Pennies From Heaven Bakery

09/01/2026

This week's specials are:

Cherry white chocolate chip cookies, made with Door County cherries 🍒
$12 for 1 dozen

Brownies
8x8 tray $10

Brownies!!

08/31/2026

Weekend bakery porch pop up shop will be starting again, as soon as the weather starts to cool down.
I will post the schedule later this week.

08/31/2026

Fall and Halloween Menu 👻🎃👻

🧙‍♀️ Chocolate chip cookies
with or without walnuts
$15 per dozen
$16 per dozen w/nuts

👻 Peanut butter kiss
cookies
$15 per dozen

🎃 Toffee bars
$15 per dozen

🧙‍♀️ Peanut butter bars
$15 per dozen

👻 Basic frosted cutouts for Fall or Halloween
$20 per dozen
$12 for 6

🎃 Cherry white chocolate
chip cookies made with
Door County cherries 🍒
$15 per dozen

🧙‍♀️ Cupcakes 🧁 🧁🧁
Chocolate, white, or
yellow with vanilla
buttercream frosting or
chocolate buttercream
frosting
$30 for 1 dozen
$15 for 6
$10 for 4

👻 Pumpkin bars with
cream cheese frosting
(Limited time only)
8x8 tray $15
13×9 tray $20

🎃 M&M Sugar Cookies
$15 per dozen

👻 White chocolate chip cookies with Macadamia nuts
$15 per dozen

🎃 Double Chocolate peanut butter chip cookies
$15 per dozen

👻 Bon bon cookies with fall themed frosting
$15 per dozen

🧙‍♀️ More items will be added, watch for specials and
flash sales.

👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻👻

08/31/2026

My fall menu goes live tonight!! Even in 90 degree temperatures 🤣

08/29/2026

Late night order prepping 🤩

08/26/2026

Door County cherry 🍒 white chocolate chip cookies on sale this week!
$12 for a bakers dozen

08/25/2026

This week only, order by Sunday 5pm for pick up anytime this week or next week.

08/24/2026

My messages from messenger and market place have been recovered. I am slowly getting back to everyone. I had over 1,000 spam or fake messages come over. I am anticipating another day or 2 for answering everyone back. I am so sorry for the delay. This has been a nightmare 😫

08/23/2026

I will be closed until Sunday night, and should have phone and internet back up on Tuesday. My messenger messages keep disappearing.

08/19/2026

I am a little behind responding to messages, this has been the year of everything breaking 🙄 New cell phone arriving on Wednesday.