bettersweet bakery

bettersweet bakery welcome to bettersweet! here you can find our news, a la carte menus and general visuals for our work.

please note, we do not use Facebook Messenger to receive or accept incoming orders. instead, please email or give the bakery a call to inquire.

Scraps scraps and more scraps. We still have over 20 scraps here in our lobby. Let’s give them all a good home. We are d...
06/03/2026

Scraps scraps and more scraps. We still have over 20 scraps here in our lobby. Let’s give them all a good home. We are doing a flash sale for the next 2 hours! 3 for $10, so stop on by and load on up(they can also freeze😀).

Along side the scraps we have some eggs, earl grey cookies, cupcakes, and peanut squares available yet.

Feel free to stop by from 4-6.

Cash or check for payment.

If you do stop in ask Abe a homemade joke!

Speaking of extras, there are just a few from tonight that we wanted to tell you about.  Abe has offered to watch the sh...
06/03/2026

Speaking of extras, there are just a few from tonight that we wanted to tell you about. Abe has offered to watch the shop tomorrow, Wednesday 6/3 between 12-1 pm OR 4-6 pm.

Feel free to reserve any of the items below or just pop in to see what's in the lobby.

Payment is cash or check and we'll reply to you tomorrow morning to confirm what we have reserved for you as well as your total.

#1. SOLD OUT Sourdough bread. $8 per loaf, 4 available.

#2. SOLD OUT Gluten free almond flour chocolate chip cookie scones. $7 per baker's half dozen, 2 available.

#3. Peanut squares, $6 each, 5 available.

#4. Petite cake scraps, on sale for $4 each [normally $5 for this size], 22 available.

#5. Farm fresh organic eggs, on sale for $3 per dozen [normally $4], 9 available.

#6. Earl grey shortbread cookies, $5 per package, 8 available.

#7. 2 pack of regular size cupcakes, vanilla chocolate chip with vanilla creme filling and signature butter frosting. $7 per 2 pack, 1 available.

#8. 2 pack of regular size cupcakes, one each: vanilla with raspberry compote creme filling and signature butter frosting and vanilla chocolate chip with vanilla creme filling and signature butter frosting. $7 per 2 pack, 2 available.

It is simply the nicest summer evening… right now!   Come on out to Restoration Orchard Market for a lovely time of musi...
06/02/2026

It is simply the nicest summer evening… right now! Come on out to Restoration Orchard Market for a lovely time of music, a little shopping and of course, food… gelato, fresh cheese, sorghum, ginger beer and shrubs, tallow- just to name a few of the other incredible vendors.

Until 8 pm.

If you’re headed out to our pop-up event tonight, you’re in for some great bakery. Fresh sourdough bread, strawberry rhu...
06/02/2026

If you’re headed out to our pop-up event tonight, you’re in for some great bakery. Fresh sourdough bread, strawberry rhubarb brunch bread, cake scraps, Sammies, peanut squares- and a few other goodies too.

5-8 pm TONIGHT at Restoration Orchard Market in Sheboygan Falls.

Snag some dinner, peruse a few local vendors and stay for the live music.

It is definitely worth putting on your shoes and taking a Sunday morning drive out to the bakery.  Look at all these unr...
05/31/2026

It is definitely worth putting on your shoes and taking a Sunday morning drive out to the bakery. Look at all these unreserved goodies available!

Open till 10 am.

Remember that busy weekend we were headed into a few days ago?  Too busy to offer an a la carte menu?Well, since we have...
05/30/2026

Remember that busy weekend we were headed into a few days ago? Too busy to offer an a la carte menu?

Well, since we have a some extras from today’s event here’s a surprise a la carte menu for tomorrow morning, Sunday 5/31 with pick up from 8-10 am.

Simply reply to this post with the item number and quantity you’d like to reserve and we’ll reply to confirm and send you your total.

#1. Brunch bread: blueberry citrus. $8 per loaf, 3 available.

#2. ½ pound cinnamon honey nut granola. $5 per bag, 6 available.

#3. Earl grey tea cookies, $5 per package, 10 available.

