Not Your Average Cookie

Not Your Average Cookie Not Your Average Cookie is open to the public by appointment only. Hope to see you soon! In addition, we are always open for special orders.

Not Your Average Cookie, LLC is a small bakery business located in northern NY, at the eastern end of the Thousand Islands. With offerings including cookies, biscotti, pies, breads, cakes, whoopie pies, granola, caramel corn, fudge, jams and jellies... there's something for just about everyone! Gift baskets can be ordered and shipped anywhere by Priority Mail - we've sent a lot of packages to depl

oyed troops in the Middle East. Follow us here for updates on community events we participate in as well as local farmers market dates. Find the Not Your Average Cookie booth on Fridays at the Canton Farmer's Market in downtown Canton, NY from mid May to late September. Don't forget pies, breads, cakes and specialty desserts during the holiday season! Call today for special occasion and wedding cake/cupcake/cookie consultations.

07/17/2026

After two decades of baking, I have decided that it's time to hang up my apron and retire. I am currently booked through the end of August - if you have an order confirmed please rest assured that your order has NOT been cancelled. However, no new orders will be accepted.

This decision has not been made lightly and a number of factors have played into it, including some that are health related.

I wish to thank all of my customers from over the past 20 years - farmers market customers, craft/food&wine show patrons, custom cake and cookie orders - I have appreciated each and every one of you. đź’—

Address

426 Lee Road
Ogdensburg, NY
13669

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Not Your Average Cookie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Not Your Average Cookie:

Shortcuts

Share

Category