Little Pie Company

Little Pie Company Desserts made from scratch in the heart of NYC’s Theater District.
✈️ Nationwide Shipping
(540)

We may be known for our pies, but don't sleep on our New York Cheesecake.Rich, creamy, and perfectly dense, it's made wi...
07/30/2026

We may be known for our pies, but don't sleep on our New York Cheesecake.
Rich, creamy, and perfectly dense, it's made with fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all-natural ingredients on a buttery graham cracker crust.

It's peak cherry pie season, and we couldn't be more thrilled!Made with plump, juicy cherries and finished with our sign...
07/29/2026

It's peak cherry pie season, and we couldn't be more thrilled!
Made with plump, juicy cherries and finished with our signature lightly browned crinkle crust and a sprinkle of sparkling sugar, this summertime favorite is as classic as it gets. 🍒🥧

Chocolate lovers, this one's for you: Our Mississippi Mud Pie is layered with imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streus...
07/27/2026

Chocolate lovers, this one's for you: Our Mississippi Mud Pie is layered with imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel, rich chocolate glaze, and a chocolate cookie crust. Order it for nationwide shipping, local delivery, or in-store pickup—and sharing is totally optional. 😉🍫

Peak berry season calls for pie.Our Three-Berry Pie is packed with fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries, gen...
07/25/2026

Peak berry season calls for pie.
Our Three-Berry Pie is packed with fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries, gently simmered into a luscious filling and tucked beneath a beautiful hand-crafted lattice crust. 🫐🍓

🍋When life gives us lemons, we make Lemon Meringue Pie! 🍋Our mile-high, stiff-peaked meringue crowns a bright, homemade ...
07/22/2026

🍋When life gives us lemons, we make Lemon Meringue Pie! 🍋
Our mile-high, stiff-peaked meringue crowns a bright, homemade lemon filling, all nestled in a flaky, buttery crust that's light as air.

Patio season at Little Pie Company is in full swing! ☀️Snag a table, order a pie, and bask in the bustle of the Theater ...
07/20/2026

Patio season at Little Pie Company is in full swing! ☀️Snag a table, order a pie, and bask in the bustle of the Theater District—we'd love to have you join us!

Decisions, decisions…what's your favorite flavor? No wrong answers. 😉
07/18/2026

Decisions, decisions…what's your favorite flavor? No wrong answers. 😉

There's nothing quite like catching the warm aroma of our pies and pastries drifting down 43rd Street. It's been drawing...
07/16/2026

There's nothing quite like catching the warm aroma of our pies and pastries drifting down 43rd Street. It's been drawing locals and Theater District visitors through our doors for more than 40 years—and for good reason. 😍

Our famous Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is still the dessert that put us on the map—and 40-plus years later, it's just as...
07/14/2026

Our famous Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is still the dessert that put us on the map—and 40-plus years later, it's just as beloved today. Made with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream, and finished with a buttery brown sugar, cinnamon, and walnut streusel, it's anything but an ordinary apple pie. 🍏

🫐Happy ! 🫐Fresh-baked and made from scratch with plump summer blueberries, our blueberry muffins are the perfect way to...
07/11/2026

🫐Happy ! 🫐
Fresh-baked and made from scratch with plump summer blueberries, our blueberry muffins are the perfect way to start your morning—or enjoy as an afternoon treat.

🍫🍨 Cool off with our Brownie All the Way Sundae! 🍨🍫Warm, fudgy brownie? Check. Hand-scooped ice cream? Check. Rich Belgi...
07/09/2026

🍫🍨 Cool off with our Brownie All the Way Sundae! 🍨🍫
Warm, fudgy brownie? Check. Hand-scooped ice cream? Check. Rich Belgian hot fudge, homemade whipped cream, crunchy nuts, and a cherry on top? Check.
Summer never tasted so sweet. 🤤

We believe that when life gives you lemons, you turn them into something unforgettable. And with that in mind, meet our ...
07/07/2026

We believe that when life gives you lemons, you turn them into something unforgettable. And with that in mind, meet our Lemon Meringue Pie!

Baked fresh in our Theater District bakery, our July Pie of the Month features whole, ripe lemons, farm-fresh eggs, and a mountain of mile-high, stiff-peaked meringue.

Our homemade lemon filling is incredibly tangy, allowing the fruit's natural flavors to shine through. It’s a slice of summertime cheer, meant to make every bite feel like a little celebration.

Available today for pickup in our bakery.

