Clicky

Cookie Jar

Cookie Jar A bakery dedicated to a huge selection of great cookies all made by hand. Visit our our second locat Each recipe is unique.

CookieJar currently has 140 plus different cookies on a daily basis. Each cookie is developed and modified by the Master Baker Cakechef and tweaked to perfection or at the very least a very satisfying bite. After all...if it aint worth the calories...Why would you eat it???? We live by that motto at the CookieJar. Plus we have 8 different delicious CUPCAKES. Check out the pics on our web site and follow us on instagram coookiejarnyc

Operating as usual

10/27/2022
Halloween Giveaway Winner

Congratulations to our winner of this month’s contest on Facebook! Yeno-Rosenblum you may stop by our store at 1226 Forest Ave either tomorrow or Saturday to pick up your prize! Make sure to show your ID for verification!

🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑Halloween is just around the corner, so we’re giving away a cute halloween bucket with a free pound of...
10/21/2022

🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑

Halloween is just around the corner, so we’re giving away a cute halloween bucket with a free pound of cookies included! All you have to do is tag five friends and share this post! There will be one winner for Instagram and one winner for Facebook!

Winners will be announced this Thursday the 27th, and will be able to pick up their prizes Friday & Saturday!








Our Black Sesame Shortbread cookies are the perfect treat to help you get through the rest of the week!                 ...
10/06/2022

Our Black Sesame Shortbread cookies are the perfect treat to help you get through the rest of the week!








09/22/2022

Congratulations to our winner of this month’s contest on Facebook! Kathleen Rubino Sinagra you may stop by our store at 1226 Forest Ave either tomorrow or Saturday to pick up your prize! Make sure to show your ID for verification!

🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑With school back in session we’re giving away a teacher’s bucket with a free pound of cookies! All you...
09/16/2022

🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑

With school back in session we’re giving away a teacher’s bucket with a free pound of cookies! All you have to do is tag five friends and share this post! There will be one winner for Instagram and one winner for Facebook!

Winners will be announced this Thursday the 22nd, and will be able to pick up their prizes Friday & Saturday!








🛑 Question of the day! 🛑⁠⁠What's YOUR favorite shortbread cookie? Ours is the Lemon Poppy Shortbread cookie! 🤩          ...
09/10/2022

🛑 Question of the day! 🛑⁠

What's YOUR favorite shortbread cookie? Ours is the Lemon Poppy Shortbread cookie! 🤩








This one is for all our jelly fans! If you enjoy apricot jelly, and want a small and simple cookie, then our Apricot Ham...
09/09/2022

This one is for all our jelly fans! If you enjoy apricot jelly, and want a small and simple cookie, then our Apricot Hamentashen are just for you!








Our chocolate chip sandwiches are a crowd favorite! 😋 With two butter cookies filled with chocolate ganache inside, mini...
09/08/2022

Our chocolate chip sandwiches are a crowd favorite! 😋 With two butter cookies filled with chocolate ganache inside, mini chocolate chips, and some powdered sugar, these will easily become your favorite too!








09/07/2022

Looking for a cute decoration piece for your dining room or kitchen? Maybe this can be a gift to friends who just bought a new house! 🧁⁠

This cupcake cookie jar, along with many others we have in our store, start at $60.00 with tax and come with a free pound of cookies! ⁠








Do we have any cherry fans here? 😍 Our Dark Chocolate Cherry Cookies have the perfect balance of a cherry in each bite w...
09/06/2022

Do we have any cherry fans here? 😍 Our Dark Chocolate Cherry Cookies have the perfect balance of a cherry in each bite with delicious semi-sweet chocolate! 🍪⁠








08/26/2022

Our Red Velvet Cake Shake is the perfect treat to start off your weekend! 🧁








08/25/2022

Congratulations to our winner of this month’s contest on Facebook! Kayla Circolone you may stop by our store at 1226 Forest Ave either tomorrow or Saturday to pick up your prize! Make sure to bring your ID for verification!

08/20/2022

🤩 Cookie Jar Spotlight! 🤩⁠

"Oh, bother!" ⁠Winnie the Pooh stole our hearts with his love for honey. 🍯 If you're a Winnie the Pooh fan, you'll love this floral cookie jar as a display piece in your house!⁠

⁠Our jars start at $60.00 + tax, and include a free pound of cookies as well as wrapping them up in cellophane & bubble wrap if you're looking to gift them to someone!⁠








🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑We’re giving away 6 assorted cookies with a small starfish plate! All you have to do is tag five frien...
08/19/2022

🛑 Contest Alert! 🛑

We’re giving away 6 assorted cookies with a small starfish plate! All you have to do is tag five friends and share this post! There will be one winner for Instagram and one winner for Facebook!

