Sarah's Cookies

02/23/2026

Hey everyone, thanks for your interest in my cookies! I'm no longer selling them, but if you're in the North Jersey area, I recommend The Sweet Life Cafe for beautiful cookies and gifts!

Making Celebrations Sweeter since 2021

05/25/2018

I'm hoping to make jam this weekend, so if any of you have any of my jars and would like to get rid of them, I will happily take them off your hands! Just let me know.

08/06/2015

Hey everyone! I know I've been really quiet lately. Just wanted to let you know I still have some strawberry and strawberry-rhubarb jam. $8 per pint.

12/25/2014

Merry Christmas!

11/21/2014

Hello!!! I know some of you are wondering why I've been so quiet and whether I'm doing cookies this year. I've had a very busy fall, but I will be taking some orders. I'm not making all eight types of cookies, but let me know what you need, and I'll do my best to accommodate you. Thanks!!

01/16/2014

Ever wonder what happens to all the leftover cookies? They are donated to an organization called Seafarers & International House. Crews that work at sea for 10 months at a time come to port in NYC and NJ, and you can fill tins of homemade cookies to be delivered to them during their stay. These crews are thousands of miles from home, and they're doing this work for many reasons — all of them difficult. Nothing is more heartwarming than a homemade cookie, right? Read more about the seafarers here: http://www.sihnyc.org/port-ministry.php

Seafarers & International House. Serving seafarers, sojourners and community since 1873.

01/01/2014

Happy New Year! Enjoy some post-holiday cookies for half price (until supplies last)!

12/30/2013

It's been a great cookie season. Thank you everyone for your orders, likes, and support!

12/19/2013

It's not too late for last-minute orders! I am home today and tomorrow, just to fill you with cookie goodness.

Lemon lovers will want to savor every bite of these Lemon Stars. And for those who prefer sweet over sour, try them upside-down, so the powdered-sugar-based glaze hits your tongue first. These cookies offer a most delicious balance of tart and tasty.

12/18/2013

What's your favorite cookie? Scotcheroos are a classic -- and very popular! I'm always surprised by which ones people like the most, though, and I'd love to hear your favorites!

Scotcheroos are no stranger to many, but they delight people wherever they go. This peanut butter and chocolate combo is an old favorite, and it's sure to please.

12/17/2013

Don't want to spring for a whole box? No problem! Mix and match however you like. A small box holds three packages of cookies. It's a perfect way to sample and share!

Custom boxes can be either large or small. I can fit three kinds of cookies in a small box or up to seven kinds for a large box. Each kind comes in the quantities listed here. They are wrapped separately to help keep them fresh and keep the flavors separate.

12/16/2013

There is still time to place orders for local customers (New York and New Jersey)! I'll be taking orders through Friday, to be picked up by end of day Friday. Thanks, everyone!