Legacy Pizza and Bakery

Home
United States
New Albany, IN
Legacy Pizza and Bakery

Legacy Pizza & Bakery
1001 Vincennes Street, Suite 100
Phone: 812-725-0021
New York style pizza, Stromboli, calzones, subs, fresh baked breads and sweets.

Locally owned and operated by Marcy and Rich Doering. Open for dine-in and curbside pick. Call us to place a convenient in car curbside order and we will meet you at your car. Join us for dine-in in our cozy and quiet pizza shop. Reservations are appreciated. Feel free to stop in for daily bread needs or to satisfy your sweet tooth. Reservations are highly recommended during diner hours and for parties larger than 4.

Payment Options: Amex Cash Discover Mastercard Visa

Operating as usual

05/01/2022

🌞Happy Sunday Funday!! We are open from 3-8 today.
Let us cook dinner so you can enjoy this beautiful day!!
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place a Curbside Pickup order or reserve a table. Pick up at our convenient, In-Car-Curbside service on Beeler St. We begin answering phones at 2:30.
❤Grab a Legacy gift card for your Mom or Graduate!! Available in increments of $5 or more.
💥SUNDAY FUNDAY MEAL DEAL $20 - One Small Stromboli & One Small 3 Topping Pizza!!
✨Other Specials:
~Mediterranean Salad $13 - Our Huge House Salad w/Chicken, Banana Peppers, Kalamatas, Feta and Asiago, w/Greek Dressing on the side
~Cheesesteak Sub Sm. $7, Lg. $12
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Ruby Rose Cannoli, Mint Julip Cannoli, Bourbon Bread Pudding, Blueberry Bread Pudding (last day for Blueberry), Chocolate Mousse Tarts, Lemon Meringue Tarts.
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Cinnamon Babka, Pumpernickel, Rye, Rye/Pump Swirl, German Rye, Whole Grain, Brioche Loaves& Buns, White Loaves & Buns, French Country. Select "colored dot" breads are $2 Off today! Shop our breads in store from 3-8, or call and order for Curbside Pickup. Please remember that all breads are first come/call, first served!!
*All prices are valid today only and all items are subject to availability.
#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #sundayfunday #dailybreads #dailyspecials #curbsidepickup #letuscookdinner #lemonmeringue #chocolatemousse

04/30/2022

🌞Happy Saturday!! Legacy is open from 12-9 for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 11:30. Curbside Pickup is on the side of our building on Beeler St. Super easy and we love to do Curbside!! You call in your order, we tell you how long & we will meet you at your car!!
💥Saturday Features:
~$1 Off All Pizzas
~Mediterranean Salad $13 - Our huge House Salad topped w/Chicken, Sirocco Ridge Farm Feta Cheese, Asiago, Kalamatas, Red Onions & Banana Peppers, w/ Greek dressing on the side.
~Cheesesteak Sub - Sm. $7, Lg. $12
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Bourbon Bread Pudding $7, Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Rose Chocolate Cannoli or Mint Julip Cannoli $3.50 each
~Lemon Meringue or Chocolate Mousse Tarts $5 each
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Whole Grain, White, French Country, Cinnamon Babka, Rye, German Rye (Mischbrot), Brioche Loaves and Buns, Sandwich Buns. Select breads will be $1 off today and tomorrow. Ask your server for details or come in to shop and look for the colored dot sticker.

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #dailybreads #dailyspecials #familybusiness #curbsidepickup #supportlocalsmallbusiness #pizzasale #newalbanysmallbusiness

04/29/2022

Ask and you shall receive!! Available at 4:00 today-Lemon Meringue or Chocolate Mousse w/Cashew Brittle. These little pies won’t last long!! 812-725-0021
#tinytarts #lemonmeringue #chocolatemousse #whatsyourlegacy

04/29/2022

🌞Happy Friday!! Legacy is open from 12-9 today for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. Call-In orders please pickup at our Curbside on Beeler St, right across from the New Albany High School sign. We come to your car and take care of everything there! Dine-In reservations are highly suggested, especially for dinner. We begin answering phones at 11:30.
✨Friday Specials:
~$1 Off Large Subs, Reuben & Muffaletta Sandwiches.
~Mediterranean Salad $13 - Our huge House Salad w/Chicken, Feta, Asiago, Banana Peppers, Kalamatas, Red Onions & Greek Dressing on the side.
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Ruby Rose Chocolate Cannoli or Mint Julip Cannoli $3.50 each
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6 or Bourbon Bread Pudding $7
~All regular sweets available!
~We have some special sweets in the works, but this week has been extremely busy so please be patient as we catch up this morning!
🥖🍞Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Cinnamon Babka, Whole Grain, Pumpernickel, Rye, Mischbrot (German, unseeded Rye), Brioche Loaves & Buns, Sandwich Buns, French Country.
*All items are subject to availability and all prices are valid today only.