#4. Lemon lavender shortbread cookies, $5 per package, 10 available.

#5. Abe’s chocolate chip sprinkle cookies, $5 per package, 5 available.

#6. Cake slice: signature carrot cake. $7 per slice, 7 available.

#7. 4 pack of Carl’s original sammies, $5 per container, 10 available.

#8. Petite cake scraps, $5 per scrap, 50 available [that is not a typo!].

#9. 4 pack of regular size cupcakes. $14 per box, 7 available. Each box will have one each of the following four flavor combinations:
~ lemon sage with blackberry compote crème filling and lemon butter frosting
~ vanilla bean with strawberry rhubarb compote crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting
~ Fresh orange with mixed berry compote crème filling and cream cheese frosting
~ French vanilla with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting

#10. 4 pack of regular size cupcakes. $14 per box, 9 available. Each box will have one each of following four flavor combinations:
~ Signature red velvet with semi sweet almond crème filling and cream cheese frosting
~ Signature razmon delight with lemon mascarpone crème filling and raspberry cream cheese frosting
~ Signature peanut butter chocolate chip with peanut butter crème filling and cocoa butter frosting
~ vanilla bean with strawberry rhubarb compote crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting

#11. 8” single layer cake: milk chocolate with caramel crème filling and signature butter frosting. Simplistic text available upon request. $40 per cake, 1 available.

#12. 8” single layer cake: lemon poppy seed with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting. Simplistic text available upon request. $40 per cake, 1 available.

#13. 6” single layer cake: French vanilla cake with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. Simplistic text available upon request. $25 per cake, 1 available.

#14. 6” single layer cake: fresh lemon with mixed berry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. Simplistic text available upon request. $25 per cake, 1 available.

#15. 6” single layer cake: amaretto with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting.

Bettersweet is on the go today!   You can find this tent out at Petal Palooza at Airy Point Farms until 3 pm today.  Hea...
05/30/2026

Bettersweet is on the go today! You can find this tent out at Petal Palooza at Airy Point Farms until 3 pm today. Head to their page for more details about the event.

And if you stop by, send us some feedback on the set up: bakery goodies along with our lobby market items.

Happy Thursday!It’s a very, very full weekend here at the bakery and we thought we’d bring you in on some of the excitem...
05/28/2026

Happy Thursday!
It’s a very, very full weekend here at the bakery and we thought we’d bring you in on some of the excitement. Find your favorite chair and something nourishing to sip on- there’s a lot to read in this post.

~ Stop by Airy Point Farms on Saturday from 10-3 pm for their incredible Petal Palooza event. Can you think of a better way to kick off the summer season? Plus the weather looks perfect for an outside strolling kind of day. You can stop by the Bettersweet tent and say hello to Keston and Abe, pick up some nature inspired treats as well as some farmer's market menu favorites. We’re also bringing some of our lobby market items with us: Bettersweet on the go. Read more about the event here: https://www.facebook.com/airypointfarms

~ Then, next Tuesday, June 2nd you can find us at Restoration Orchard & Market’s Blue Moon pop up from 5-8 pm. Once again you’ll be able to stop by the Bettersweet tent and greet Abe, who will be representing the bakery and selling some great treats. We’ll hop on FB again early next week to remind you of the event and let you know what our menu holds. Word on the street- bring your lawn chair and enjoy some live music and dinner once you’ve done a little perusing. You can take a look at this monthly event here: Restoration Orchards & Market

~ We do not have an official a la carte menu for tomorrow, but if enough extras are generated, we’ll let you know tomorrow evening about any extras available for Saturday morning.

~ We wanted to take a few moments to chat about the shift happening here at the bakery, starting next week. While we’ve appreciated the kindness that has been shown to us already around these changes, it's time for a little clarity.

1. We are NOT closing.

2. Our a la carte menu will be available when we have the capacity.

3. Our wedding options, services, and menu are not changing at this time.

4. Our website will look completely different in the next two weeks. All across the board things are simplifying, and our website will visually reflect this shift.

