Little Pie Company

Directions Website Contact the business

Little Pie Company Desserts made from scratch in the heart of NYC’s Theater District.
✈️ Nationwide Shipping
(539)

The ultimate fall dessert lineup has arrived: Which one is making it to your table this season? No wrong answers. 😉🥧 ...
10/27/2026

The ultimate fall dessert lineup has arrived: Which one is making it to your table this season? No wrong answers. 😉🥧

You asked, we answered. 🥕🥦🥧 Our Vegetable Pot Pie is here—and just in time for cozy season.Packed with broccoli, green b...
10/25/2026

You asked, we answered. 🥕🥦🥧 Our Vegetable Pot Pie is here—and just in time for cozy season.
Packed with broccoli, green beans, sweet peas, carrots, peppers, and hearty potatoes, all simmered in a rich, herby broth and tucked inside a golden, flaky crust, it's the ultimate comfort food for crisp fall days.

The smell of fall is in the air, and the Little Pie Patio is still open! 🍂🥧 Snag a seat outside, grab your favorite pie ...
10/23/2026

The smell of fall is in the air, and the Little Pie Patio is still open! 🍂🥧 Snag a seat outside, grab your favorite pie (or pies—we won't judge!), and soak up the season with us.

We're all about treats over tricks. 👻🧁🎃This Halloween week, we're baking up our festive cupcakes, each one hand-decorate...
10/21/2026

We're all about treats over tricks. 👻🧁🎃
This Halloween week, we're baking up our festive cupcakes, each one hand-decorated with plenty of spooky-season sweetness.

Spooky season calls for Pumpkin Pie.Made from scratch with the freshest ingredients and just the right touch of warm fal...
10/16/2026

Spooky season calls for Pumpkin Pie.
Made from scratch with the freshest ingredients and just the right touch of warm fall spices, our Pumpkin Pie is the classic taste of the season we wait all year for.

One of our favorite fall desserts is back: Our Pumpkin Cheesecake is handcrafted with real pumpkin and simple, high-qual...
10/14/2026

One of our favorite fall desserts is back: Our Pumpkin Cheesecake is handcrafted with real pumpkin and simple, high-quality ingredients—think fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and a golden graham cracker crust—for a rich, creamy taste of fall in every bite.
Enjoy it at home or send a little seasonal sweetness to someone you love. We ship nationwide! 📦

Since 1985, we've believed the best pies start with the best ingredients, which is why we always use fresh, ripe fruit i...
10/12/2026

Since 1985, we've believed the best pies start with the best ingredients, which is why we always use fresh, ripe fruit in every fruit pie we bake. Four decades later, we're still baking them the same way—with care, quality ingredients, and plenty of New York spirit—right in the heart of the Theater District ❤️

October's Pie of the Month has officially arrived! 🍠🥧Our Sweet Potato Pie is everything we crave this time of year: rich...
10/09/2026

October's Pie of the Month has officially arrived! 🍠🥧
Our Sweet Potato Pie is everything we crave this time of year: rich, comforting, and filled with the warm flavors of locally sourced sweet potatoes.
Cozy season never tasted so sweet.

The only thing more indulgent than our sinfully sweet Mississippi Mud Pie? A warm pie topped with a heaping scoop of van...
10/07/2026

The only thing more indulgent than our sinfully sweet Mississippi Mud Pie? A warm pie topped with a heaping scoop of vanilla ice cream, slowly melting into all that chocolatey goodness. 🍫🥧🤤

Name a better fall duo: We'll wait.A warm cup of spiced apple c***r + our freshly baked Pumpkin Pie = The ultimate pairi...
10/05/2026

Name a better fall duo: We'll wait.
A warm cup of spiced apple c***r + our freshly baked Pumpkin Pie = The ultimate pairing for crisp fall days and cozy autumn afternoons.

Before there was Little Pie Company, there was Broadway. 🎭🥧 Founder Arnold Wilkerson first came to New York as an actor ...
10/01/2026

Before there was Little Pie Company, there was Broadway. 🎭🥧 Founder Arnold Wilkerson first came to New York as an actor after studying at London’s Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. So when Little Pie Company found its home in NYC’s Theater District, it was a natural fit.
More than 40 years later, we’re still here—baking from scratch, by hand, in the neighborhood where Arnold’s New York story began.

Some things are simply better together. ☕🥧 Celebrate Coffee Day with the perfect pairing—a fresh cup and your favorite p...
09/29/2026

Some things are simply better together. ☕🥧 Celebrate Coffee Day with the perfect pairing—a fresh cup and your favorite pie.

Our Pumpkin Cheesecake is handcrafted with real pumpkin for a smooth, creamy texture and just the right touch of seasona...
09/27/2026

Our Pumpkin Cheesecake is handcrafted with real pumpkin for a smooth, creamy texture and just the right touch of seasonal spice. The result? A taste of fall in every bite!

Sweet, tart, smooth & creamy. 🍋‍🟩🥧 Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime from a 75-year-old recipe and served bes...
09/26/2026

Sweet, tart, smooth & creamy. 🍋‍🟩🥧 Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime from a 75-year-old recipe and served best chilled with fresh whipped cream.

Back-to-school nights + cozy season call for comfort food. Our Chicken Pot Pie is made from scratch with tender white ch...
09/23/2026

Back-to-school nights + cozy season call for comfort food.

Our Chicken Pot Pie is made from scratch with tender white chicken, fresh cream, peas, carrots & onions, all tucked into our hand-rolled crust and baked until golden. An easy weeknight favorite, made the LPC way..

It’s fall, y’all! ’Tis the season to indulge in seasonal staples: Baked from scratch with pure ingredients, seasonal fla...
09/21/2026

It’s fall, y’all!

’Tis the season to indulge in seasonal staples: Baked from scratch with pure ingredients, seasonal flavors, and a whole lot of love.

TGIF! Raise a glass—or better yet, raise a pie—to the weekend! 🥧🙌
09/18/2026

TGIF! Raise a glass—or better yet, raise a pie—to the weekend! 🥧🙌

Address

424 W 43rd Street
New York, NY
10036

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Little Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Little Pie Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category