Petey Wheaty's

Petey Wheaty's Serving the best of the best hand crafted ice creams, hot foods, and baked goods in the heart of New Over 30 parking spaces and curbside delivery!

UPDATED HOURS:THURSDAY: 4:00 PM-9:00 PMFRIDAY AND SATURDAY: 4:00 PM-9:30 PMSUNDAY:3:30 PM-8:30 PM🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦
11/09/2022

UPDATED HOURS:
THURSDAY:
4:00 PM-9:00 PM
FRIDAY AND SATURDAY: 4:00 PM-9:30 PM
SUNDAY:
3:30 PM-8:30 PM
🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦🍨🍦

HOURS OF OPERATION:Thursday though Sunday4:00 PM to 9:00 PMClosed Monday through Wednesday🍨🍁🍦🍂🍨🍂🍦🍁
11/03/2022

HOURS OF OPERATION:
Thursday though Sunday
4:00 PM to 9:00 PM
Closed Monday through Wednesday
🍨🍁🍦🍂🍨🍂🍦🍁

We will be closed Tuesday November 1st and Wednesday November 2nd.Starting Monday November 7th, our fall/ winter schedul...
10/30/2022

We will be closed Tuesday November 1st and Wednesday November 2nd.
Starting Monday November 7th, our fall/ winter schedule, we will be closed Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays and we will be open on Thursday through Sunday 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM. 🍂 🍁 💨 🌧 🥶
Our motto: It is never too cold for ice cream. 🍨 🍦
Our hot food will keep you toasty and warm. 🌭 🍔 🍟


There is never a trick at Petey Wheaty’s, only a TREAT!!!We will be open on Halloween with our array of SP🎃🎃KTACULAR ice...
10/30/2022

There is never a trick at Petey Wheaty’s, only a TREAT!!!
We will be open on Halloween with our array of
SP🎃🎃KTACULAR ice cream and foods.
🧙‍♀️ 👻 🎃 🍨 🍦


Petey Wheaty’s is rooting for the Yankees to win game 5!! Join us by coming in and purchasing a “ Bronx Bomber Brownie” ...
10/18/2022

Petey Wheaty’s is rooting for the Yankees to win game 5!! Join us by coming in and purchasing a “ Bronx Bomber Brownie” hot fudge sundae, today. Say that 5 times fast, lol 😆😆😆😆😆😆

Due to the observance of the high holy day of Yom kippur, we will be open on Tuesday October 4th, only till 6:00 PM.. We...
10/04/2022

Due to the observance of the high holy day of Yom kippur, we will be open on Tuesday October 4th, only till 6:00 PM.. We will be closed all day on Wednesday October, 5th and we will reopen on Thursday October 6th.
To all those who observe, we wish you an easy and meaningful fast.

Family meal available today! Order early before we sell out.
08/12/2022

Family meal available today! Order early before we sell out.

We have non-dairy too y’all… but we don’t judge 🤣🤫
07/24/2022

We have non-dairy too y’all… but we don’t judge 🤣🤫

Our friend Caroline sure likes our Dole Whip!😊Come on by and try it yourself if you’re looking for a flavorful dairy-fre...
07/22/2022

Our friend Caroline sure likes our Dole Whip!😊

Come on by and try it yourself if you’re looking for a flavorful dairy-free option!😋

What’s better than one sweet treat? Two!Get a freshly baked chocolate chip cookie when you buy any of our ice cream or s...
07/20/2022

What’s better than one sweet treat? Two!

Get a freshly baked chocolate chip cookie when you buy any of our ice cream or soft serve! 😊😋

Come to Petey Wheaty’s where we’re all one big family!🥰😊😋
07/19/2022

Come to Petey Wheaty’s where we’re all one big family!🥰😊😋

Address

145 S Main Street
New City, NY
10956

Telephone

+18457085030

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Petey Wheaty's posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

About Petey’s

Upper Nyack resident Peter Margolin and New City resident Mark Semel have been best friends since growing up in Yonkers. With Mark’s clean eating as a gym-aholic and body-building competitor and Peter’s success and knowledge of food sales - it was a no-brainer! The store is all about clean ingredients! We will be serving five-ounce burgers, of which is pasture raised and locally made*, hot dogs, pizza rolls, grilled chicken sandwich, grilled skirt steak sandwich, skin-on fries, and more. You can’t forget to end your meal with dessert: expect four soft-serve flavors (with no fructose corn syrup) and 16 hard ice cream flavors, as well as toppings, fudge, and shakes. We will also be serving vegan options from our ice cream options and our grill!