Not Your Average Cookie

Not Your Average Cookie Not Your Average Cookie is open to the public by appointment only. Hope to see you soon! In addition, we are always open for special orders.

Not Your Average Cookie, LLC is a small bakery business located in northern NY, at the eastern end of the Thousand Islands. With offerings including cookies, biscotti, pies, breads, cakes, whoopie pies, granola, caramel corn, fudge, jams and jellies... there's something for just about everyone! Gift baskets can be ordered and shipped anywhere by Priority Mail - we've sent a lot of packages to depl

oyed troops in the Middle East. Follow us here for updates on community events we participate in as well as local farmers market dates. Find the Not Your Average Cookie booth on Fridays at the Canton Farmer's Market in downtown Canton, NY from mid May to late September. Don't forget pies, breads, cakes and specialty desserts during the holiday season! Call today for special occasion and wedding cake/cupcake/cookie consultations.

10/26/2024

IMPORTANT NOTICE -- Due to a family commitment that will require my attention over the next few months, I WILL NOT be taking orders for Thanksgiving pies or Christmas cookies this year. In addition, I will NOT be vending at the holiday craft shows such as the Thanksgiving show at Kennedy grade school or the big show at SUNY Potsdam. I am currently booked with orders through November 12th and that is my cutoff date, orders will resume in mid January 2025. Thank you!

Edit - please don't worry, my family commitment isn't anything bad - just VERY time consuming.

A couple recent cookie sets...
09/12/2024

A couple recent cookie sets...

I have three pies available - first come, first served. TWO peach pies and one blueberry pie. $15 each. A scrumptious de...
07/14/2024

I have three pies available - first come, first served. TWO peach pies and one blueberry pie. $15 each. A scrumptious dessert without heating up your kitchen!

All set up in Ives Park for Potsdam Summerfest! Lots of yummy options here - come see me before everything disappears! V...
07/13/2024

All set up in Ives Park for Potsdam Summerfest! Lots of yummy options here - come see me before everything disappears! Vendors will be set up until 6 pm today. See you soon!

07/07/2024

Hearing up for the 2024 Potsdam Summerfest! I will have lots of sweet treats - cookies, pies, cake cups, whoopie pies, marshmallows (yes, really - marshmallows!), jams and jellies.... Also, if you are a fan of the Bare Essentials Granola that was sold at Nature's Storehouse and have been missing it - that will be available too! https://facebook.com/events/s/2024-potsdam-summerfest/1800317620460128/

04/30/2024

PLEASE NOTE -- Due to some upcoming renovations which will render the kitchen inaccessible, I will not be taking any new orders before mid June. All currently booked orders will be completed. I apologize in advance for any inconvenience to my clientele.

Here is a list of items I still have available, quantities are included with each picture.
02/04/2024

Here is a list of items I still have available, quantities are included with each picture.

02/04/2024

Good Sunday afternoon, my peeps! First off, I want to extend a heartfelt "Thank you!!!" to everyone who came out to the Frederic Re*****on Museum's Tastes and Treasures show yesterday and supported local small businesses - mine included! I do have some items still available and will put a list in a second post. Everything is first come, first served - so don't wait to claim your goodies!

I have six Decorate Your Own cookie kits available - $25 each. Each contains 12 large cookies, three bags of icing, two ...
12/16/2023

I have six Decorate Your Own cookie kits available - $25 each. Each contains 12 large cookies, three bags of icing, two containers of sprinkles, a candy cane (just for fun), and instructions. First come, first served!

Available - maple whoopie pies! I have a total of 14 extras, they are $1.50 each. First come, first serve! Pickup only.
12/15/2023

Available - maple whoopie pies! I have a total of 14 extras, they are $1.50 each. First come, first serve! Pickup only.

12/09/2023

Need a last minute little thank you gift, Secret Santa item, or teacher gift? Got ya covered! A decorative mug stuffed with a dozen mini cookies will do the trick, just $10 each!

Address

426 Lee Road
Ogdensburg, NY
13669

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Not Your Average Cookie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Not Your Average Cookie:

Shortcuts

Share

Category