Pennies From Heaven Bakery

Pennies From Heaven Bakery My in home bakery specializes in vintage cookie recipes and other sweet treats.

06/02/2026

I am closed until June 12th, but will be checking messages.

05/10/2026

I am booked full until June 11th, but if I have extra bakery from orders I will post here. 🩷🩷

05/07/2026

For those who are picking up your bakery this morning. There is an accident at westbound highway 16 and Capital. (8am Thursday) Traffic is a mess in the area.

05/03/2026

Experimenting with different cinnamon roll recipes 😋 Stay tuned for new menu items coming soon 🥰

04/30/2026

I have a variety of cookies and bars ready for pick up anytime on Friday or Thus weekend.

🍪 chocolate chip cookies 1 dozen $12 ⚡️sale

🍥 1 dozen sugar cookies
$10 ⚡️sale

🍒 1 dozen cherry white chocolate chip cookies
$12 ⚡️sale

🍪 oatmeal butterscotch cookies (I only have 10 left, but will make more on Friday) $8

A bakers dozen of peanut butter bars
$12 ⚡️sale

*Pewaukee porch pick up, cash or venmo.

*Message me here, or text order to 414-477-1400

04/30/2026

Address

Pewaukee, WI

Telephone

+14144771400

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pennies From Heaven Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pennies From Heaven Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category