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailybreads #dailyspecials #bettertogether #livingthedream #whoneedsadayoff #curbsidepickup #gottapaythebills

04/28/2022

🌞Happy Thursday!! We are open from 12-9 today for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order for Curbside-Pickup or Reserve a Table for Dine-In. We begin answering phones at 11:30.
💥Today is Hazelwood Middle School Pto - New Albany 47150 Spirit Day. If you are supporting this event let us know by showing us the flyer or mentioning Hazelwood.
✨Thursday Specials:
~$1 Off Any Pizzas w/3+ Toppings
~Mediterranean Salad $13 - Our huge, House Salad w/Chicken, Feta, Asiago, Red Onions, Banana Peppers, Kalamatas & Greek Dressing (on the side).
~Cheesesteak Sub - Sm. $7, Lg. $12
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Bourbon Bread Pudding $7, or Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Bananas Foster Tarts $6
~Ruby Rose or Mint Julip Cannoli $3.50
~All regular Cookies, Brownies, Blondies & Original Cannoli all available.
🥖🍞Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Rye, Mischbrot (unseeded German Rye), Pumpernickel, Whole Grain, Brioche, Sandwich Buns, Crostini/Croutons.
All breads are subject to availability, as are all menu items. All prices are valid today only.

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailybreads #dailyspecials #curbsidepickup #hazelwoodspiritday #bettertogether

04/27/2022

🌞Happy Wednesday!! We are open from 12-9 today for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 11:30. When calling in an order for Curbside, please pick up from your vehicle at our Curbside service on Beeler St, just across from New Albany High School, off of Vincennes St.
✨Check out our regular menu under the MENU button on our FB page.
⭐Today we are hosting a Spirit Day for St. John Paul II Catholic School. If you are supporting this event, either mention the school or show us a pic of the flyer and we will donate 20% of your total to them.
❤️Get your Grad, Mom, or any Legacy Lover in your life a Legacy Gift Card!! Available all day, everyday!
💥Today is $1 Off Stromboli Day!!
🔥Other Specials for this Week:
~Mediterranean Salad - $13 Our huge, house salad w/Chicken, Banana Peppers, Red Onions, Kalamatas, Feta, Asiago & Greek Dressing on the side. A meal in itself, or great to share.
~Cheesesteak Sub - Sm. $7, Lg. $12
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Rose OR Mint Julip Cannoli $3.50 each. Made fresh to order!
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6 OR Bourbon Bread Pudding $7
~Bananas Foster Tarts $6
~Chocolate Hazelnut Brioche "Danish" $2
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Whole Grain, Pumpernickel, Rye, German Rye (Mischbrot), Cinnamon Babka, and like usual, more is in the works. Please call for pricing and availability on breads, or stop by during business hours and shop our bread selection.
*All breads, specials and regular menu items are subject to availability. All prices are valid today only.
#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailyspecials #curbsidepickup #dailybreads #bettertogether #artisannotexpensive #preservativefreebreads

04/26/2022

We just found out that today is National Pretzel Day!! What a great excuse to get a Pretzel Stromboli!! Salted soft pretzel crust stuffed with loads of Ham, Mozz & a tiny bit of yellow mustard, served w/a side of Cheese sauce!! Enough for up to 3 people, IF you like to share!!
#whatsyourlegacy #everydayispretzelday

04/26/2022

🌞Happy Tuesday!! Legacy is open from 12-9 today for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
💥Today is S. Ellen Jones Elementary School Spirit Day!! Mention S. Ellen when ordering and we will donate 20% of our order to the PTO. You can also show us a pic of the flyer.
☎️Call us at 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 11:30. Reservations are not required but are extremely helpful for parties larger than 6.
💥Tuesday Specials:
~$1 Off Calzones
~Mediterranean Salad $13 - Our huge house salad topped with Feta, Asiago, Banana Peppers, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives and Chicken. Served w/Greek Dressing on the side.
~Cheesesteak Sub - Sm. $7, Lg. $13 Toasted w/Provolone, Onions & fully dressed w/lettuce, tomatoes, pickles & Italian dressing.
~Shrimp Alfredo $13 served w/Garlic Bread
~Bourbon Bread Pudding, $7, or Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Banana Fosters Tarts $6
~Ruby Rose OR Mint Julip Cannoli $3.50 each
~Chocolate Hazelnut Brioche "Danish" $2
🥖🍞Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Whole Grain, Cinnamon Babka, French Country.
Today is the beginning of our week and we are in production of other breads. We will try to post this evening when other breads are ready, business permitting.
*All items are subject to availability and all prices are valid today only.
#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #sellenjonesspiritday #dailyspecials #curbsidepickup #newalbanysmallbusinesses #bettertogether

04/25/2022

⭐️This Weeks Spirit Events at Legacy Pizza & Bakery⭐️
~Tuesday, 4/26/22, @S. Ellen Jones Elementary School
~Wednesday, 4/27/2022, St. John Paul II Catholic School
~Thursday, 4/28/2022, Hazelwood Middle School Pto - New Albany 47150
Join us from 12-9 for Dine-In or In-Car-Curbside-Pickup to support these schools. Just mention the school on their day or show us a pic of the flyer for your school and we will donate 20% of your total to their PTO!!
View our menu under the MENU tab on our FB page. It's easy to order or place a table reservation- just call 812-725-0021. We begin taking orders at 11:30 each Spirit Day!! Curbside-Pickup from your car on Beeler St., across from New Albany High School.