Winners will be announced this Thursday, and will be able to pick up their prizes Friday & Saturday!








Our Apricot Walnut squares are another favorite amongst customers! Make sure to pick some up next time you visit us! 🤩  ...
08/19/2022

Our Apricot Walnut squares are another favorite amongst customers! Make sure to pick some up next time you visit us! 🤩








Looking for a classic cupcake to snack on throughout the day? Our Carrot Cupcake is just for you! 🥕 ⁠⁠                  ...
08/18/2022

Looking for a classic cupcake to snack on throughout the day? Our Carrot Cupcake is just for you! 🥕 ⁠








Our variety of whoopie pies are great to bring to your next party! We have Red Velvet, Oatmeal Buttercream, Buttercream,...
08/17/2022

Our variety of whoopie pies are great to bring to your next party! We have Red Velvet, Oatmeal Buttercream, Buttercream, Chocolate, and Lemon! ⁠

Which one is YOUR favorite? 😋








08/16/2022

🤩 Cookie Jar Spotlight! 🤩⁠

Can you believe Pixar released the movie 'Up' 13 years ago? It's still one of our favorite movies! 🎈🏠️⁠

⁠Our jars start at $60.00 + tax, and include a free pound of cookies as well as wrapping them up in cellophane & bubble wrap if you're looking to gift them to someone!⁠








These Raspberry Pecan Squares will instantly become your favorite after you try them! 😍
08/15/2022

These Raspberry Pecan Squares will instantly become your favorite after you try them! 😍








Our variety of cupcakes allow you to have the best mix possible! With a banana cupcake, cream cheese frosting, and some ...
08/11/2022

Our variety of cupcakes allow you to have the best mix possible! With a banana cupcake, cream cheese frosting, and some walnuts on top, your friends will be begging you to bring more! 🧁








If you are a fan of ginger, you'll love our White Ginger Almond cookies! They are similar to a Florentine, with sliced a...
08/10/2022

If you are a fan of ginger, you'll love our White Ginger Almond cookies! They are similar to a Florentine, with sliced almonds, candied ginger, and white chocolate! 🥰








Want to start the morning off with a cupcake? Our Orange Sunshine cupcakes have a little orange juice baked into the bat...
08/08/2022

Want to start the morning off with a cupcake? Our Orange Sunshine cupcakes have a little orange juice baked into the batter and icing, giving a subtle yet sweet flavor! 🍊








Have a nutty craving? Our Peanut Squares may be just the treat for you! 🥜
08/07/2022

Have a nutty craving? Our Peanut Squares may be just the treat for you! 🥜








08/06/2022

🤩 Cookie Jar Spotlight! 🤩⁠

We have another throwback cartoon jar of Sylvester Cat and Tweety bird! Was this your favorite cartoon growing up? 🐤⁠

⁠Our jars start at $60.00 + tax, and include a free pound of cookies as well as wrapping them up in cellophane & bubble wrap if you're looking to gift them to someone!⁠








Are you a Brownie Walnut fan? Or maybe a Double Chocolate Cashew one? Either way, you'll love the chocolatey goodness fr...
08/05/2022

Are you a Brownie Walnut fan? Or maybe a Double Chocolate Cashew one? Either way, you'll love the chocolatey goodness from both! 🍪








You may know them as 'Lace Cookies', but here in our store we call them Florentines! They're made with sliced almonds, c...
08/04/2022

You may know them as 'Lace Cookies', but here in our store we call them Florentines! They're made with sliced almonds, candied cherries, and chocolate! 🥰








What's better than a red velvet cupcake? One that's dipped in white chocolate! Our Red Velvet Lulus have to be one of ou...
08/03/2022

What's better than a red velvet cupcake? One that's dipped in white chocolate! Our Red Velvet Lulus have to be one of our most popular cupcakes! Take a bite, and enjoy the cream cheese icing hiding inside! 🧁








08/02/2022

🤩 Cookie Jar Spotlight! 🤩⁠

We all love Mickey Mouse, but if you're an original Steamboat Willie fan then you'll absolutely adore this jar! 🍪⁠

⁠Our jars start at $60.00 + tax, and include a free pound of cookies as well as wrapping them up in cellophane & bubble wrap if you're looking to gift them to someone!⁠








Our Caramel Oatmeal Squares are a crowd favorite here in the store! Each bite has a delicious mixture of caramel, chocol...
08/01/2022

Our Caramel Oatmeal Squares are a crowd favorite here in the store! Each bite has a delicious mixture of caramel, chocolate, oatmeal, and walnuts! 😍








