Crust & Crumb Baking Co.

Home
United States
Newfane, NY
Crust & Crumb Baking Co.

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Welcome to Crust & Crumb Baking Co. Built from scratch, just like our treats!

11/13/2025

Although we had a rough autumn, with lots of abrupt & unexpected changes, I am happy to announce that we will be offering a selection of baked goods & treats for Thanksgiving and Christmas! Quick Menu below for thanksgiving full holiday menu coming soon!

Pie (Reuglar 9 inch double crust pies)
- The Big Apple - $16
- Apple Chai - $16
- Dutch Apple -$20
- Perfect Pear - $18
- Classic Pumpkin - $18
… & More! (Inquire for full list)

Cookies ($18 per Dozen)
-Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
-Sweet Corn
-Pumpkin Snickerdoodle
-Harvest Oatmeal
-Triple Chocolate

Muffins & Scones ($10 Per Box of 4)
-Cinnamon Coffee Cake Muffin
-Pumpkin Muffin w/Pepita Streusel
-Blueberry Muffin w/ Cardomom Crumble
-Bacon & Cheddar Scones
-Pumpkin Pie Scones
-Apple Walnut & White Cheddar Scones

Confections & More
-Vanilla Bean Mini Scones ($12 per Dozen)
-C&C Gourmet Dog Cookies ($14/ 18 ct.)
-Small Batch Vanilla Bean Extract ($20/ 8oz Bottle)

Orders for thanksgiving must be placed no later than 11/23, Pickup available in Newfane, NY. 11/25-11/27(AM) Let me help to make your thanksgiving dessert standout from the rest to impress your pesky in-laws & please the pickiest kids!🤣🦃🥧

10/22/2025

Hey friends — I wanted to take a moment to share a quick update.

Crust & Crumb will be taking a short pause while I figure out what’s next for my baking setup. Unfortunately, the oven that I was renting was sold unexpectedly over the weekend (2 weeks ago) — without any prior notice — which put me in a bit of a tough spot. I originally did not want to have to share this post in hopes of finding a temporary solution, but I have already had to cancel 3 orders since it was sold. So here we are! 😞

Furthermore, my family used to consider this “person” a friend, & someone we cared about. So for them to flip a switch to being so deceptive & malevolent is sickening. It’s like; You’re more than than twice my age, but behave like someone who is less than half of it… GROW UP! 👍😎

I understand business is business, sometimes you have no control over a situation. Difficult decisions that can go on to affect others have to be made, and I get that. However the abruptness & absence of communication gives me reason to believe this person either didn’t actually care & wants me to see fail. So this really makes me question who I can trust in regard to the business moving forward.

It’s a little over two weeks since that dreaded Monday. I have been brainstorming & searching for another oven. However I still feel pretty devastated after investing so much time and love into building momentum this season, and it feels like a betrayal and will take some time to get over. Instead of I’m taking it as a loss, I’m choosing to see this as sign to regroup, refocus, and plan for an even stronger comeback. With a more refined approach, with more flavor. I’m going to practice my skills, hone my craft, and continue growing!

I can’t thank everyone enough for your continued support, encouragement, and love for my baked goods. Every kind word and order has meant the world to me, and I promise this isn’t goodbye — just a “see you soon.”

Stay tuned for updates as I get things sorted. The best is definitely YET TO to come. 💚🍪👨‍🍳

**P.S: If I have NOT reached out to you, to cancel your order then I still plan to fulfill it. My current home oven is VERY tempermental, untrustworthy for MOST items, & really just needs to be replaced… which I’m also looking into! luckily it still works great for pie! 🥧
***any leads or suggestions on where I can find an affordable convection oven(s) are greatly appreciated. I am also looking for a new home oven.

10/02/2025

As the warmer weather dwindles down. The amount of in person pop up events that will be available to me will also dwindled.

Therefore, I encourage any of my fans/ loyal customers to feel free to place an order with me anytime! I can bring it right to your home, or have it available for you to pickup at my home in Newfane. (On Rounds Rd.)

Below is a copy of my summer menu. All items are still available. As I am still working on my fall/winter menu for 2025 (as a perfectionist i take too much time on things like this sometimes.) However here is a short list of the fall/ autumn items I am currently offering…

-Pear, Gorgonzola, & Toasted Black Walnut Scones
($14 per Half Dozen)
-Apple Chai Mini Pies
($8 /5 inch pie)
-Brown Butter Pumpkin Snickerdoodles
-Harvest Oatmeal Cookies
($18 per Dozen)
-Pumpkin Muffins W/ Cinnamon Pepita Streusel
($14 per Half Dozen.)
-Cinnamon Walnut Coffee Cake (Loaf)
($8 per Loaf)

As well as my full summer menu.
Please Call or Text (716) 438-8831 to place your order today! (Pickup/Delivery scheduled when placing order.)al

10/02/2025

We will no longer be able to “POP-UP” at the Ransomville Methodist church event this weekend. Sorry to anyone I told I would be there. (Always looking for affordable markets & vendor fairs to join.

