Butterball's Bakery

Butterball's Bakery Cakes, Cupcakes and More! Self taught baker and looking to share my love for baking with you.

There’s just something special about sourdough!!Not only is it packed with amazing flavor, but the natural fermentation ...
06/01/2026

There’s just something special about sourdough!!
Not only is it packed with amazing flavor, but the natural fermentation process can make it easier to digest, support gut health, and help break down gluten and sugars better than traditional breads. Plus… nothing beats that homemade taste and texture! 🥖✨
Sourdough is so much more than just bread!
Featuring our SOURDOUGH PIZZA CRUST!�Crispy, chewy, flavorful, and the perfect base for homemade pizza night.

We have some goodies available for you!! 🎉🎊 We have plenty of lemon poppyseed muffins available! 🍋 🤤 These super soft mu...
05/30/2026

We have some goodies available for you!! 🎉🎊 We have plenty of lemon poppyseed muffins available! 🍋 🤤 These super soft muffins just burst with lemon in each bite! Only $2.50 each. We also have a tin of 6 cinnamon rolls available! The cinnamon rolls can come with or without cream cheese frosting. If you’re interested in these delicious items, either leave a comment below or send us a message☺️

Double the cakes, double the celebration, and double the sweetness! 🎉🎂These custom cakes were created for a set of twins...
05/29/2026

Double the cakes, double the celebration, and double the sweetness! 🎉🎂
These custom cakes were created for a set of twins celebrating their 21st birthday!!
📚 For the future teacher: a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting inspired by her journey into education.
⚾️ For the Yankees fan and criminal justice major: a rich chocolate cake with vanilla frosting featuring his favorite team.

I love creating cakes that reflect each person’s personality and passions while still tying everything together for such a special celebration. Thank you for trusting me to be part of your big day!

🖤💛 Sweet celebrations for a special little guy! 🚜🎉This custom 2nd birthday chocolate chip cookie cake was made with rich...
05/27/2026

🖤💛 Sweet celebrations for a special little guy! 🚜🎉

This custom 2nd birthday chocolate chip cookie cake was made with rich chocolate frosting, vanilla buttercream details, and a construction theme perfect for the birthday boy! Complete with a hand-piped excavator
Thank you for letting me be a part of such a fun celebration!

Hi all! Here’s this weeks line up! 🤩☺️Our pick of the week is strawberry rhubarb cookies! 🍓🍪 These, soft and chewy cooki...
05/26/2026

Hi all! Here’s this weeks line up! 🤩☺️

Our pick of the week is strawberry rhubarb cookies! 🍓🍪 These, soft and chewy cookies just melt in your mouth with a sweet and tangy strawberry rhubarb jam swirled through it. You have to try these cookies! $2.50 each

Another new item this week! Lemon poppyseed muffins! These muffins just bust with lemon flavor and are a great way to start your day or end it!😁 $2.50 each.

We will still have our chocolate chip cookies, regular cinnamon rolls and sourdough bread. Prices will be listed below 👇🏻 Thank you everyone!! ☺️

Cinnamon rolls:
WITH CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
- 4 count: $8
- 6 count: $12
- 8 count: $16
- 12 count: $24
WITHOUT CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
- 4 count: $6
- 6 count: $8
- 8 count: $12
- 12 count: $18

Chocolate chip cookies: 🍪
- 4 count: $6
- 6 count: $8
- 8 count: $12
- 12 count: $18

Sandwich loaf: $8
Artisan style: $10
Cinnamon loaf: $12

Hi all! We hope that you have had an amazing weekend and a great Memorial Day 🇺🇸❤️Butterball’s Bakery took this weekend ...
05/25/2026

Hi all! We hope that you have had an amazing weekend and a great Memorial Day 🇺🇸❤️Butterball’s Bakery took this weekend off, but will be back this week with some amazing items!! So keep an eye out for tomorrows post!☺️ Thank you everyone!

“Baby in Bloom!” 🌸🧁These floral cupcakes were made for the sweetest baby shower celebration, honoring a little one on th...
05/18/2026

“Baby in Bloom!” 🌸🧁

These floral cupcakes were made for the sweetest baby shower celebration, honoring a little one on the way!
Every cupcake is handmade with love and designed to match your special occasion perfectly. 💕✨ Thank you for choosing Butterball’s Bakery🤗

Another custom cake out the door ! ☘️🏀Had so much fun creating this Boston Celtics-themed cake for a special customer. T...
05/12/2026

Another custom cake out the door ! ☘️🏀

Had so much fun creating this Boston Celtics-themed cake for a special customer. This one was a blast to bring to life!

Thank you for supporting my small bakery and trusting me to be part of your celebrations. 💚
Need a custom cake for your next birthday, party, or event? Message me to get on the schedule!

Don’t forget to check out this weeks items!! You won’t regret trying the strawberry cinnamon rolls!🍓😊
05/12/2026

Don’t forget to check out this weeks items!! You won’t regret trying the strawberry cinnamon rolls!🍓😊

Hi all! Here’s this weeks line up! 🤩☺️Our pick of the week is strawberries and cream cinnamon rolls!🍓🤤 Our delicious sou...
05/12/2026

Hi all! Here’s this weeks line up! 🤩☺️

Our pick of the week is strawberries and cream cinnamon rolls!🍓🤤 Our delicious sourdough cinnamon rolls, but filled with a sweet and juicy strawberry jam. Then topped with a strawberry glaze. $3.00 each.

New cookie alert!!‼️ A new cookie has been added to our rotation. Sourdough oatmeal cream pies!! Oh My Gosh!! These cookies are soft with the perfect amount of spice, then filled with a fluffy vanilla frosting. $3.00 each.

We will still have our chocolate chip cookies, regular cinnamon rolls and sourdough bread. Prices will be listed below 👇🏻 Thank you everyone!! ☺️

Cinnamon rolls:
WITH CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
- 4 count: $8
- 6 count: $12
- 8 count: $16
- 12 count: $24
WITHOUT CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
- 4 count: $6
- 6 count: $8
- 8 count: $12
- 12 count: $18

Chocolate chip cookies: 🍪
- 4 count: $6
- 6 count: $8
- 8 count: $12
- 12 count: $18

Sandwich loaf: $8
Artisan style: $10
Cheddar jalapeño artisan style: $12
Cinnamon loaf: $12

Address

Otego, NY
13825

Telephone

+6072877253

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butterball's Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Butterball's Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category