Sugar Loves Butter Baking Co.

12/14/2025

Cookies are ready for pick up! I do have a few extras if anyone missed out on oredering!

12/09/2025

Don't forget to order your cookies by Thursday!🥰🤤🍪

🎄 Gingerbread Crème Pies – $5
Big, soft, chewy gingerbread cookies bursting with warm holiday spices, sandwiched around a cloud of fluffy cream cheese filling. Rolled in festive red and green sprinkles for the perfect Christmas bite.

🍪 Sugar’s Chocolate Chip Cookies – $4
These are not your average chocolate chip cookies — they’re thick, buttery, perfectly chewy, and loaded with melty chocolate in every single bite. Truly the best you’ll ever taste. Full stop.

🎅 Santa’s Cookies – $4
Soft, fluffy vanilla cookies filled with classic holiday sweetness, topped with a swirl of silky vanilla buttercream and a shower of peppermint sprinkles. Santa-approved deliciousness.

⭐ Snoop’s Stoop Cookies – $4
A rich, chewy peanut butter chocolate chip cookie packed with semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips, then finished with a smooth peanut butter drizzle. Sweet, salty, and addictively good.

🍹 Butter Rum Cookies – $4
Made with Harvey’s iconic Butter Rum batter, these cookies are soft, buttery, and deeply cozy. Finished with a velvety butter rum frosting that melts in your mouth.

Orders due by 12/11/2025

Cookies will be ready for pick up 12/14

11/26/2025

🎄 Gingerbread Crème Pies – $5
Big, soft, chewy gingerbread cookies bursting with warm holiday spices, sandwiched around a cloud of fluffy cream cheese filling. Rolled in festive red and green sprinkles for the perfect Christmas bite.

🍪 Sugar’s Chocolate Chip Cookies – $4
These are not your average chocolate chip cookies — they’re thick, buttery, perfectly chewy, and loaded with melty chocolate in every single bite. Truly the best you’ll ever taste. Full stop.

🎅 Santa’s Cookies – $4
Soft, fluffy vanilla cookies filled with classic holiday sweetness, topped with a swirl of silky vanilla buttercream and a shower of peppermint sprinkles. Santa-approved deliciousness.

⭐ Snoop’s Stoop Cookies – $4
A rich, chewy peanut butter chocolate chip cookie packed with semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips, then finished with a smooth peanut butter drizzle. Sweet, salty, and addictively good.

🍹 Butter Rum Cookies – $4
Made with Harvey’s iconic Butter Rum batter, these cookies are soft, buttery, and deeply cozy. Finished with a velvety butter rum frosting that melts in your mouth.

Orders due by 12/11/2025

Cookies will be ready for pick up 12/14

10/20/2025

08/10/2025

Extras from a custom order! Carmel Latte Cheesecake and Dark Cherry Almond! So delish 6 for $24 🥰☕️🍒

07/03/2025

Lemon Blueberry Cupcakes with a beautifully fluffy lemon icing! 6 for $30 🍋🍋🫐🫐🍓

04/19/2025

Cookie orders are ready for pick up!

04/13/2025

Lunching with my boys!

04/13/2025

Easter cookies!! Orders due by 4/17, cookies will be ready for pick up Saturday evening 04/20.

1. Carrot Cake Cookies - soft carrot cake cookies with cream cheese frosting. $5

2. Lemon Bar Cookies - A buttery cookie topped with tart homemade lemon curd and a dusting of powder sugar. $5

3. The Drumstick - A chocolate chip waffle cone cookie stuffed with caramel, topped with more caramel, waffle cone pieces, chocolate, and peanuts! $5

4. Banana Bread cookies - soft yummy bread cookies with a cream cheese glaze and a brown brown sugar crumble.

04/13/2025

Don't forget to get your orders in!

Easter cookies!! Orders due by 4/17, cookies will be ready for pick up Saturday evening 04/20.

1. Carrot Cake Cookies - soft carrot cake cookies with cream cheese frosting. $5

2. Lemon Bar Cookies - A buttery cookie topped with tart homemade lemon curd and a dusting of powder sugar. $5

3. The Drumstick - A chocolate chip waffle cone cookie stuffed with caramel, topped with more caramel, waffle cone pieces, chocolate, and peanuts! $5

4. Banana Bread cookies - soft yummy bread cookies with a cream cheese glaze and a brown brown sugar crumble $5

04/06/2025

Easter cookies!! Orders due by 4/17, cookies will be ready for pick up Saturday evening 04/20.

1. Carrot Cake Cookies - soft carrot cake cookies with cream cheese frosting. $5

2. Lemon Bar Cookies - A buttery cookie topped with tart homemade lemon curd and a dusting of powder sugar. $5

3. The Drumstick - A chocolate chip waffle cone cookie stuffed with caramel, topped with more caramel, waffle cone pieces, chocolate, and peanuts! $5

4. Banana Bread cookies - soft yummy bread cookies with a cream cheese glaze and a brown brown sugar crumble $5

Drumstick pictured below