Please let me know if you’re aware of any good events for Crust & Crumb to host a “pop-up” at. As the warmer weather dwindles down I’m starting to panic about my income however I know things always have a way of working out! 💚🍪👨‍🍳

09/29/2025

Apple Harvest Fest, Leftover Cookie Flash Sale! $1 each while supplies last! ($10 per dozen)

Availabile Flavors:
-Salted Brown Butter Chocolate Chip 🍪
-Classic Peanut Butter 🥜
-Harvest Oatmeal 🌾
-Triple Chocolate 🍫
-Brown Butter Pumpkin Snickerdoodle 🎃
-Sweet Corn 🌽

Customer Pickup available all day! (Monday 9/29) Located in Newfane, NY.
Call or Text (716) 438-8831 to place your order!

09/28/2025

& thats a wrap for the Apple Harvest Festival 2025. Big thanks to everyone who came out to support today. It was also great to see so many loyal/ return customers & friends today! Hoping to have made lots of new connections & customers today! 👨‍🍳🍪💚

Did you get something delicious from Crust & Crumb today? Please share your comments/ suggestions with us below! 😋👌

I Still can’t get over what a great turn out we had today! Definitely have to make both Apple Harvest & Blossom festivals an annual event for Crust & Crumb.

(Forgot to snap a pic of my stand before I started & sold out of a few items, But here’s a shot from about half way through the day.)

Also, A big thanks to Newfane Historical Society for hosting these great events. Can’t wait for the Apple Blossom in the Spring!

09/22/2025

Did you know we also offer custom cakes? Contact us next time you have a special event in which you need a cake, Crust & Crumb Baking Co. has got your back! 👍

Custom Minecraft Birthday Cake for the coolest 6 year old i know, Morgan! Complete with TNT Boxes, Diamond Tools, & A Creeper in the middle ofcourse! 🧨💎🌳🎮

So happy to help make your birthday an extra special one. Don’t forget to eat too much cake.
Wishing you the happiest of birthdays yet Morgan, From Chef Andy/ Crust & Crumb Baking Co.! 😛🎂👨‍🍳🎉

09/10/2025

POP-UP ALERT!!!

Final week of the Newfane Methodist Farmer's Market this week! Stop out and see us before it’s over! Lots of your favorites as well as our new fall items available. Like our Pumpkin & Pepita Strussel Muffin, Harvest Oatmeal Cookies, & Apple Danishes!

Stop by to say hi, & try some of these delicious baked goods! Customer Pickup & Delivery to your home or office available anytime. (Please place your order in advance)

Next scheduled POP-UP,
The Newfane Apple Harvest Festival
September 28th
From 10:00 AM - 4:00 PMNewfane Historical Societyy
(2685 West Creek Rd. Newfane, NY. 14108)

09/03/2025

Stop out to the Newfane Methodist Farmers Market Tonight from 4:30-7:00 PM to try some of our new fall treats like pumpkin muffins, butter croissants, & cheese danishes. As well as of your favorite Cookies, Muffins, & Scones!

Only 2 weeks left until the end of the market for the season! Fear not. I will still be accepting orders for customer pickup & delivery to your home or office!
Call or text (716)438-8831 to place you order today!
( Full menu available on our page)

08/29/2025

As a pastry chef who loves to create all kinds of baked goods & desserts. Choosing just one type of goodie to focus on is a real life nightmare for me.

However after opening i found myself doing a little bit of everything. While that is the end goal for C&C. It’s alot to take on right now all by myself.

After getting my “feet wet” this summer with my first few pop up shops & customer orders i have a little bit better of an idea of what customers want.

As the colder weather approaches I’m going to really focus on fine tuning my craft and brushing up on some old areas In which i used to really excel in like breads & yeast dough products, and see where this takes us. Cookies muffins and scones will still be available. But cakes & pies are going to be less of a focus going forward.

Address

6452 Rounds Road
Newfane, NY
14108

Telephone

(716)4388831

Website

https://dot.cards/crustncrumb_716

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Crust & Crumb Baking Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Crust & Crumb Baking Co.:

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Newfane?

Crust & Crumb Baking Co.

11/13/2025

10/22/2025

10/02/2025

10/02/2025

09/29/2025

09/28/2025

09/22/2025

09/10/2025

09/03/2025

08/29/2025

Address

Telephone

Website

Alerts

Contact The Business

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Listing takedown request