Not Just Cakes

Not Just Cakes Gourmet Cakes and Desserts for any occasion. Third place winner of the 2020 Kiss 98.5 Cupcake Challenge. Follow us on Instagram-notjustcakes1

🥕🍪 Carrot Cake Cookie 🍪🥕Meet your new obsession: Carrot Cake Cookies stuffed with cream cheese 🤍✨Soft, spiced carrot cak...
06/19/2026

🥕🍪 Carrot Cake Cookie 🍪🥕

Meet your new obsession: Carrot Cake Cookies stuffed with cream cheese 🤍✨

Soft, spiced carrot cake cookie on the outside… rich, creamy cream cheese filling on the inside. Every bite tastes like your favorite slice of carrot cake — but make it cookie form 😍

Available this weekend— stop in and grab yours before they disappear! 🧡

✨ Childhood nostalgia… but make it cake pops ✨Introducing our Cosmic Brownie Cake Pops 🌈🍫Everything you love about the c...
06/18/2026

✨ Childhood nostalgia… but make it cake pops ✨

Introducing our Cosmic Brownie Cake Pops 🌈🍫
Everything you love about the classic treat transformed into a rich, chocolatey cake pop topped with colorful candy crunch!

Fudgy ✔️
Fun ✔️
Impossible to stop at one ✔️

Who’s grabbing one (or a couple)? 👀✨

Stop in and treat yourself today before they disappear! 🌈🍫

Weekly Menu for June 18,19,20,21Cupcake’s: Cherry ChipWedding Cake(Almond Cake,Raspberry Filled Buttercream frosting) Ch...
06/17/2026

Weekly Menu for June 18,19,20,21

Cupcake’s:
Cherry Chip
Wedding Cake(Almond Cake,Raspberry Filled Buttercream frosting)
Chocolate Hazelnut
Boston Cream Pie
Chocolate
Resse’s

Cookies:
Cutout Cookies

Regular Cookies:
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Chip
Toffee Cookies

Stuffed Cookie:Carrot Cake

Cheesecake:
Regular Cheesecake Slices
Mini Cheesecake:Brownie

Cake Pops: Cosmic Brownie

Loaded Brownies: Buckeye

Other Desserts:

Pastry Hearts

5inch Pie: Coconut Cream Pie

Cinnamon Rolls will be Available on Saturday

Italian Bread Will be Available Friday & Saturday

Be Sure to Visit us this weekend!
5037 Lake Ave
Orchard Park Ny,14127

We are so excited!
06/17/2026

We are so excited!

Move over traditional cakes… there’s a new favorite in town ✨We’ve got the VIRAL Dot Cakes IN STOCK! 🎉Cute, delicious, a...
06/11/2026

Move over traditional cakes… there’s a new favorite in town ✨

We’ve got the VIRAL Dot Cakes IN STOCK! 🎉
Cute, delicious, and impossible to resist.

Stop by and see what everyone’s talking about before they’re gone! 🍰💕

Weekly Menu for June 11,12,13,14Cupcake’s: Hummingbird Cake Triple Lemon Butterfinger Tres Leches CakeChocolate Resse’s ...
06/10/2026

Weekly Menu for June 11,12,13,14

Cupcake’s:
Hummingbird Cake
Triple Lemon
Butterfinger
Tres Leches Cake
Chocolate
Resse’s

Cookies:
Cutout Cookies

Regular Cookies:
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Chip
Raspberry PopTart

Stuffed Cookie:Brownie Stuffed Cookie

Cheesecake:
Regular Cheesecake Slices
Mini Cheesecake:Orange

Cake Pops: Key Lime Pie

Loaded Brownies: Hostess

Other Desserts:

Vanilla Dot Cake Cups

Pastry Hearts

5inch Pie: Strawberry

Strawberry and Cream Decorated Cake Sandwiches

Cinnamon Rolls will be Available on Saturday

Italian Bread Will be Available Friday & Saturday

Be Sure to Visit us this weekend!
5037 Lake Ave
Orchard Park Ny,14127

Have you had a chance to try one of our delicious cinnamon rolls yet? 😋If not, today is the perfect day to treat yoursel...
06/06/2026

Have you had a chance to try one of our delicious cinnamon rolls yet? 😋

If not, today is the perfect day to treat yourself! Fresh, soft the perfect amount of sweetness, they’re a customer favorite for a reason.

Stop in and grab one before they’re gone!

📍 Open today until 5:00 PM

💕 Sweet decisions are the hardest decisions 💕If you stopped in today… what are you choosing? 👇🤍 A flaky, delicious Pastr...
06/05/2026

💕 Sweet decisions are the hardest decisions 💕

If you stopped in today… what are you choosing? 👇

🤍 A flaky, delicious Pastry Heart
🍰 A fun and sweet Reese’s Cake Sickle
🍪 A rich and irresistible Salted Caramel Cookie

We want to know — which treat are you grabbing first? Tell us in the comments! ⬇️

No wrong answers… but we know everyone has a favorite 😉

Stop in today and treat yourself! 🧁✨

Weekly Menu for June 4,5,6,7Cupcake’s: Peanut Butter and Jelly Cherry Pie Carrot Cake Caramel Apple Pie Vanilla Resse’s ...
06/03/2026

Weekly Menu for June 4,5,6,7

Cupcake’s:
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Cherry Pie
Carrot Cake
Caramel Apple Pie
Vanilla
Resse’s

Cookies:

Cutout Cookies

Regular Cookies
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Chip
Salted Caramel

Stuffed Cookie: S’Mores

Cheesecake:
Regular Cheesecake Slices
Mini Cheesecake: Bischoff Cookie

Cake Pops: Resse’s

Loaded Brownies: Chocolate Chip Cookie

Other Desserts:
Pastry Hearts

5inch Pie: Chocolate Peanut Butter

Blueberry Decorated Cake Sandwiches

Cinnamon Rolls will be Available on Saturday

Italian Bread Will be Available Friday & Saturday

Be Sure to Visit us this weekend!
5037 Lake Ave
Orchard Park Ny,14127

🌟 We Need Your Support! 🌟If you’ve enjoyed our cookies, pastries, cakes, and sweet treats, we’d be honored to have your ...
06/01/2026

🌟 We Need Your Support! 🌟

If you’ve enjoyed our cookies, pastries, cakes, and sweet treats, we’d be honored to have your nomination in the Best of 716 awards! ❤️

Please consider nominating us in the following categories:

🍪 Desserts & Sweets
• Bakery
• Cookie
• Dessert Menu
• Pastry

💍 Wedding
• Wedding Cake

We are so grateful for your support and for allowing us to be a part of your celebrations, big and small.

Thank you for choosing us, supporting local, and helping us strive to be the Best of 716! 🧁✨

https://thebuffalonews2.secondstreetapp.com/2026-Buffalo-Best-of-716/gallery/?group=541043

Address

5037 Lake Avenue
Orchard Park, NY
14127

Opening Hours

Thursday 12pm - 5pm
Friday 12pm - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Not Just Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category