Little Pie Company

Little Pie Company Desserts made from scratch in the heart of NYC’s Theater District.
✈️ Nationwide Shipping
(541)

🇺🇸🥧 Celebrate with our new All-American Apple Pie, a patriotic twist on a classic favorite.🇺🇸🥧 Made with the same reci...
06/06/2026

🇺🇸🥧 Celebrate with our new All-American Apple Pie, a patriotic twist on a classic favorite.🇺🇸🥧

Made with the same recipe as our Old-Fashioned Apple Pie, it's filled with fresh Golden Delicious apples and warm notes of cinnamon and nutmeg, all wrapped in a flaky, golden crust and topped with a festive 1776 design. Low in sugar but big on flavor, it's the perfect centerpiece for your Fourth of July gathering.

Available for pickup, local delivery, and nationwide shipping

Our limited-edition Bourbon Pecan Pie is back! 🥃🥧This scrumptious, limited-edition pie was created in partnership with ...
06/05/2026

Our limited-edition Bourbon Pecan Pie is back! 🥃🥧

This scrumptious, limited-edition pie was created in partnership with as the perfect Father’s Day gift for dad. Our handmade pie features an incredibly crisp crust, a rich, tasty filling, and Hudson Bright Lights, Big Bourbon-marinated pecans, finished with a hint of cayenne pepper for a little extra kick.

The true star of the show? Rich, indulgent imported Belgian chocolate. 🍫🥧 Amazing on its own, but even better combined w...
05/31/2026

The true star of the show? Rich, indulgent imported Belgian chocolate. 🍫🥧 Amazing on its own, but even better combined with fudgy brownie streusel, silky chocolate glaze and a chocolate cookie crust in our Mississippi Mud Pie. Consider this your sign to try it if you haven't already….

As America celebrates its 250th anniversary this July, Little Pie Company is proud to honor the people, stories, and tra...
05/31/2026

As America celebrates its 250th anniversary this July, Little Pie Company is proud to honor the people, stories, and traditions that continue to shape our community.

For more than 40 years, our business has been built on love, family, loyalty, and the belief that handmade food can bring people together.

That’s why we’re launching our American As Apple Pie campaign, starring...YOU!

Enter for your chance to win a cruise on Independence Day to see Macy's 4th of July Spectacular! And many other prizes!

Here’s how to enter:

✅ Take a photo or video inside our photo booth that represents American As Apple Pie to YOU! Live outside of NYC? No problem. Take a photo or video from your hometown.

✅ Post it to social media using the hashtag

✅ Tag & follow

Learn more from the link in our bio!

Can you guess this pie? 👀🥧 Hint: It’s savory instead of sweet — not our usual, but every bit as comforting. Drop your gu...
05/29/2026

Can you guess this pie? 👀🥧 Hint: It’s savory instead of sweet — not our usual, but every bit as comforting. Drop your guesses below! ⬇️

Which pie are you reaching for first? No wrong answers. 😉
05/27/2026

Which pie are you reaching for first? No wrong answers. 😉

Today, we pause to remember and honor the brave individuals who gave their lives in service to our country. 🇺🇸 Wishing e...
05/25/2026

Today, we pause to remember and honor the brave individuals who gave their lives in service to our country. 🇺🇸 Wishing everyone a meaningful Memorial Day spent with family and friends. !

Wishing everyone a sweet Memorial Day Weekend filled with sunshine, family, friends, and good food. Here's to the unoffi...
05/22/2026

Wishing everyone a sweet Memorial Day Weekend filled with sunshine, family, friends, and good food. Here's to the unofficial start of summer 2026! !

Blueberry Crumb Pie is back in the spotlight just in time for Memorial Day Weekend. 🫐🥧Made from scratch with plump, farm...
05/20/2026

Blueberry Crumb Pie is back in the spotlight just in time for Memorial Day Weekend. 🫐🥧

Made from scratch with plump, farm-fresh blueberries and topped with a buttery oatmeal crumb with brown sugar and cinnamon, it’s the perfect pie for BBQs, long weekends, and the start of summer.

The week before Memorial Day feels a lot like the start of summer. ☀️⚾🥧 Blue skies, baseball season, fresh pie, and a li...
05/18/2026

The week before Memorial Day feels a lot like the start of summer. ☀️⚾🥧 Blue skies, baseball season, fresh pie, and a little extra time outdoors — what could be better?

TGIF — you deserve a slice of Mississippi Mud Pie. 🍫🥧This ultra-rich favorite is made from imported Belgian chocolate, b...
05/15/2026

TGIF — you deserve a slice of Mississippi Mud Pie. 🍫🥧
This ultra-rich favorite is made from imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel, and silky chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust.

In the heart of the Theater District, our Classic Old-Fashioned Apple Pie has been bringing people together for decades....
05/14/2026

In the heart of the Theater District, our Classic Old-Fashioned Apple Pie has been bringing people together for decades. 🥧🍎Made from scratch with fresh Golden Delicious apples, warm cinnamon and nutmeg, and finished with a light, flaky crust, taste it today to discover why it’s a timeless favorite.