A banana cupcake with peanut butter frosting?! Yes please!! 😋 ⁠
07/31/2022

A banana cupcake with peanut butter frosting?! Yes please!! 😋 ⁠








07/30/2022

🤩 Cookie Jar Spotlight! 🤩⁠

Today we're highlighting our amazing Huckleberry Hound Jar! Does anybody remember this cartoon? 🐶⁠

⁠Our jars start at $60.00 + tax, and include a free pound of cookies as well as wrapping them up in cellophane & bubble wrap if you're looking to gift them to someone!⁠








Did you know? 🤔 Macadamia nuts have the hardest shells! And they make a delicious Macadamia Coconut square! ⁠  ⁠   ⁠  ⁠ ...
07/29/2022

Did you know? 🤔 Macadamia nuts have the hardest shells! And they make a delicious Macadamia Coconut square! ⁠








07/23/2022

I cannoli be happy when I have Cannoli Cream Cookies to snack on! 😋 These delicious cookies are our take on the classic cannoli!








Address

1226 Forest Avenue
New York, NY
10310

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 9am - 8pm
Saturday 9am - 8pm
Sunday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

(718) 448-3500

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Jar:

Videos

Category

Nearby bakeries


Comments

OPEN INTERVIEWS TOMORROW! Don’t miss the chance to work with an awesome staff at Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE & Cookie Jar!
St. Patrick’s Day is right around the corner! Stop by and pick up fresh Irish soda bread from Cookie Jar!
Do you make any items sugar-free for diabetics?
Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE and Cookie Jar are HIRING! Work for the amazing Maria and her wonderful team! Open call MONDAY, Feb. 21st from 4PM to 7PM at 177 New Dorp Lane. Positions available for barista, baker, sales associates and more positions! Don’t miss out to work in a fun, friendly and delicious work environment.
JOB ALERT! Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE and Cookie Jar located at 177 New Dorp Lane is holding an open call until 7pm today for barista, baker, sales associates and more positions! Inquire with Maria! Don’t miss out to work in a fun, friendly and delicious work environment.
Merchants of New Dorp Lane District are spreading the message! Rise Above with SILOVE! Head over to www.SILOVE.org to see how Staten Island District Attorney's Office is combating hate, intolerance and bigotry on our beloved Staten Island. Pizzeria Giove Cookie Jar Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE SIPS + MAKER JHU Comic Books JHU Comic Books Taste Of India Restaurant & Lounge DiTommaso Real Estate
Giveaway ALERT! Cookie Jar is giving away a half-pound box of chocolate chip cookies & blue jay tray when you tag five friends on their post! Head over to their page and enter to win!
New Dorp Lane District distributed Covid-19 supplies earlier today to merchants along the corridor. Please reach out to us if your business is in need of masks, hand sanitizer and/or other supplies! NYC Department of Small Business Services Council Member David Carr NYC Mayor's Office Mayor Eric Adams Staten Island Advance Staten Island Borough President Vito J. Fossella Fresh Twist Brioso Ristorante A.F. Bennett Salon and Wellness Spa Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE Cookie Jar DiTommaso Real Estate
Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE is HIRING! The popular bake shop is looking for bakers, decorators, sales counter associates and kitchen help. Interviews will be taking place November 2nd from 2:00pm to 5:00pm at Cookie Jar located at 1226 Forest Avenue. Apply and join their team!
These florentines are soooooo good! The funny thing is I had an urge for them after seeing them baked this week on The Great British Baking Show, so when I stopped in the New Dorp Lane location today and saw them, I added 2 to my selection of favorites. OMG Cookie Jar - you hit it out of the ballpark with these!
We are excited to announce that Cookie Jar has REOPENED! And just in time for Mother’s Day!

Want to help out this local small business?Then treat mom to some delicious sweet treats from the Cookie Jar! They have just reopened daily 10am-5pm! They are delivering cookies for Mother’s Day anywhere on the island this weekend and will ship them within 24 hours of your placed order. And, for a limited time, they are offering their "Cakechef Strawberry Shortcake" and signature "Red Velvet" for delivery on Staten Island only.

SIEDC Staten Island Chamber of Commerce NYC Department of Small Business Services Small Business Development Center, Staten Island Cake Chef's PIECE-A-CAKE
I was so surprised to see it closed. I thought this was considered essential. Seen all the cookies sitting there. what a shame.
x

Other Bakeries in New York (show all)

You Deserve It from Scratch VinnyCakes Desserts by Watts Sweet Bitez Cafe con Pan Bakery & Restaurant Cakechef Bakery Sugar Sweet Nothings Bakedgoodiesnyc Famous Kosher Bakery The Sweet Life Bakeshop Moretti Bakery The Sugar Fairy Shoppe M.mtreats_bym Dhang’s Ketosina Beansie Cakes