The Rustic Whisk Bakery

Directions

The Rustic Whisk Bakery Hi, I’m Gabby, the owner and baker behind The Rustic Whisk Bakery! I specialize in custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes and other sweet treats!

We are located in New Carlisle, Ohio! Thank you for supporting my small business!

✨ THIS WEEK’S TREATS ✨Sweet Bread Flights + Oatmeal Cream Pies are here! 🤎🍞 Sweet Bread Flight — four delicious flavors ...
08/20/2026

✨ THIS WEEK’S TREATS ✨

Sweet Bread Flights + Oatmeal Cream Pies are here! 🤎

🍞 Sweet Bread Flight — four delicious flavors in one box!

🍂 Pumpkin
🍌 Banana
🤎 Cinnamon Swirl
🫐🍋 Glazed Lemon Blueberry

🍪 Oatmeal Cream Pies — soft, chewy oatmeal cookies sandwiched around a sweet, creamy filling. 🤤

Everything is available while supplies last at Sparks Meats

And for everyone who’s been waiting… 👀

🍪 Cookies + Sourdough Flights will be BACK NEXT WEEK! 🥖

Thank you so much for supporting The Rustic Whisk Bakery! 🤎

✨ A LITTLE BIT OF EVERYTHING LATELY! ✨Between back-to-school treats and birthday celebrations, the kitchen has been BUSY...
08/19/2026

✨ A LITTLE BIT OF EVERYTHING LATELY! ✨

Between back-to-school treats and birthday celebrations, the kitchen has been BUSY! 🥰

📚🍎 These back-to-school cookie sets were SO much fun to make! Personalized pencils, apples, school supplies, and that adorable little goldfish treat, the perfect way to make the first day a little sweeter! 💙❤️💛

And then we have this fun Busch Light birthday cake! 🍺🎂💙 I absolutely loved how this one came together. Blue and white buttercream, “ice,” and a little birthday sparkle to finish it off!

Two completely different orders, but both made with lots of love and attention to detail. 🤍

Thank you to everyone who continues to choose The Rustic Whisk Bakery for your birthdays, celebrations, school events, and all the little moments worth making sweeter. 🥹🧁

My calendars are beginning to fill up for October and November! If you have been thinking about booking a special cake or treat now is the time to book! 🫶🏻

**SOLD OUT** More to come Friday 8/21!🥖✨ SOURDOUGH FLIGHTS ARE HERE! ✨🥖I’m so excited to finally offer these little sour...
08/18/2026

**SOLD OUT** More to come Friday 8/21!

🥖✨ SOURDOUGH FLIGHTS ARE HERE! ✨🥖

I’m so excited to finally offer these little sourdough flights! 😍

Each flight comes with 4 mini sourdough loaves so you can try a little bit of everything:

🤍 Plain
✨ Everything bagel
🌶️🧀 Jalapeño Cheddar
🧄🧀 Garlic Parmesan

$16 per flight

These will be LIMITED at Sparks Meats each week while I test out offering them, so quantities will be small!

Perfect for sharing… or keeping all four for yourself. 😉😂

I can’t wait to hear which flavor is your favorite! ❤️

📞 Please call ahead to check availability before coming to pick up!

— The Rustic Whisk Bakery 🥖✨

🎂✨ A LITTLE CAKE FUN! ✨🎂A birthday cake for a TikTok loving girl 💗💙🎵 Complete with all the pink, blue, and TikTok vibes ...
08/16/2026

🎂✨ A LITTLE CAKE FUN! ✨🎂

A birthday cake for a TikTok loving girl 💗💙🎵 Complete with all the pink, blue, and TikTok vibes for a fun milestone birthday! 🎉

And then there’s this chocolate dream… 🤎🍫 Rich chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, lots of pretty piped details, and just a little touch of gold ✨ Because honestly, you can never go wrong with more chocolate! 😋

Two completely different cakes, but I loved creating both! 🥰

📣 A quick reminder for my upcoming cake orders!
If you have a cake booked with me for this week, I’ll be reaching out soon to confirm all of your details. 💕 Please keep an eye on your messages so we can make sure everything is just right for your celebration! 🎂✨

Thank you all for keeping my little bakery so busy and allowing me to be part of your special moments! 🩷

— The Rustic Whisk Bakery 🧁

🤠 To infinity & beyond! ✨This Toy Story + cow print custom half-sheet was such a fun one to create! 🖤💛❤️From the edible ...
08/09/2026