5. You can still order cakes!

Let’s look at #5 in a little more detail. For the past 20 years, when you’ve wanted to order a birthday cake, you’ve visited our cake menu, picked out a cake size and then built a flavor combination. You’ve chosen the cake flavor, filling flavor and frosting flavor. Then you’ve communicated on what you’ve wanted the cake to say, the colors you’ve wanted us to use when decorating and often sent over photos of an invite, or a similar cake design you’ve wanted or even left the decoration up to us. It’s truly been a custom order cake.

Here’s what will look different starting next week.

When you want to order a cake, you can visit the menu for the weekend you’re cake order is for, select a cake size and pick one of the 10 weekly rotating flavor combinations. Our decoration style is shifting to simple and pretty, so while we are not accepting inspiration photos or high level custom decorating requests, you can let us know what you'd like the cake to say as well as any color/s you'd like us to use.

The same concept applies to cupcake orders.

We appreciate the incredible outpouring of support to our entire family not only for the past 20 years of business in this community, but in particular, in this calendar year that has been... a difficult one.

[Anyone looking to sell a vehicle that can hold wedding cakes? All joking aside, DM or email us if you have any leads.]

In closing, thank you for allowing us to exist and create.

Thank you for supporting a local business run by a family that makes changes that reflect what that family needs.

Thank you for grace when we run out of time to reply to your email or forget your order was for 'today'.

Thank you for visiting us at other events and supporting other amazing creators, growers, farmers, and artisans. .

Thank you for your kindness to us as we chose to pivot rather than burn out.

Now, find your self a little sunshine before the stars come out and tell someone close to you that they matter.

And think about visiting Abe on Saturday or next Tuesday.

And... ask him about his new business venture this summer. :)

AVAILABLE QUANITIES UPDATED AT 6 AM ON SATURDAY. When we’re busy baking, there are always some extra goodies that find t...
05/22/2026

AVAILABLE QUANITIES UPDATED AT 6 AM ON SATURDAY.

When we’re busy baking, there are always some extra goodies that find their way onto our cooling rack.

Since there’s quite a few from today’s work, let’s make a little surprise a la carte menu for tomorrow, Saturday 5/23.

The goodies can be reserved ahead of time by simply replying to this post and letting us know the item number and quantity you’re interested in. [You can also send us an email if you’re not a FB user].

We’ll reply to confirm what is yours and let you know your total.

Payment is cash or check when you stop in.

Wander in’s are always welcome.

Any extras not reserved will be out in the lobby tomorrow morning.

All cakes [ #1- #10] will have simple red, white and blue florals unless you request a specific text and desired text color.

#1. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: milk chocolate cake with double chocolate fudge crème filling and cocoa butter frosting. $25, 1 available.

#2. 6” single layer cake: caramel cake with cheesecake crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting. $25, 1 available.

#3. 6” single layer cake: vanilla chocolate chip cake with double chocolate fudge crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25, 1 available.

#4. 6” single layer cake: May’s COTM- blueberry poppy seed with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $25, 1 available.

#5. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: vanilla bean cake with mixed berry compote crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $25, 1 available.

#6. 6” single layer cake: classic chocolate cake with cookies n’ crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25, 1 available.

#7. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: French vanilla cake with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25, 1 available.

#8. SOLD OUT. 8” single layer cake: signature Good AM- coffee chocolate cake with espresso crème filling and mocha butter frosting, finished with chocolate ganache frosting. $42 per cake, 1 available.

#9. 8” single layer cake: almond poppy seed cake with blueberry compote crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting. $40 per cake, 1 available.

#10. 8” single layer cake: French vanilla with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $40 per cake, 1 available.

#11. Farm fresh organic eggs. $4 per dozen, 5 available.

#12. SOLD OUT. Brunch bread: strawberry rhubarb streusel. $8 per loaf, 4 available.

#13. 4 pack of regular size cupcakes: signature S’mores- classic vanilla cupcake with marshmallow graham crème filling and cocoa butter frosting. $14 per box, 5 available.

