Mystic Sugar Bakery

10/14/2026

We will be CLOSED TODAY (Wednesday) for a much needed catch up day. We’ve been working hard to keep up with orders and we simply need a day to catch up and reset for the upcoming weeks.

We’re sorry for any inconvenience and we hope to see you later this week. Our new theme and flavors will be posted by the end of the day! Happy Wednesday everyone!

10/04/2026

WE ARE HIRING!
Seasonal help (now through Nov 15th). We are looking for someone who wants to earn some extra money making sandwiches for the boxed lunches we provide to a very busy customer! This is a very fast-paced position but very easy to learn! We provide hundreds of boxed lunches per week and we just need some extra hands. Message the bakery here or by calling or stoping by. We need this filled fast as we are in peak season. :)

10/03/2026

There’s still time to pop in! Come get a reading!

09/30/2026

Book now for your spot! Message here or call the bakery. Spots will fill up fast so book early.

09/29/2026

We're having a delicious meeting this week, and ordinary human cupcakes are absolutely...forbidden!

As the Grand High Witch herself would say: Smack your lips, ladies, and roll your eyes! It's rrrriiiich!!

Helga's Wisdom
Vanilla Cake with Caramel Apple Butter Filling and
Brown Butter Buttercream

Bruno Jenkins
Cookie Bottom Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Buttercream

Purple-Eyed Witch
Lavender Cake with Lemon Filling and Honey Buttercream

Hotel Excelsior
Princess Cake with Strawberry & White Chocolate Filling and Vanilla Buttercream

Room 454
Chocolate Cake with Nutella Filling and Coffee Buttercream

Formula 86
Vanilla Cake with Key Lime Filling, Lime Buttercream and Graham Crumble

Dog's Droppings
Chocolate Cake with Ganache Filling and Chocolate Buttercream

Grand High Witch
Chocolate Cake with Raspberry Filling and Chocolate Buttercream

Grandmama's Tea
Earl Grey Cake with Blackberry Filling and Lemon Buttercream

Mouse-Maker
Brown Butter Cake with Brown Butter Caramel and Caramel Buttercream

The Blue Spit
Blueberry Filled Vanilla Cake with Maple Buttercream

Toeless Wonder
Almond Cake with Almond Butter Filling and Almond Buttercream

One Child a Week
Red Velvet Cake with Tart Cherry Filling and Vanilla Buttercream

​Charlie's Sweet Tooth
Vanilla Cake with Pumpkin Butter Filling and Toasted Marshmallow Buttercream

Grand Orleans Hotel
Vanilla Cake with Seedless Raspberry Jam and Vanilla-Almond Buttercream

Luke's Brave Brew
Vanilla Cake with Bavarian Cream Filling and Chocolate Buttercream

Fried and Sizzled
Chocolate S'mores Cake with Toasted Marshmallow Buttercream

Mr. Stringer
Butter Pecan Cake with Ginger-Peach Filling and Brown Butter Buttercream

Cress Soup
Lemon Cake, Lemon Filling and Lemon Buttercream

​The Witching Hour
Chocolate Cake with Cannoli Filling and Vanilla Buttercream

​Rat Gas
Chocolate Cake with Mint Oreo Buttercream

Send a message to learn more

09/22/2026

Well friends, it’s time to share some news that some of you already knew. We have decided it’s time for us to move closer to the family in Arkansas and we are leaving Mystic Sugar Bakery. We are still working out some details but we’ll keep you posted along the way. Just to put one rumor to rest, we were NOT asked to leave the space. This was solely our decision (and a difficult one).

What we know for sure:
We are going to remain OPEN (regular business hours) until November 15th. We will continue to offer our themed cupcakes and most of our most popular baked goods. So we hope you make some time to come in and stock up and give us a chance to say our goodbyes. Because we really will miss seeing you! Our awesome customers/friends have been the best part of what we do! I personally have enjoyed being able to be a part of so many special events, birthday, weddings, babies and celebrations!!

We will be making a few changes to some of our other offerings. After this coming Sunday, September 27th, we will no longer offer hot lunch items. This includes our hot dogs, Mac and cheese, and yes, the beloved biscuit sandwiches. We are beginning the downsizing process and we want to put our focus on the cupcakes, cookies, muffins, scones and some other favorites for the remainder of our time.

Many who know we are leaving have asked what will happen next, and we don’t have a definitive answer as of yet. But when we do, we’ll be sure to share it!

Please be patient as we navigate this next step. We will do everything we can to keep the treats coming as we work on the behind the scenes stuff.

You all have made us feel so welcome in the Valley! We’ve made some awesome friends and awesome memories here! So here’s to the next adventure!!

09/15/2026

Spells are tricky, but baking? That’s a science. 🧪✨

This week at the bakery, we’re channel-ing our inner Owens sisters for a theme that’s pure Practical Magic! We’ve been stirring our cauldrons (and mixing bowls) to bring you a lineup of cupcakes so good, they might just cure a broken heart—or cause a little trouble.

We have the perfect sweet treats to satisfy your cravings. Just remember: always throw salt over your left shoulder, keep rosemary by your garden gate, and never, ever eat just one. 🌿🧁

Drop by this week to grab a box, because a little magic is always practical.

Midnight Margaritas
Lime Cake with Lime Curd Filling and Blackberry Margarita Buttercream

Wild Child
Mexican Chocolate Cake with Marshmallow Filling and Cinnamon Buttercream

Aunt Frances
Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Aunt Jet
Lavender Honey-Soaked Vanilla Cake with Honey Buttercream

The Owens Curse
Espresso Cake with Espresso Buttercream

Rose Cottage
Strawberry Cake with Strawberry Buttercream

Jimmy Angelov
Guinness Chocolate Cake with Bourbon Caramel Filling and Brown Sugar Buttercream

Broken Hearts
Chocolate Cake with Raspberry Filling and Chocolate Buttercream

Toad in the Garden
Matcha Cake with Strawberry Filling and Honey Buttercream

Verbena
Lemon Verbena Tea-Infused Cake with Ginger and Lemon Ginger Buttercream

Cactus Pancakes
Maple-Soaked Vanilla Cake with Maple Buttercream and a Cactus Pancake

Botanical Garden
Hibiscus Cake with Plum Rose Filling and Elderflower Orange Buttercream

White as Light
Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream

Hang up the Broom
Apple Filled Vanilla Cake with Apple C***r Buttercream

Blood on the Moon
Vanilla Cake with Seedless Raspberry Jam and Vanilla-Almond Buttercream

Love Spell
Chocolate Cake with Blackberry Filling and Smoked Vanilla Buttercream

Banishing Circle
Vanilla Cake with Lemon Curd Filling and Chocolate Sage Buttercream

Deathwatch Beetle
Ginger Molasses Cake with Brown Sugar Buttercream and Graham Cracker Crunch

Salt Over the Shoulder
Chocolate Cake Filled with Salted Caramel and Salted Caramel Buttercream

Black as Night
Chocolate Cake with Ganache Filling and Chocolate Buttercream

Send a message to learn more