bettersweet bakery

Home
United States
Plymouth, WI
bettersweet bakery

Call Directions Website Contact the business

welcome to bettersweet! here you can find our news, a la carte menus and general visuals for our work.

please note, we do not use Facebook Messenger to receive or accept incoming orders. instead, please email or give the bakery a call to inquire.

10/15/2026

Happy Thursday!

We’re looking forward to another weekend full of weddings, fresh apples, fall colors and hopefully a little sunshine. And if that’s not a full enough list, there’s a la carte happening tomorrow at the bakery too.

You can reserve any of the goodies below by simply reply to this post with the item number and quantity you’re looking for.

We’ll reply later this evening or tomorrow morning to confirm what is yours as well as your total.

Feel free to email your reservation as well.

A couple logistical reminders:
~ Please only reserve items if you can come during the pick up window: Friday, 10/16 between 2-6 pm.
~ Cash or check for payment.
~ Wander ins are always welcome-you don’t have to have anything reserved to stop in.

#1. Cinnamon honey nut granola: simple ingredients and a lot of flavor! Rolled oats, coconut oil, honey, spices, pecans, almonds, sea salt and well… goodness. 1 pound bag, $9- 5 available.

#2. Cake slice: signature carrot cake. $8 per slice, 10 available.

#3. Cake slice: French vanilla cake with raspberry and cookies n crème filling and signature butter frosting. $7 per slice, 4 available.

#4. Cake slice: fresh lemon with blueberry compote crème filling and almond butter frosting. $7 per slice, 4 available.

#5. Brunch bread: cherry almond poppy seed. $8 per loaf, 8 available.

#6. Brunch bread: apple cinnamon streusel. $8 per loaf, 8 available.

#7. Cake scraps! $6 each, 22 available. While we can not accept specific flavor requests, you can ask for no nuts, coffee or adult flavors.

#8. Carl’s original sammes: two softer chocolate cookies are filled with our signature butter frosting to create our iconic sandwich cookie. $5 per container of 4, 8 available.

#9. Salted chocolate chip cookies: $6 per container of 7, 4 available.

All cakes [ #10- #15] are can be reserved with requested text added. Please mention the text and a text color in your reply. If no text is requested, each cake will be simply decorated in a fall colors.

#10. 6” single layer cake: lemon poppy seed with raspberry compote crème filling and cream cheese frosting $25 per cake, 2 available.

#11. 6” single layer cake: milk chocolate with peanut butter crème filling and cocoa butter frosting. $25 per cake, 2 available.

#12. 6” single layer cake: vanilla sprinkle with crushed chocolate crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting$25 per cake, 2 available.

#13. 6” single layer cake: French vanilla with salted caramel crème filling and bourbon butter frosting. $25 per cake, 2 available.

#14. 6” single layer cake: signature red velvet with semi sweet almond crème filling and cream cheese frosting. $25 per cake, 2 available.

#15. 6" single layer GLUTEN FREE chocolate cake with raspberry compote creme filling and signature butter frosting. $28 per cake, 1 available.

10/11/2026

40 plus scraps, apple tree backdrops, a cool breeze with sunshine and a lot of delicious fall flavors.

Happening now till 3 pm today out at Restoration Garden Orchard Market.

:).

10/10/2026

It might be a tad warm for October today, but when we’ve wrapped up our wedding deliveries- we’ll be turning to fall flavors in preparation for tomorrow’s pop up event. Come on out to Restoration Orchards for some great autumn fun.. and food!

See you there tomorrow.

10/03/2026

Feeling sad you weren’t able to snag a smash burger last night? Or bummed it’s the end of Buttery Buns’s grilling season? You’re in luck! He took his wares to the road again and is set up today over the lunch hour out at Airy Point Farms again!

11-2 pm- make it brunch, lunch or an early dinner.

While you’re there, check out the beautiful display of pumpkins, gourds, squash and of course- flowers.

10/02/2026

Your dinner awaits!

There’s still plenty of time to head over to the bakery patio for a made to order smash burger from Buttery Buns.

So so so so soooooo good. You don’t need to cook tonight. Abe has you covered.

10/01/2026

AVAILABLE QUANITITES UPDATED AT 11 AM FRIDAY.

It’s officially time.

Clear your calendar for tomorrow evening and plan to stop out at the bakery between 3-7 pm [please note the time change- to accommodate anyone who has dinner a little later].

You can experience a smash burger from Buttery Buns right here on the bakery patio as well as popping inside for some dessert. In fact, you can reserve items from our a la carte menu below and plan to have goodies for the weekend.

And if that’s not enough goodness for one Friday evening, you can also reserve a loaf of sourdough so you’ll be able to have grill cheese with your Saturday evening soup or even a blt with the last of your garden tomatoes. Who doesn’t love October??!

Reminder of the a la carte details:
~ Pick up tomorrow, 10/2 from 3-7 pm.
~ Please make sure you can make that time window if you’re going to put items on reserve.
~ Simply reply to this post with the item number and quantity you’d like to reserve. We’ll send a confirmation reply to your request along with your total.
~ Don’t have a Facebook account but someone share’s the menu with you? Feel free to email your request in.
~ Payment is cash or check.
~ Wander in’s [without reservations] are always welcome.
~ All available cake scraps will indeed be in the lobby.