#14. 4 pack of regular size cupcakes: $14 per box, 5 available. Each box will have one each of the following four flavor combinations:
~ lemon poppy seed with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting
~ white chocolate with raspberry cheesecake crème filling and signature butter frosting
~ vanilla sprinkle with vanilla crème filling and signature butter frosting
~ vanilla bean with mixed berry compote crème filling and cream cheese frosting

#15. 1 dozen mini cupcake box: $20 per box, 3 available. Each box will have four each of the following three signature flavors;
~ German chocolate
~ S’mores
~ Peanut butter chocolate chip nonsense

AVAILABLE QUANTITIES UPDATED AT 7 AM SUNDAY.Bakery friends, we just came in from a little outside time [gosh it was nice...
05/17/2026

AVAILABLE QUANTITIES UPDATED AT 7 AM SUNDAY.

Bakery friends, we just came in from a little outside time [gosh it was nice today!] and finished cleaning up from the weekend.

And… there are way to many goodies to just hang out in our fridge.
So, here’s a quick list of the treats, all on sale at least 25% off, and available to reserve to sneak in tomorrow morning between 8-10 am. [Sunday, 5/17]

We’ll do a quick round of replies to confirm anything reserved before the night ends and another check in the morning before we open.

Everything extra in the lobby tomorrow will also be 25% off, including cake scraps. Payment is cash or check please.

*Prices listed below reflect the sale price.

#1. 2 pack regular size cupcakes: razmon delight. Raspberry cupcake with lemon mascarpone crème filling and raspberry cream cheese frosting. $5.25 per package of 2, 1 available.

#1. 2 pack regular size cupcakes: French vanilla with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $5.25 per package of 2, 3 available.

#3. SOLD OUT. 2 pack regular size cupcakes: lemon poppy seed with lemon cheesecake crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $5.25 per package of 2, 4 available.

#4. SOLD OUT. 4 pack mini size cupcakes: signature carrot. $4.50 per container of 4, 3 available.

#5. 4 pack mini size cupcakes: sprinkle with cookies n’ crème filling and signature butter frosting. $4.50 per container of 4, 3 available.

#6. 6 pack of regular size cupcakes. $13.50 per box, 3 available. Each box will have two each of the following 3 flavor combinations:
~Classic chocolate with crushed chocolate crème filling and signature butter frosting
~ Signature S’mores- classic vanilla with marshmallow graham crème filling and cocoa butter frosting
~ Vanilla bean with salted caramel crème filling and cocoa butter frosting

#7. Cake slice: sprinkle cake with vanilla crème filling and signature butter frosting. $4.75 per slice, 4 available.

#8. SOLD OUT. Cake slice: May’s Cake of The Month: blueberry poppy seed with lemon curd crème and cream cheese frosting. $4.75 per slice, 3 available.

#9. Cake slice: French vanilla cake with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $4.75 per slice, 4 available.

#10. SOLD OUT. Cake slice: vanilla bean cake with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $4.75 per slice, 2 available.

#11. Cake slice: coffee espresso cake with salted caramel crème filling and mocha butter frosting . $4.75 per slice, 1 available.

#12. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer COTM blueberry poppy seed cake with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $18.75 per cake, 1 available.

#13. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer vanilla bean cake with strawberry rhubarb crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting. $18.75 per cake, 1 available.

#14. 6” single layer spice cake with cheesecake crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $18.75 per cake, 1 available.

#15. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer classic chocolate cake with double chocolate fudge crème filling and cocoa butter frosting. $18.75 per cake, 1 available.

#16. SOLD OUT. 8” single layer French vanilla cake with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $30 per cake, 1 available.

#17. SOLD OUT. 8” single layer signature red velvet cake with semi sweet almond crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $30 per cake, 1 available.

#18 . SOLD OUT. 8” single layer classic chocolate cake with mint crushed chocolate crème filling and signature butter frosting. $30 per cake, 1 available.

#19. Farm fresh organic eggs. $3 per dozen, 2 available.

Address

N6947 Jennifer Drive
Plymouth, WI
53073

Opening Hours

Thursday 4pm - 6pm
Friday 12pm - 6pm

Telephone

+1 920-893-0617

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when bettersweet bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to bettersweet bakery:

Share

Category