Sunny spring afternoons call for pie and something cold to drink. ☀️🥧 Post up on our patio for some pie, an iced coffee ...
05/12/2026

Sunny spring afternoons call for pie and something cold to drink. ☀️🥧 Post up on our patio for some pie, an iced coffee or iced tea, and a chance to slow down and enjoy one of the season’s simple pleasures.

Happy Mother’s Day ❤️ Wishing a sweet day to all the moms, grandmothers, mother figures, and pie lovers celebrating toda...
05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day ❤️ Wishing a sweet day to all the moms, grandmothers, mother figures, and pie lovers celebrating today. We’re grateful to be part of your tables, traditions, and family gatherings. With love from all of us at Little Pie Company

Mom's Spring Pie Sampler 💐| Last chance for Mother’s Day delivery!Celebrate Mom with our limited-edition sampler pack fe...
05/08/2026

Mom's Spring Pie Sampler 💐| Last chance for Mother’s Day delivery!

Celebrate Mom with our limited-edition sampler pack featuring four of our favorite five-inch pies: Strawberry Rhubarb, Montmorency Cherry, Three Berry, and Blueberry Crumb. Timeless, handmade from-scratch pies baked fresh for Mother’s Day. 🥧

Show Mom just how much she means to you with something sweet, fresh, and made from scratch. Our limited-edition Strawber...
05/06/2026

Show Mom just how much she means to you with something sweet, fresh, and made from scratch. Our limited-edition Strawberry Shortcake, crafted exclusively for Mother’s Day, features fresh strawberries, light whipped cream, and our signature three-layer yellow cake.

**Available for in-store pickup only**

04/29/2026

I scream, you scream, we all scream for…Pecan Pie! Have you tried our Southern Pecan Pie? With its rich, tender crust and crispy, crunchy pecans, you're guaranteed to love it!

Simple ingredients. Exceptional pies.At Little Pie Company, we believe less is more—just wholesome, high-quality ingredi...
04/27/2026

Simple ingredients. Exceptional pies.
At Little Pie Company, we believe less is more—just wholesome, high-quality ingredients and time-honored recipes.

At Little Pie Company, we may be known for our pies—but don’t miss our cakes, including our signature New York Cheesecak...
04/25/2026

At Little Pie Company, we may be known for our pies—but don’t miss our cakes, including our signature New York Cheesecake. Rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced, it’s made with fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all-natural ingredients, all nestled in a golden graham cracker crust.

What better way to show you care than with a custom, hand-decorated cake?Meet our Romantic Rose Cake: Stunning to look a...
04/23/2026

What better way to show you care than with a custom, hand-decorated cake?
Meet our Romantic Rose Cake: Stunning to look at and just as delicious—featuring moist yellow cake wrapped in soft pink buttercream, piped into delicate roses. 🌹
📞 Call 212-736-4780 to order today—each cake is made fresh just for you!

Since 1985, our pies have stayed true to their roots—but we’re evolving in how we care for the planet. We’ve upgraded to...
04/22/2026

Since 1985, our pies have stayed true to their roots—but we’re evolving in how we care for the planet. We’ve upgraded to energy-efficient ovens from MIWE and Sveba-Dahlen, added LED lighting, improved our cooling systems, and introduced reusable, biodegradable tote bags—all to reduce our footprint without compromising the quality you love.
Because to us, great baking should also mean giving back—for today and future generations 🌍♻️

🍒 Cheers for Cherry Pie! 🍒April’s Pie of the Month features fresh Montmorency cherries, a golden crinkled crust, and jus...
04/20/2026

🍒 Cheers for Cherry Pie! 🍒

April’s Pie of the Month features fresh Montmorency cherries, a golden crinkled crust, and just the right amount of sugary crystals.

ICYMI: Our Strawberry Rhubarb Pie is back in time for spring! This berrylicious treat makes the perfect seasonal indulge...
04/17/2026

ICYMI: Our Strawberry Rhubarb Pie is back in time for spring! This berrylicious treat makes the perfect seasonal indulgence.

🥧💼 Tax Day doesn’t have to be stressful…Start your morning the sweet way—with a fresh, homemade pie from us! Whether you...
04/15/2026

🥧💼 Tax Day doesn’t have to be stressful…
Start your morning the sweet way—with a fresh, homemade pie from us! Whether you’re filing early or procrastinating just a little 😉, a slice of comfort goes a long way.
📍 Stop by, grab a pie, and make Tax Day a little sweeter.

Arnold Wilkerson came to New York City to be an actor after training at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Arts—but between a...
04/13/2026

Arnold Wilkerson came to New York City to be an actor after training at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Arts—but between auditions, he started baking pies in his tiny apartment, inspired by his grandmother.

He began selling them to friends… then friends of friends… until the buzz reached Barbara Costikyan at New York Magazine, who tried his Sour Cream Apple Walnut and wrote: “Buy, buy, this American pie.”

That moment turned a side hustle into the Little Pie Company 🍎🥧

Address

424 W 43rd Street
New York, NY
10036

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Little Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Little Pie Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category