My Sweet Valentine Bakery

Call Website Contact the business

My Sweet Valentine Bakery Mother-Daughter duo. 🩷
Custom cakes, cupcakes, and much more for any occasion! 🍰
Pickerington and Buckeye Lake Pick Up 📍
📩 Fill out an order form

10/31/2026

Happy Halloween from My Sweet Valentine Bakery! 🎃🧡

We hope everyone has a fun, safe Halloween filled with lots of treats, sweet memories, and a little extra sugar!

Thank you for continuing to support our little bakery. We appreciate every order, share, and kind word more than you know!

Have a spooktacular Halloween! 👻🍬

10/30/2026

A pretty little cake for a very special 21st birthday! 🖤

Loving all the little details on this one. The bows, the hearts, and the classic black and white combo made this one so fun to put together!

Happy 21st Birthday! 🎂

SWEET TREATS & FIRE PIT NIGHTS! Good food, great friends, and delicious cupcakes make the perfect recipe for a party! ❤️...
10/25/2026

SWEET TREATS & FIRE PIT NIGHTS!

Good food, great friends, and delicious cupcakes make the perfect recipe for a party! ❤️

We had the pleasure of making these yummy cupcakes for a fun Food & Social gathering around the fire pit.

🍫 S’mores Cupcakes — chocolate cupcakes topped with chocolate frosting, toasted marshmallows, chocolate chips, and graham crackers. All the flavors of a campfire favorite in one delicious bite!

🍓 Strawberry Shortcake Cupcakes — fluffy cupcakes topped with swirls of creamy frosting and sweet, juicy strawberries!

Whatever you’re planning, let us help make your event a little sweeter! 🤍

Happy 50th wedding anniversary to the cute couple!
10/24/2026

Happy 50th wedding anniversary to the cute couple!

🦃🍂 THANKSGIVING ORDERS ARE OPEN! 🍂🦃Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and we’re taking orders for all your holiday...
10/22/2026

🦃🍂 THANKSGIVING ORDERS ARE OPEN! 🍂🦃

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and we’re taking orders for all your holiday sweets! 🧡 Let us take a little baking off your plate this year!

🥧 Thanksgiving Menu

🧁 Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes – Cheesecake-flavored frosting | $25/dozen

🍰 Pumpkin Roll – Cheesecake-flavored frosting | $15 each

🦃 6” Turkey Cake – Two layers with a cute Thanksgiving design | $25

🍁 Frosted Sugar Cookies – Buttercream frosting | $20/dozen

🍪 12” Cookie Cake | $25

🍫 Buckeyes | $12/dozen

Whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving or just need something sweet to bring along, we’ve got you covered! 🧡

📩 fill out a form on our page to place your order! We recommend ordering early so you can get your favorites!

10/16/2026

Twenty One Pilots cookies for a birthday celebration before their home show at The Shoe this Saturday! ❤️💛💙

How fun is this?! Who’s heading to the show this weekend?! 🙌🏼

Thanks for letting My Sweet Valentine Bakery be a little part of the celebration! 🖤

Pretty in purple 💜🌸 Buttercream roses, vintage piping, and the sweetest details for a special 80th birthday!Custom cakes...
10/15/2026

Pretty in purple 💜🌸 Buttercream roses, vintage piping, and the sweetest details for a special 80th birthday!

Custom cakes are one of our favorite things to make. Thank you for letting My Sweet Valentine Bakery be part of your celebrations! 🎂

10/15/2026
🤍 A beautiful two-tier wedding cake for a special day! 💍This cake featured an 8” white almond cake with raspberry fillin...
10/12/2026

🤍 A beautiful two-tier wedding cake for a special day! 💍

This cake featured an 8” white almond cake with raspberry filling on top and a 10” spice cake on the bottom, finished with classic white buttercream and delicate rustic details.

Thank you so much for choosing My Sweet Valentine Bakery to be a small part of your big day! Wishing you both a lifetime of love, happiness, and the sweetest memories together. Congratulations to the happy couple! 🤍✨

10/04/2026

A little pink vintage birthday cake for Rayne’s 7th birthday! 🎀💗

We had so much fun with all the pretty pinks, vintage piping, roses, pearls and that sweet little bow! 🥰

Happy 7th Birthday, Rayne! We hope you had the sweetest birthday! 💕🎂

✨ Made by My Sweet Valentine Bakery ✨

Looking for a custom cake for your next celebration? Send us a message — we’d love to make something special for you! 💗

Address

Pickerington, OH

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sweet Valentine Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Sweet Valentine Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share