Happy Independence Day from all of us at Little Pie Company. ❤️🤍💙**We will close today at 3PM**For more than 40 years, L...
07/04/2026

Happy Independence Day from all of us at Little Pie Company. ❤️🤍💙

**We will close today at 3PM**

For more than 40 years, Little Pie Company has been built on a dream, hard work, and the belief that great things can come from humble beginnings. As we gather with family and friends this holiday, we're grateful to be part of the traditions, milestones, and memories that bring people together.

As we get closer to America's 250th anniversary, we're reminded that our nation's story is shaped by people from every b...
07/01/2026

As we get closer to America's 250th anniversary, we're reminded that our nation's story is shaped by people from every background, culture, and walk of life. 🇺🇸

Today is the last day to enter our pie giveaway!

To enter:
📸 Share a photo or video showing what "American As Apple Pie" means to you
🏷️ Use
❤️ Follow and tag

We will be giving away free pie and 3 contestants will win a boat tour to 4th of July Fireworks! 🎆🇺🇸

*Official rules in bio link



Last chance to order for the Fourth of July! 🫐🥧🇺🇸Our Blueberry Crumb Pie is bursting with farm-fresh blueberries and top...
06/30/2026

Last chance to order for the Fourth of July! 🫐🥧🇺🇸

Our Blueberry Crumb Pie is bursting with farm-fresh blueberries and topped with a buttery oatmeal crumb made with brown sugar and cinnamon. It's the perfect addition to your holiday BBQ—and even better with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Available for pickup, local delivery, and nationwide shipping. Preorder now before the holiday rush!

Today and every day, we're celebrating Pride. Because as so aptly put it, "Love is love is love." 🏳️‍🌈❤️
06/28/2026

Today and every day, we're celebrating Pride.

Because as so aptly put it, "Love is love is love." 🏳️‍🌈❤️

Bring a slice of Americana to your holiday table with our All-American Apple Pie. 🇺🇸🥧Made with fresh Golden Delicious ap...
06/25/2026

Bring a slice of Americana to your holiday table with our All-American Apple Pie. 🇺🇸🥧

Made with fresh Golden Delicious apples, warm cinnamon and nutmeg, and our signature flaky crust, this special edition pie is topped with a commemorative 1776 design in honor of America's 250th anniversary.

Available for pickup, local delivery, and nationwide shipping. Preorder now for your Fourth of July celebration!

There's still time to win a free pie and boat tour to 4th of July Fireworks! 🎆🇺🇸To enter:📸 Share a photo or video showi...
06/23/2026

There's still time to win a free pie and boat tour to 4th of July Fireworks! 🎆🇺🇸

To enter:
📸 Share a photo or video showing what "American As Apple Pie" means to you
🏷️ Use
❤️ Follow and tag

Good luck!

*Official rules in bio link

Fresh in time for summer: our newly revamped Little Pie Patio! ☀️🥧Grab a seat, grab a pie, and enjoy the view.
06/22/2026

Fresh in time for summer: our newly revamped Little Pie Patio! ☀️🥧
Grab a seat, grab a pie, and enjoy the view.

Happy Father’s Day! There’s still time to snag our limited-edition Hudson Bourbon Pecan Pie. Flaky crust, rich filling,...
06/21/2026

Happy Father’s Day!

There’s still time to snag our limited-edition Hudson Bourbon Pecan Pie. Flaky crust, rich filling, and pecans marinated in Bright Lights, Big Bourbon, finished with a cayenne kick.

This Juneteenth, we honor freedom, unity, and the strength of our community."Because after 250 years, one thing remains ...
06/19/2026

This Juneteenth, we honor freedom, unity, and the strength of our community.

"Because after 250 years, one thing remains true: Our diversity is our power, and our unity is our strength." ❤️🥧 .

Dad called. He wants pie. 🥧Back in time for , our Dad's Pie Sampler includes four crowd-pleasing favorites: Florida Key...
06/15/2026

Dad called. He wants pie. 🥧

Back in time for , our Dad's Pie Sampler includes four crowd-pleasing favorites: Florida Key Lime, Salted Caramel Apple, Mississippi Mud, and Bourbon Pecan. Father's Day is less than 10 days away, so now's the time to order.

Available nationwide through .

Next week, celebrate with our red velvet cupcakes — a festive nod to the tradition of red foods and drinks served duri...
06/12/2026

Next week, celebrate with our red velvet cupcakes — a festive nod to the tradition of red foods and drinks served during the holiday. ❤

Address

424 W 43rd Street
New York, NY
10036

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Little Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Little Pie Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category