Shut Your Piehole Cheesecakes

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Shut Your Piehole Cheesecakes Retail bakery spreading the Cheesecake Love in Southeast Iowa - located at 600 South Pine Street in New London IA.

Open Wednesdays and Thursdays 10:00 to 6:00, Fridays 10:00 to 5:00 and Saturdays 9:00 to 1:00.

It's time to think about those Thanksgiving dessert orders. Whether it's for your family dinner, your office potluck or ...
10/16/2026

It's time to think about those Thanksgiving dessert orders. Whether it's for your family dinner, your office potluck or just because you want to be Grandma's favorite - you will be so happy you ordered one of our Thanksgiving cheesecakes!
You can place an order via Facebook Messenger, email to [email protected] or text/call the shop at (319)931-7551.
Please DO NOT place an order in the comments - we don't always see all of them.
You will get an order confirmation from us when we receive your order.
We will be open for pickups Monday - Wednesday of Thanksgiving Week (Nov 23 - 25). Order deadline is Friday, November 20.

10/14/2026

And for our Des Moines friends....

It's National Dessert Day and you deserve it - stop in today for a little sweetness!
10/14/2026

It's National Dessert Day and you deserve it - stop in today for a little sweetness!

All we can say is "Yum" this week!For October 14 - 17, our special flavors are:Dark Chocolate Espresso Cheesecake- Choco...
10/14/2026

All we can say is "Yum" this week!

For October 14 - 17, our special flavors are:

Dark Chocolate Espresso Cheesecake- Chocolate crust, dark chocolate espresso Cheesecake covered with chocolate Espresso ganache, dark chocolate buttercream and chocolate covered coffee beans

Lemon Meringue Cheesecake- a graham crust, lemon cheesecake topped with tangy homemade lemon curd and homemade toasted meringue

Strawberry Cookie Butter Cheesecake (this week's PINK Cheesecake, so 10% of sales goes to Henry County Relay for Life) - a Biscoff cookie crust, cookie butter cheesecake topped with strawberry mascarpone mousse, fresh strawberries and crushed Biscoff cookies. You've got to try this flavor combo!

Whoppers Cheesecake- chocolate crust, vanilla malted cheesecake with chopped Whoppers candies mixed in, topped with white chocolate ganache, chocolate buttercream and crushed Whoppers

Turtle
Classic Cherry
New York Vanilla
White Chocolate Raspberry

Sugar free Vanilla and Cherry slices
Keto Vanilla slices
Gluten-free Cherry and Oreo slices

Flavor of the Week, Traditional and Cannoli Flights

Various flavors of Chookies and Cannolis

We are open Wednesday and Thursday 10:00 to 6:00, Friday 10:00 to 5:00 and Saturday 9:00 to 1:00.

600 South Pine Street in New London IA- right off US 34 at Exit 244.

We'd love to see you!

We were proud to be a Key Sponsor at tonight's Dueling Pianos event, orchestrated by New London's own Carson McSorley an...
10/11/2026

We were proud to be a Key Sponsor at tonight's Dueling Pianos event, orchestrated by New London's own Carson McSorley and her teammates from the Henry County Health Center Foundation!
The Foundation holds a special place in the King's heart, as the former director, so it was great to be part of this event. What a fun night - great job, Carson and crew!

Our specialty freezer shelf is freshly stocked with slices today of:Gluten Free Oreo (yay! Finally gluten free slices!)K...
10/10/2026

Our specialty freezer shelf is freshly stocked with slices today of:

Gluten Free Oreo (yay! Finally gluten free slices!)
Keto New York Vanilla (almond flour crust)
Sugar Free New York Vanilla
Sugar Free Cherry

Open 9:00 to 1:00 today.

The team sure has fun with new chookie ideas! They crafted the "Fluffernutter" - two homemade peanut butter marshmallow ...
10/07/2026

The team sure has fun with new chookie ideas! They crafted the "Fluffernutter" - two homemade peanut butter marshmallow cookies with a marshmallow cheesecake center and a peanut butter drizzle.
Grab a napkin and enjoy!

There is a little something for everyone in the case this week!For October 7 - 10, we are featuring:Bourbon Pecan Cheese...
10/07/2026

There is a little something for everyone in the case this week!

For October 7 - 10, we are featuring:

Bourbon Pecan Cheesecake- graham crust, vanilla bourbon cheesecake with pecan pie topping and vanilla buttercream

Coconut Cream Cheesecake- graham and toasted coconut crust, coconut cream cheesecake topped with coconut pudding, toasted coconut and vanilla buttercream

Frosted Animal Cracker PINK Cheesecake (10% of sales go to Henry County Relay for Life) - graham crust, vanilla cheesecake with chopped frosted animal crackers mixed in, topped with pink chocolate ganache, circus sprinkles, vanilla buttercream and frosted animal crackers

KitKat Cheesecake- graham crust, vanilla cheesecake with pieces of KitKat candy bars mixed in topped with milk chocolate ganache, vanilla buttercream and more chopped KitKat bars

Classic Cherry
New York Vanilla
Turtle
White Chocolate Raspberry

Flavor of the Week, Traditional and Cannoli Flights

Various flavors of chookies, cannolis and cake pops.

Open Wednesday and Thursday 10:00 to 6:00, Friday 10:00 to 5:00 and Saturday 9:00 to 1:00.

Come enjpy some cheesecake!

We've got a brand new fall Chookie to share this week. We call this one "The Aubree" because Aubree came up with the ide...
10/06/2026

We've got a brand new fall Chookie to share this week. We call this one "The Aubree" because Aubree came up with the idea and knocked it out of the park!
Two Pumpkin Snickerdoodle cookies with a fluffy marshmallow cheesecake center.
Add it to your Cheesecake Shopping List this week!

Once again, we will be Thinking Pink during October's Breast Cancer Awareness Month.Each week in October, we will be fe...
10/06/2026

Once again, we will be Thinking Pink during October's Breast Cancer Awareness Month.

Each week in October, we will be featuring a Pink Cheesecake and 10% of our Pink Cheesecake sales will be donated to the Henry County Relay for Life.

October 7 - 10 - Frosted Animal Cracker
October 14 - 17 - Strawberry Cookie Butter
October 21 - 24 - Raspberry Mousse
October 28 - 31 - Pink Sugar Cookie

So, come support a great cause and enjoy some cheesecake!

Address

600 South Pine Street
New London, IA
52645

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 1pm

Telephone

+13199317551

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shut Your Piehole Cheesecakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shut Your Piehole Cheesecakes:

Shortcuts

Share

Category