🤠 To infinity & beyond! ✨

This Toy Story + cow print custom half-sheet was such a fun one to create! 🖤💛❤️

From the edible image to the hand-piped rope border and cow print buttercream details, every part came together to make this one of a kind cake. 🎂

Thank you for trusting The Rustic Whisk Bakery with your special celebrations!🤎✨

🍓 One Berry Sweet Cake! 🍓This vintage-inspired strawberry themed cake was such a fun one to create! Featuring a baby pin...
08/07/2026

🍓 One Berry Sweet Cake! 🍓

This vintage-inspired strawberry themed cake was such a fun one to create! Featuring a baby pink buttercream, fondant strawberries and daisies, it’s the perfect sweet summer design. 🌼💕

Thank you for supporting The Rustic Whisk Bakery! 🤍

🍪 This Week’s Cookie Lineup is Here! 🍪Freshly baked and available this week while supplies last!🤍 Cookies & CreamA thick...
08/06/2026

🍪 This Week’s Cookie Lineup is Here! 🍪

Freshly baked and available this week while supplies last!

🤍 Cookies & Cream
A thick vanilla cookie loaded with Oreo pieces and stuffed with a creamy Oreo truffle center.

🥜 Nutter Butter
A soft peanut butter cookie loaded with chopped Nutter Butter cookies and peanut butter chips, stuffed with a creamy peanut butter filling, and topped with crunchy Nutter Butter pieces.

🍓 Strawberry Crunch
A thick vanilla cookie topped with strawberry buttercream and finished with a buttery strawberry crunch topping made with Golden Oreos and freeze-dried strawberries.

🍫 triple fudge brownie cookie
A rich chocolate cookie stuffed with a fudgy brownie center, topped with silky chocolate fudge buttercream and finished with brownie crumbles.

✨ Available while supplies last at Sparks Meats!

💖✨ When two favorite themes become one! ✨💜This custom half-and-half birthday cake was so much fun to create! One side ce...
08/01/2026

💖✨ When two favorite themes become one! ✨💜

This custom half-and-half birthday cake was so much fun to create! One side celebrates K-Pop Demon hunters, while the other brings the cutest Baby Shark underwater party to life! 🎤🦈

I love helping bring unique ideas together into one special cake that’s perfect for celebrating siblings or anyone who can’t pick just one favorite theme!

🎂 Custom cakes are made to order and designed just for you.
🗓️August and September availability is limited, so if you’re thinking about booking a custom cake, now is the perfect time to reserve your date!

Thank you for trusting The Rustic Whisk Bakery to be part of your special celebrations! 💕

🎂 August & September Availability 🎂If you’ve been thinking about ordering a custom cake for an upcoming celebration, now...
07/30/2026

🎂 August & September Availability 🎂

If you’ve been thinking about ordering a custom cake for an upcoming celebration, now is the perfect time to reserve your date!

My availability for August and September is very limited, with only a few openings remaining. Once those dates are filled, I won’t be able to accept additional orders for those weekends.

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, baby shower, bridal shower, anniversary, or another special occasion, I’d love to create something sweet for you! 🩷

📅 Check out my availability below and send me a message to reserve your spot.

✨ 50% non-refundable retainer required to secure your order.

Thank you for supporting my small business, it truly means so much! 💕

Please check out my page to see any past work! 🫶🏻

— The Rustic Whisk Bakery

🎡🍪 Step right up… Fair Week cookies are here! 🍪🎡You don’t have to wait in line at the fair to enjoy your favorite summer...
07/29/2026

🎡🍪 Step right up… Fair Week cookies are here! 🍪🎡

You don’t have to wait in line at the fair to enjoy your favorite summer flavors! This week’s lineup is inspired by all the treats we look forward to every year.

🍎 Caramel Apple Crumble – A soft apple cinnamon cookie filled with homemade apple filling, topped with buttery streusel and a rich caramel drizzle.

🍑 Peach Cobbler – A cinnamon cookie topped with sweet peach filling, buttery streusel.

🍋 Lemon Shake-Up – A soft lemon cookie topped with tangy lemon filling and finished with a swirl of lemon buttercream for the perfect sweet and tart summer treat.

Also available is our classic Chocolate chip, and our large fudge brownies!!

✨ Available at SpSparks MeatsPlease call ahead to verify availability!
🎠 Freshly baked in small batches at The Rustic Whisk Bakery.

Address

412 N Main Street
New Carlisle, OH
45344

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Rustic Whisk Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category