Lucky Penny Custom Cookies

Lucky Penny Custom Cookies We are Lucky Penny Cookie Co! Specializing in custom cookies & desserts.

The mountains are blue for Bill’s 60th! 🏔️ 🍻
05/31/2026

The mountains are blue for Bill’s 60th! 🏔️ 🍻

Nicholas is two fast, two curious!! 🚙 💨 if you know him, you know! 🏁🏁
05/10/2026

Nicholas is two fast, two curious!! 🚙 💨 if you know him, you know! 🏁🏁

Happy Teacher Appreciation Week to all my fellow teachers! Hope these ones enjoy their well deserved treats 🍪 ✨ ...
05/06/2026

Happy Teacher Appreciation Week to all my fellow teachers! Hope these ones enjoy their well deserved treats 🍪 ✨

Love is in bloom 🤍 Ready to welcome spring with open arms….anytime it feels like showing up ☀️ 🌼
05/04/2026

Love is in bloom 🤍 Ready to welcome spring with open arms….anytime it feels like showing up ☀️ 🌼

A little sweetheart is on the way 🍦 🍩 🩷 Give me a good theme & creative freedom and I’ll go off every time ✨ comment wha...
04/26/2026

A little sweetheart is on the way 🍦 🍩 🩷 Give me a good theme & creative freedom and I’ll go off every time ✨ comment what’s your favorite cookie because I can’t decide!

Shiloh’s swinging into 5! 🕷️ 🕸️
04/25/2026

Shiloh’s swinging into 5! 🕷️ 🕸️

The letter of the day is N! ❤️💛💙💚🎂 🥨 Now offering cake pops & chocolate covered pretzels!
04/21/2026

The letter of the day is N! ❤️💛💙💚

🎂 🥨 Now offering cake pops & chocolate covered pretzels!

Oneder the sea with the cutest little mermaid! ✨ 🌊
04/18/2026

Oneder the sea with the cutest little mermaid! ✨ 🌊

For the first time in forever, Lucy is 3!! ❄️ 🩵🤍
04/14/2026

For the first time in forever, Lucy is 3!! ❄️ 🩵🤍

We 🩵💙🤍 a monochromatic moment
04/05/2026

We 🩵💙🤍 a monochromatic moment

Address

New York, NY
10314

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lucky Penny Custom Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category