For Old Times' Bake

For Old Times' Bake NJ Home Bakers 🍪🧁
Sisters who love making family recipes- classic, simple cookies and treats!

It’s so hard to believe another school year is almost already over! 🎓🎓As graduation and the end of school is approachin...
06/10/2026

It’s so hard to believe another school year is almost already over! 🎓🎓

As graduation and the end of school is approaching, let us take the pressure off of you!

We’ll be more than happy to put together cookie or cupcake trays for your graduation celebrations, and cookie/blondie gift bags for any end of year gifts!

Congrats to all of the teachers and students - you’re in the home stretch!! ☀️🩵

Our Bakesy Ordering Site:
https://shop.bakesy.app/b/for-old-times-bake

**CELEBRATE NURSES & TEACHERS! 🥳🤍For Old Times’ Bake is ready to celebrate National Nurses Week 🩺👩‍⚕️👨‍⚕️(5/6-5/12) and ...
04/29/2026

**CELEBRATE NURSES & TEACHERS! 🥳🤍

For Old Times’ Bake is ready to celebrate National Nurses Week 🩺👩‍⚕️👨‍⚕️(5/6-5/12) and Teachers Appreciation Week 🍎👩‍🏫👨‍🏫(5/4-5/8)!

Gift bag options include:

🍪Option 1 - 6 cookies (Cookies of your choice!) - $5 each (minimum 2)

🍪Option 2 - 8 cookies (4 chocolate chip, 4 cookie butter chocolate chip) - $8 each

🍪Option 3 - 6 bars (Brownies/blondies of your choice!) - $8 each

🍪Option 4 - The BFF bag! - 10 items (4 chocolate chip, 3 cookie butter chocolate chip, 3 cookies and cream blondies) - $10 each

If you’d like to do a “break room” item, our Choose Your Own Adventure (half and full) and Cupcake trays are also available!

Our standard menu is always open for ordering 🍪🧁

THANK YOU!! 🩷

🐰🐤If you plan on ordering for your Easter desserts, please be sure to get your orders in soon!Blondie option special for...
03/31/2026

🐰🐤

If you plan on ordering for your Easter desserts, please be sure to get your orders in soon!

Blondie option special for Easter -
Cadbury Egg Blondies! Our regular blondies base with mini Cadbury eggs, chocolate chips, and a hint of sea salt flakes on top. YUM!

Our pastel M&Ms and all sprinkles/nonpareils are also back.

Thank you!! 🐰

Busy Irish Soda Bread weekend! Get those last orders in! Today is the last day to order for St. Patrick’s Day! ☘️
03/14/2026

Busy Irish Soda Bread weekend! Get those last orders in! Today is the last day to order for St. Patrick’s Day! ☘️

Sláinte! 🍀💚Hi friends! 🍀 a reminder to get your orders in for Irish soda bread! 💚We had to close off Monday, 3/16 for pi...
03/04/2026

Sláinte! 🍀💚

Hi friends! 🍀 a reminder to get your orders in for Irish soda bread! 💚

We had to close off Monday, 3/16 for pickup and deliveries due to high order demand!

All other dates are still available!!! Full menu, and Irish Soda Breads, are made to order for you!

Thank you all for all of the love and support!! We’re so 🍀lucky🍀 to have such wonderful customers!! 💚

Bakesy Ordering Site:
https://shop.bakesy.app/b/for-old-times-bake

Christmas cheer in the kitchen this morning! 🎄🎅🏼🤶🏼✨
12/22/2025

Christmas cheer in the kitchen this morning! 🎄🎅🏼🤶🏼✨

♥️🎅🏼Gingerbread cookies!🎄💚We love these cookies - they taste amazing and are quite sturdy for decorating! We’ll do the ...
12/17/2025

♥️🎅🏼Gingerbread cookies!🎄💚

We love these cookies - they taste amazing and are quite sturdy for decorating! We’ll do the hard part- cutting out and baking. You do the easy part- get your candies, decorate and get creative!

These are on sale now for $10/dozen! 🎄

Bakesy Ordering Site:
https://shop.bakesy.app/b/for-old-times-bake

🎁Gifts!🎁☕️Holiday Biscotti Gift Mug☕️🍪Perfect for a teacher gift or your employees at the office party! 🛍️Cookie gift ba...
12/13/2025

🎁Gifts!🎁

☕️Holiday Biscotti Gift Mug☕️🍪
Perfect for a teacher gift or your employees at the office party!

🛍️Cookie gift bags 🛍️
🍪Option 1 - 6 cookies (Cookies of your choice!) - $5 each (minimum 2)
🍪Option 2 - 8 cookies (4 chocolate chip, 4 cookie butter chocolate chip) - $8 each
🍪Option 3 - 6 bars (Brownies/blondies of your choice!) - $8 each
🍪Option 4 - The BFF bag! - 10 items (4 chocolate chip, 3 cookie butter chocolate chip, 3 cookies and cream blondies) - $10 each

🎅🏼Cookies for Santa! 🎅🏼
Something special for your kiddos!! Each bag has 6 cookies, or 3 Holiday Blondies or Brownies to leave out on Christmas Eve!
We have all of Santa’s favorites! ✨Chocolate Chip Cookies✨Cookie Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies✨M&M Sugar Cookies✨Holiday Blondies✨Sea Salt Butterscotch Pretzel Blondies✨Deep Dish Brownies✨Deep Dish Oreo Brownies✨Gingerbread

Bakesy Ordering Site:
https://shop.bakesy.app/b/for-old-times-bake

♥️🎅🏼*new holiday item*🎄💚 All of our holiday items are now available to order!   In addition to our gift bags, holiday bi...
12/10/2025

♥️🎅🏼*new holiday item*🎄💚
 
All of our holiday items are now available to order! 
 
In addition to our gift bags, holiday biscotti mugs, and Cookies for Santa bags, and gingerbread cookies, we curated a holiday tray for this season!
 
Included in our holiday tray is-
♥️ Holiday Mix M&M Sugar Cookies
💚 Holiday Blondies (Holiday Mix M&Ms, Oreos, White and Semi-Sweet Chocolate chips, and Holiday Sprinkles)
♥️ Deep Dish Brownies with Holiday Sprinkles
 
We are offering this tray in 2 sizes – half tray (18 items, 6 each - $20) or full tray (36 items, 12 each - $40).
 
Don’t forget about our Holiday Discount through New Year’s Day – 15% off all orders!
 
Our full menu is also available for ordering!  Our calendar is starting to fill fast so please get your holiday orders in as soon as possible!
 
As always, THANK YOU!  We love what we do and are so happy to share the gift of sweets with all of you! ♥️🎅🏼🎄🫶🏼

Bakesy Ordering Site:
https://shop.bakesy.app/b/for-old-times-bake

Address

North Plainfield, NJ
07063

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 6pm
Tuesday 8am - 6pm
Wednesday 8am - 6pm
Thursday 8am - 6pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 8am - 6pm
Sunday 8am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when For Old Times' Bake posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to For Old Times' Bake:

Shortcuts

Share

Category