Itsa Cookie

Drop cookies in fun and seasonal flavors. Baked in Pensacola, Florida.
(1)

05/04/2026

A little late this month but here we are again. Come find your favorite cookies at and this month.

We're especially excited to welcome back to Pensacola our friends , who will be playing at The Handlebar on the 19th.

Come say hey. 💜

🍪 Can't make it to a market? You can now order cookies online and have cookies shipped to you. Link in bio.

03/31/2026

April is filling up with good shows and plenty of cookies. Find us at and throughout the month with a mix of familiar favorites and a few flavors tied to the bands we’re celebrating. Come say hey. 💜

03/28/2026

Our new Sixth Sense Cookie was inspired by the sound and spirit of the band Retirement Party. The energetic, earthy feel in their music became the starting point for this pistachio rose cookie.

Rose brings a gentle floral sweetness, while pistachio and subtle caramel flavors create a bite that feels vibrant yet grounded like their music.

Catch live Wednesday, April 1, at with and . See y'all there.

📷:

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Saturday 3/28 | 9-2
🍪 Tuesday 3/31 | 6-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Wednesday 4/1 | 6:30-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 4/4 | 9-2 Palafox Market

03/22/2026

Some cookies come and go, but a few stick around because people keep coming back for them. Our Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie is one of those.

This cookie is the kind of flavor that feels familiar the first time you try it. Bright and just a bit indulgent, it’s easy to see why it’s become one of our most well-loved cookies.

If you’ve had one before, you already know. And if you haven’t yet, this is a good place to start.

📷:

Upcoming Pop-ups:

🍪 Saturday 3/28 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Tuesday 3/31 | 6-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Wednesday 4/1 | 6:30-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 4/4 | 9-2 Palafox Market

03/03/2026

Your favorite cookies are back at and this month, as well as supporting this year's event this coming Saturday.

New band cookie releasing later this month. (Any guess who? 👀)

Ps. It's my birthday this month, so come say hey. 💜

02/14/2026

Our new The Dennis Finger Cookie gets its flavor inspiration from the driven musical style of southeast emo favorites Dear Cincinnati.

Pretzels and cinnamon chips mix together to mirror the way different lines in their songs cross and connect, and a bit of salted caramel brings a steady sweetness that carries the whole bite.

Catch at this Wednesday 2/18 as they begin their mini tour through Florida.

📷:

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Tuesday 2/17 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Wednesday 2/18 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 2/28 | 9-2 Palafox Market

02/08/2026

Our Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie is proof that some pairings are perfect for a reason. Built around one of the most recognizable childhood flavor combos, this cookie transforms it into a handheld dessert instead.

This cookie brings back the simple, familiar flavors many of us grew up with and transforms those early snack memories into dessert form. It’s the perfect pick for sharing with someone you love, or claiming as your own favorite combo.

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Monday 2/9 | 6-8 The Handlebar
🍪 Tuesday 2/10 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Thursday 2/12 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Tuesday 2/17 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Wednesday 2/18 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 2/28 | 9-2 Palafox Market

02/03/2026

February is shaping up to be a fun month for cookies and shows. Catch us at Palafox Market and at The Handlebar, bringing the flavors that made people fall in love with what we do.

Please note there is no Palafox Market on February 14 due to the downtown Mardi Gras parade, and we will also miss the one on February 21 as we head to Arizona to enjoy a music festival.

For those curious, we do have a few new band cookies coming soon, including one releasing this month. Stay tuned for the next flavor collab.

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Saturday 2/7 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Saturday 2/7 | 8-10 The Handlebar
🍪 Monday 2/9 | 6-8 The Handlebar
🍪 Tuesday 2/10 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Thursday 2/12 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Tuesday 2/17 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Wednesday 2/18 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 2/28 | 9-2 Palafox Market

01/27/2026

's photos tell the darker side of live music, where emotion and movement collide. She documents the energy of the room as it unfolds, preserving the messier moments that make a show feel real.

Sara’s Cookie carries that same balance. Strawberry and peach flavors blend seamlessly, creating something soft and familiar. And of course just like last year, her cookie is a vivid pink, inspired by her iconic hair.

This cookie is a part of our January collaboration with Pensacola band photographers who help document the local music scene. A portion of sales from these cookies supports the Blues Angel Music Foundation and their work in music education and community outreach.

🍪📷:
🎵📷: by
🎵📷: by
🎵📷: by
👤📷:

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Saturday 1/31 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Saturday 1/31 | 6-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 2/7 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Tuesday 2/10 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Thursday 2/12 | 7-9 The Handlebar

01/25/2026

approaches the Pensacola music scene with an eye for more than what’s happening on stage. His photos pull in the atmosphere, the people, and the in-between moments that make a show feel alive, capturing the raw energy that exists beyond the performance itself.

Andrew’s Cookie leans into that same intensity. Crunchy pretzels, dark chocolate chips, and coconut bring sweet and salty together, while jalapeño adds a sharp kick that keeps things interesting. It’s not subtle, and that’s the point.

This cookie is a part of our January collaboration with Pensacola band photographers who help document the local music scene. A portion of sales from these cookies supports the Blues Angel Music Foundation and their work in music education and community outreach.

🍪📷:
🎵📷: by
🎵📷: by
🎵📷: by
👤📷:

Upcoming Pop-ups:
🍪 Saturday 1/24 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 1/31 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Saturday 1/31 | 6-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Saturday 2/7 | 9-2 Palafox Market
🍪 Tuesday 2/10 | 7-9 The Handlebar
🍪 Thursday 2/12 | 7-9 The Handlebar

Address

Pensacola, FL

Website

http://instagram.com/itsacookiebakery

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Itsa Cookie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Pensacola?