My Sweet Valentine Bakery

My Sweet Valentine Bakery Mother-Daughter duo. 🩷
Custom cakes, cupcakes, and much more for any occasion! 🍰
Pickerington and Buckeye Lake Pick Up 📍
📩 Fill out an order form

A little farm fun for the sweetest 3rd birthday! 🚜🌾🤎This custom cake and matching sugar cookies were made for a little o...
09/06/2026

A little farm fun for the sweetest 3rd birthday! 🚜🌾🤎

This custom cake and matching sugar cookies were made for a little one’s big day, complete with tractors, horses, dirt fields and all the farm details.

The cookies included personalized age cookies, horse cookies and little fence + field designs to tie everything together.

Such a fun set to make! 🤎

Thank you for choosing My Sweet Valentine Bakery to be part of such a special celebration!

A little cupcake lineup from this weekend 🤍🍋 Lemon Blueberry — lemon cupcake + lemon buttercream + fresh blueberries🍫 Ge...
09/06/2026

A little cupcake lineup from this weekend 🤍

🍋 Lemon Blueberry — lemon cupcake + lemon buttercream + fresh blueberries
🍫 German Chocolate — chocolate cupcake + chocolate buttercream
❤️ Red Velvet Chip — red velvet chocolate chip cupcake + cheesecake buttercream + red velvet crumbs

Three very different flavors, but I honestly don’t know which one I’d pick! 🧁

Thank you for supporting our little bakery! ❤️

A little under-the-sea sweetness for a 2nd birthday! 🧜‍♀️💜These mermaid cookies turned out SO cute with all the pastel p...
09/04/2026

A little under-the-sea sweetness for a 2nd birthday! 🧜‍♀️💜

These mermaid cookies turned out SO cute with all the pastel pinks, purples and blues, sparkles and sprinkles. The perfect little addition to a magical mermaid birthday party! ✨

Thank you for letting us be part of your little one’s special day! 💕

A little sage green + gold for this sweet engagement celebration 🤍Sugar cookies and buttercream cupcakes, all made to ma...
08/31/2026

A little sage green + gold for this sweet engagement celebration 🤍

Sugar cookies and buttercream cupcakes, all made to match the party colors. I’m loving how this set turned out — especially those buttercream roses!

Congratulations to the happy couple! 💍✨

A little sunshine for the sweetest baby sprinkle ☀️💛This two-tier cake was covered in dainty daisies, sunshine details, ...
08/30/2026

A little sunshine for the sweetest baby sprinkle ☀️💛

This two-tier cake was covered in dainty daisies, sunshine details, and the prettiest gold “A Little Ray of Sunshine is on the Way” topper. Such a sweet theme to celebrate a little one on the way! 🌼

We loved making this one! 💛

Made this fun sports cookie cake for a birthday this week and I’m honestly obsessed with how it turned out! 🏈⚾️🏀 The col...
08/30/2026

Made this fun sports cookie cake for a birthday this week and I’m honestly obsessed with how it turned out! 🏈⚾️🏀 The colors, the little sports details, and of course a giant chocolate chip cookie… what’s not to love?!

I love getting to make these custom orders and seeing all the different ideas people come up with. ❤️

Happy birthday to this little sports fan!

08/25/2026

Wedding cake tasting day! 🤍

We made up four 4” cakes for a wedding tasting so our couple could try a few different flavor combinations before deciding on their wedding cake.

Red Velvet Chip + Cheesecake Buttercream
German Chocolate + Chocolate Ganache
Almond White + Almond Buttercream
Lemon + Lemon Buttercream

These 4” cakes are the perfect size for wedding tastings and give you the chance to try different flavors and buttercream combinations before the big day!

Now to pick a favorite… that’s the hard part!

08/17/2026

A little Scarlet & Gray celebration for a proud Ohio State grad! ❤️🩶

We loved making this special cupcake order featuring two Buckeye favorites:

🌰 Buckeye Cupcakes — chocolate cake with smooth, creamy peanut butter frosting.

❤️🩶 Scarlet & Gray Cupcakes — French vanilla cake with buttercream frosting and classic Scarlet & Gray sprinkles.

Perfect for celebrating a Buckeye who just graduated from The Ohio State University! We hope these made the celebration a little sweeter. 🌰❤️🩶

Okay, but these lemon cookies deserve their own moment. 🍋You probably can’t even tell from the pictures that they’re lem...
08/15/2026

Okay, but these lemon cookies deserve their own moment. 🍋

You probably can’t even tell from the pictures that they’re lemon, but one bite and you definitely can. They’re soft, buttery, bright, and SO good.

We did three different versions:
• Lemon sugar
• Lemon with cheesecake buttercream
• Lemon with lemon glaze

And I honestly don’t know which one I’d pick. Each one has something completely different going on, but they’re all seriously delicious.

If you love lemon desserts, these are for you.

08/11/2026

somewhere between sugar & sea

Address

Pickerington, OH

Telephone

+16145467317

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sweet Valentine Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Sweet Valentine Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category