#1. Cake slice: signature carrot. $7 per slice, 4 available.

#2. Cake slice: signature razmon delight- raspberry cake with lemon mascarpone crème filling and lemon cream cheese frosting. $7 per slice, 7 available.

#3. Cake slice: coffee espresso cake with chocolate hazelnut crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting. $7 per slice, 1 available.

#4. Cake slice: French vanilla with cherry and lemon curd crème fillings, signature butter frosting. $7 per slice, 2 available.

#5. Brunch bread: cinnamon apple streusel. $8 per loaf, 3 available.

#6. Brunch bread: pumpkin chocolate chip. $8 per loaf, 4 available.

#7. Brunch bread: lemon poppy seed blueberry. $8 per loaf, 2 available.

#8. GLUTEN FREE regular size cupcakes. $7 per 2 pack, 3 available. Vanilla bean cupcakes with double chocolate fudge crème filling and vanilla bean butter frosting.

#9. SOLD OUT. 4 pack of regular size cupcakes: the wait is over. Apple pie delight! Golden vanilla cupcakes with apple pie crème filling [this is apple pie baked without a crust, cooled and folded into our vanilla crème] and cinnamon butter frosting. $15 per 4 pack, 12 available.

#10. 1 dozen mini size cupcakes. $18 per box, 1 available. Each box will have four each of the following three flavor combinations:
~ fresh lemon with lemon curd crème filling and cream cheese frosting
~ almond poppy seed [nut free] with double chocolate fudge crème filling and cocoa butter frosting
~ white chocolate with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting

All cakes [ #11- #15] can be reserved with a simplistic text. Please provide text and text color in your reply. If you do not specify, all cakes will be simply decorated with a fallish colors and décor.

#11. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: classic chocolate with cherry chocolate chip crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25 per cake, 2 available.

#12. 6” single layer cake: coffee espresso with salted caramel crème filling and mocha butter frosting. $25 per cake, 1 available.

#13. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: French vanilla with raspberry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25 per cake, 4 available.

#14. SOLD OUT. 6” single layer cake: signature razmon delight- raspberry cake with lemon mascarpone crème filling and lemon cream cheese frosting. $25 per cake, 1 available.

#15. 6” single layer cake: fall sprinkle with cookies n’ crème filling and signature butter frosting. $25 per cake, 1 available.

#16. SOLD OUT. Sourdough! Freshly baked on Friday made with organic flour, salt, starter, water and love. $8 per loaf, 20 available.

09/27/2026

It took Abe’s mom a whole summer to finally try the breakfast smasher.

Verdict: why in the world did I wait so long???

Get your buttery buns out to Airy Point today. Smashburgers until 2 ish

09/26/2026

Happening now at Airy Point Farm and their incredibly curated pumpkin patch. Abe’s grilling till about 1:30 today, and then back again tomorrow over the lunch hour as well.

Head on over. You’ll be glad you did. (And so will your stomach).

09/25/2026

Good Evening! We ended up with just a few goodies from the Restoration Orchards event [did you know they have about 150 different apple varieties growing in their orchard? And one variety that is the oldest known in America??? If you haven’t visited, you should. Especially since they have some great events coming up.]

We’ll also have some extras generated from our wedding baking tomorrow, so here’s a SURPRISE small but delicious a la carte for tomorrow.

Simply reply to the post to let us know the item number and quantity you’d be interested in and we’ll reply early tomorrow morning to let you know what we have reserved for you as well as your total.

Payment when you stop in is cash or check.

Hours tomorrow, Friday 9/25 will be 2-6 pm.

Wander ins always welcome.

Don’t forget that next week, we’ll have a full a la carte menu as well as Abe grilling up smash burgers on the bakery patio. [And if you don’t want to wait until next Friday for a burger, he’ll be out at Airy Point Farm this Saturday and Sunday from 10-1 or 2 pm cooking up deliciousness during their pumpkin patch weekend.

#1. Gluten free, refined sugar free almond flour chocolate chip cookie scones. $7.50 per half dozen package, 7 available.

#2. Carl’s sammies, original version. $5 per container of 4, 8 available.

#3. Pumpkin chocolate chip brunch bread. $8 per loaf, 6 available.

#4. Triple berry brunch bread. $8 per loaf, 4 available.

#5. Cake scraps! $6 each or tomorrow’s special- buy 4 receive one on the house. 36 available. Sorry, no specific flavor requests- but you can trade out what we set aside with any out in the lobby market space.

#6. ½ dozen mini cupcake box, $9 each 6 available. Each box will have three each of the following two flavor combinations:
~ signature razmon delight; raspberry cupcake with lemon mascarpone crème filling and raspberry cream cheese frosting
~ vanilla bean with mixed berry compote crème filling and signature butter frosting

#7. Salted chocolate chip cookies, $6 per baker’s half dozen container, 4 available.

Any other goodies available will be in the lobby when you stop in.

09/24/2026

We are almost finished setting up our evening at Restoration Orchards and Market for tonight’s event. Live music, dinner from the Harvest Street food truck, string lights in the orchard, local vendors and of course- dessert from us!

5-8 pm. See you soon.

Address

N6947 Jennifer Drive
Plymouth, WI
53073

Telephone

+1 920-893-0617

Website

http://www.bettersweetbakery.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when bettersweet bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to bettersweet bakery:

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Plymouth?