONLY $3.14 FROM FRIDAY THROUGH SUNDAY!! (3/14/25-3/16/25)

STOP IN AND ENJOY OUR TOP TIER SIGNATURE PIES AT BOTTOM BARREL PRICES!!!

Address

285 Boyle Road
Port Jefferson Station, NY
11776

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 6pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 6pm
Thursday 8am - 6pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 8am - 6pm
Sunday 8am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttercup's Dairy Store posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share