Elsie's Cookie Creations

Elsie's Cookie Creations What can we create for you today?

It’s cruise time again, and this time we’ve got perfect weather on our side! Make sure to swing by our booth and indulge...
09/05/2025

It’s cruise time again, and this time we’ve got perfect weather on our side! Make sure to swing by our booth and indulge in one of our delicious creations. By popular demand, our premium Cookies & Cream sandwiches are making a comeback! We can’t wait to see you there!

07/06/2025

Deliveries are now over. Thank you!

Delivery to New Castle area starting at 9:15pm. $10 minimum please! We are down at the cruise in and will likely have extras tonight and tomorrow. We take cash and nearly all forms of digital payments. We have the following ready for delivery tonight:

Packed Peanut Butter $3
Big Buckeye Brownie $3
Nuddy Buddy Peanut Butter Sandwiches 3 for $5
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip 2 for $5
Chunky Choco' Chip $3

We have a 4 for $11 deal or 8 for $20!

We’re all set up at the Cruise In! Stop by and see us! 🍪🍪🍪
07/05/2025

We’re all set up at the Cruise In! Stop by and see us! 🍪🍪🍪

07/03/2025

Hello everyone!

We’re excited to announce that we’ll be attending the upcoming New Castle Cruise-In this Saturday! Our kids’ busy extracurricular schedules have kept us on the go, but we’re thrilled to be able to make this one! Be sure to stop by our booth and treat yourself to some of Elsie’s Cookie Creations — we can’t wait to see you there!

Saturday's Menu

Nuddy Buddys
Big Buckeye Brownies
Packed Peanut Butters
Chunky Choco' Chips
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chips
Peanut Butter Brookie Sandwiches

❤️🍪

05/03/2025

Hello everyone!

We are pleased to welcome the return of cruise-in season. However, due to the increasing cost of baking ingredients, particularly eggs, and the forecast predicting potential rain and showers this evening, we have made the difficult decision to refrain from preparing products for tonight’s event. The risk of getting rained out is too great.

In lieu of this, we are pleased to offer delivery services to New Castle and the surrounding areas, with deliveries scheduled for Sunday afternoon.

We would be delighted to fulfill any custom orders you may have. Please feel free to reach out and let us know how we may serve you.

02/27/2025

Hey everyone! We hope you're having a great day! We're almost at 300 likes on our page and we're planning a giveaway to celebrate once we hit that milestone! If you're excited for a chance to win some free cookies, please share our page and help us reach our goal. Wishing you all an amazing day!

🍪❤️

Tomorrow night is the last Indiana Legends home game! We will be setup inside the gymnasium with some of the local favor...
02/15/2025

Tomorrow night is the last Indiana Legends home game! We will be setup inside the gymnasium with some of the local favorites! Come on out to support them!

Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip
Packed Peanut Butter
Chunky Choco' Chip
Nuddy Buddy
Snickerdoodle

12/25/2024

Wishing everyone a Merry Christmas!

🍪❤️

Good morning, everyone! We've been hard at work in the kitchen over the past few days, baking almost one thousand cookie...
12/23/2024

Good morning, everyone! We've been hard at work in the kitchen over the past few days, baking almost one thousand cookies for individuals and businesses. With just a few days left until Christmas, we’d love to create something special for your holiday gathering!

🍪❤️

Hello everyone! We often get asked if we can fulfill orders just before Christmas, and the answer is yes! Our cookie cre...
12/06/2024

Hello everyone! We often get asked if we can fulfill orders just before Christmas, and the answer is yes! Our cookie creations are a popular gift choice, and I'll be in the kitchen all week leading up to Christmas to fulfill your orders. If you're looking for treats for a party or a gift, let us know! We also offer gift cards, the perfect stocking stuffer!

What can we create for you today?

❤️🍪

11/10/2024

SOLD OUT!

*11/10 Delivery to New Castle ~ 8:00pm*
**ANY 4 for $10**
***Minimum $10 order***

New Castle! We will likely have a surplus of cookies tonight after the Indiana Legends game is over. We would love to deliver cookies directly to your door tonight only!

We have the following cookies for sale:

Nuddy Buddy Peanut Butter Sandwiches ( 25 left)
(Nuddy Buddies Can also be purchased 6 for $10)
Chunky Choco' Chip (15 left)
Chocolate Xtreme (5 left)
Buckeye Brownie (5 left

Message us ASAP and we will build your box to reserve it for after the game!

Good afternoon everyone! Tomorrow night, the Indiana Legends face off against the Lousiville Pros. Maybe more importantl...
11/09/2024

Good afternoon everyone! Tomorrow night, the Indiana Legends face off against the Lousiville Pros. Maybe more importantly, the Indiana Legends is honoring our Veterans with FREE entry to the game. As their official cookie sponsor, we'd like to honor them as well! 🫡 If you're a veteran, stop by our cookie booth tomorrow and receive one free Nuddy Buddy Sandwich!

See you tomorrow!

❤️🍪

Address

New Castle, IN
47362

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Elsie's Cookie Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Elsie's Cookie Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category