Butter+Scotch Bakery

Butter+Scotch Bakery Bakery specializing in gourmet cupcakes and cookies, mobile dessert bar rental.

It’s a beautiful day to stroll the market, soak up some sunshine, and treat yourself to something sweet!We’re at 2nd Str...
05/30/2026

It’s a beautiful day to stroll the market, soak up some sunshine, and treat yourself to something sweet!

We’re at 2nd Street Market today from 9:00-3:00 with all of your favorites:

•Crookies
•FriendChip Goals
•Triple Chocolate Brownie
•Raspberry Shortbread
•S’more than a Feeling

The sun is shining, the vendors are out, and the market is buzzing. Come grab a coffee, support local, and enjoy one of those perfect Ohio days that reminds us why we love farmers market season!

One of my absolute favorite things is watching customers power walk straight up to our booth at the market, completely c...
05/25/2026

One of my absolute favorite things is watching customers power walk straight up to our booth at the market, completely confident, on a mission, already knowing exactly what they want—which is sometimes “one of each.”

When someone says, “I was thinking about that cookie all week!” or “I had a rough day and remembered that I had a piece of my chocolate chip cookie left, and it made my night!” Someone else said, “This is what (major cookie chain name here) WISHES their cookies were like!”

Those kinds of comments stick with me more than people probably realize. The fact that you choose to spend your hard earned money to support our business means everything.

Anyone who owns a bakery business knows the long hours that go into market weekends. Sometimes it’s several days straight on our feet baking, before we ever even load up and head to market.

That’s why it means so much to see people excited while we’re describing the cookies, or when someone takes one bite and immediately comes back for another.

Our business has grown in an extraordinary way and we’re so grateful. We’re entering our busiest season and you’ll start to see us in multiple places every weekend and our cookies in more retail locations. It’s also wedding season on the farm.

Having said that, we never want to be too busy to have a visit with you, to bake for your something special (or just when you need some “cookie therapy”) and to let you know how very much we appreciate you! So truly— thank you! We appreciate every single one of you more than you know. 🤍🍪

Come see us at the market!On the menu today:•FriendChip Goals•Pistachio Toffee Chip•Raspberry Shortbread •Crookie
05/24/2026

Come see us at the market!

On the menu today:

•FriendChip Goals
•Pistachio Toffee Chip
•Raspberry Shortbread
•Crookie

This Memorial Day weekend, the Market is open during its normal hours:

Friday 11 AM – 3 PM
Saturday 9 AM – 3 PM
Sunday 11 AM – 3 PM

Hope to see you there! 🌞

05/15/2026

Treasure hunting burns calories. We’re just here to help.

If you’re headed to the Springfield Antique Show & Flea Market Extravaganza this weekend, swing by Christian Bros Meat Company LLC for the kind of shopping fuel that keeps you digging through barns, loading wagons and making trips to the car! (We recommend the Barnyard Parfait, but everything is delicious!)

They’ll have our cookies ready for the adventure:

• FriendChip Goals
• Raspberry Shortbread
• Triple Chocolate
• PB+ Jealous

Come for the sweet deals and the sweet treats!

05/10/2026

**Thank you for a sold out market! It was wonderful to see familiar faces (so happy to be closer for you) and to make new friends! Your support means the world to us. We look forward to seeing you next week!**

Dayton friends — today’s the day! We’re celebrating Mother’s Day at 2nd Street Market!

Today’s cookie cast:

• Crookies — buttery croissants stuffed with warm cookie dough because self-control is overrated

• Triple Chocolate — rich, fudgy, and deeply committed to chocolate in all forms

• FriendChip Goals — our loaded chocolate chip cookie that understands the importance of good relationships

• Snickers — packed with peanuts, caramel, nougat, and milk chocolate

• Raspberry Shortbread — soft, buttery, sweet-tart perfection

Whether you’re shopping for Mom, celebrating being a mom, or just surviving motherhood with coffee and cookies, we’ve got you covered today! Come see us and many other farmers, growers, and makers!

05/09/2026

Wow! You all really showed UP on this beautiful day!

A huge thank you to Rip Rap Farmer’s Market for having us for the Mother’s Day Festival, and an even bigger THANK YOU to everyone who stopped by— because you completely sold us out early!

We truly appreciate every single purchase, share, comment, and friendly face. 🤍

We’ll see you tomorrow at the 2nd Street Market!

(Now back to baking, I go!)

05/08/2026

Busy weekend over here at Butter + Scotch Bakery! 🍪

As we speak, fresh from the oven, still-warm cookies are being delivered to Soggy Bottom Farm & Market!

Today’s lineup includes:

Raspberry Shortbread
S’more Than a Feeling
Cosmic Brownie

While you’re there, be sure to peruse the gorgeous plants — so many beautiful varieties just in time for Mother’s Day! Open today from 10–6. 🌿

Next up:

Saturday— Rip Rap Farmer’s Market Mother’s Day Festival from 11:00- 4:00.

AND exciting news for our Dayton friends…

We’ve officially been accepted as a vendor at the 2nd Street Market! We’ll see you there Sunday, May 10 from 11:00- 3:00!

We could not be more excited to bring Butter + Scotch closer to our Dayton customers. ♥️

Join us at the Rip Rap Mother’s Day Festival this Saturday! Brunch, live music, vendors— all the good stuff!We’ll have f...
05/05/2026

Join us at the Rip Rap Mother’s Day Festival this Saturday! Brunch, live music, vendors— all the good stuff!

We’ll have fresh from the oven favorites ready for gifting, sharing, or keeping all to yourself. (We won’t tell. 😉)

We love to partner with other local businesses! This will be such a fun (and tasty) event. 🌸
04/02/2026

We love to partner with other local businesses! This will be such a fun (and tasty) event. 🌸

Spring is calling and we’re answering with cookies! 🌸We’re so excited to be popping up at the Rip Rap Roadhouse Spring F...
04/02/2026

Spring is calling and we’re answering with cookies! 🌸
We’re so excited to be popping up at the Rip Rap Roadhouse Spring Fest on April 18th! We’ll be there from 11-4 with a fresh lineup of your favorites (and maybe a few new surprises). Come soak up all the spring vibes, support some amazing local vendors, enjoy live music, grab dinner (and a little something sweet) while you’re there. We’d love to see you!

03/28/2026

We won’t be at Market at Mother’s today, but this isn’t goodbye! We’re so excited to share that we’ll be joining the Springfield Farmers Market as a full-time vendor!

If you’re out and about today, please stop by and support the incredible vendors at Mother’s—they are truly something special.

Thank you for loving us so well there. We can’t wait to see you at the Springfield Farmers Market!

(In the meantime, if you run out of cookies, please reach out to us— we’re happy to bake for you!)

Address

New Carlisle, OH
45344

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+19373151892

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butter+Scotch Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Butter+Scotch Bakery:

Share

Category