04/24/2022

🌞Happy Sunday!! Legacy is open from 3-8 today for Dine-In & In-Car-Curbside-Pickup.
☎Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 2:30. Pickup from your car at our curbside serve on Beeler St., across from New Albany High School!!
*Our menu is available on our FB page under the MENU button. Don't forget we have added our Chicken Alfredo, Muffaletta & Hot Veggie Sub to the regular menu!!
💥Sunday Features:
~Sunday Funday Meal Deal: One Small Stromboli & One Small 3 Topping Pizza for just $20. Feed the family and save over $5!!
~Cheesesteak Sub Sm. $7, Lg. $12 - Legacy Sub Roll, toasted w/Provolone, Onions & thin slices of Steak, fully dressed w/Italian dressing, Tomatoes, Pickles & Lettuce.
~Shrimp Alfredo $13 Served w/Legacy Garlic Bread.
~Rose Cannoli $3.50, Bourbon Bread Pudding $7, Blueberry Bread Pudding $6, Bananas Foster Tarts $6
~Chocolate-Hazelnut Brioche "Danish" $2
~Blueberry or Cherry Tarts are 50% off today!
🥖🍞 Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Brioche, Pesto, Whole Wheat, Whole Grain, Cinnamon Babka. Select breads are $1 Off today. Just look for the colored dot sticker, or ask your server when calling!! All breads are first call/come, first served!
*All items are subject to availability and all prices are valid today only!!

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #sundayfunday #dailyspecials #dailybreads #artisannotexpensive #preservativefree #supportlocalsmallbusinesses #curbsidepickup #livingadream #bettertogether

04/23/2022

🌞Happy Saturday!! We are open from 12-9 for Dine-In & In-Car-Curbside-Pickup.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 11:30 today. If you're looking to avoid the Thunder crowds and watch the fireworks from home, let Legacy take care of dinner tonight!!
View our full menu under the MENU button on our FB page.
💥Saturday Specials:
~🍕$1 Off All Pizzas - Create Your Own or order any of our Premiums by name
~Cheesesteak Sub - toasted w/Provolone & served fully dressed w/Italian dressing. Sm. $7, Lg. $12
~🍤Shrimp Alfredo $13 - served w/Legacy Garlic Bread
~Don't forget, we have added our Chicken Alfredo, Hot Veggie Sub & Muffaletta to our regular menu. Our Chicken Alfredo has had an upgrade and now comes w/a larger portion of white meat chicken breast.
~Bourbon Bread Pudding $7
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Bananas Foster Tarts $6
~Cherry Tarts & Berry Tarts on sale for $4 each
~Rose Cannoli $3.50
~All cookies, blondies, brownies and original cannoli available
🥖🥪Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Cinnamon Babka, Whole Grain, White, Whole Wheat, Brioche Loaves & Buns, Pesto. All breads are first come, first served!!
All of our breads are made from scratch and are preservative free!!
*All specials and prices are valid today only. All items are subject to availability.

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailyspecials #dailybreads

04/22/2022

So this just happened….Bananas Foster Tarts w/Meringue and Cashew Brittle!! Only at Legacy Pizza and Bakery. Get yours soon! These will not last long. Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. Keep an eye on our posts for other specials coming this weekend!! #whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #ourkitchenisalaboratory

04/22/2022

🌞Happy Friday!! Legacy is open from 12-9 for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In.
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table! We begin answering phones at 11:30. Slots for dinner pickup can fill up quickly, so call early and we will get you on the books for this evening. Pickup from your car at our Curbside service on Beeler Street!
Our full menu is viewable under the MENU button on our FB page.
🥖🥪Today all Large Subs and Sandwiches are $1 off. This includes our Muffaletta and Reuben.
🍤Shrimp Alfredo $13; served w/Legacy Garlic Bread. Chicken Alfredo also available for $10.
💥Special Sweets:
~Bananas Foster Tarts w/Cashew Brittle $5 each
~Blueberry or Cherry Tarts on special today for $4 each
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Rose Cannoli is back for April and May, in honor of Mother's Day & Derby!! Ruby Red Chocolate, Ricotta and Rose sugar, shell is drizzled w/White Chocolate & sprinkled w/Rose Sugar!! Creamy and decadent!
All cookies, brownies, blondies & Original Cannoli all available.
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Brioche Loaves & Burger Buns (it's gonna be a grillin' out kinda weekend so get your buns today!!), Whole Wheat, Whole Grain, Pesto, Bialy, French Country. We will have Cinnamon Babka after 4pm, time permitting.
*All breads are subject to availability, as are all specials and regular menu items. All prices are valid today only

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #dailyspecials #dailybreads #familybusiness #artisannotexpensive

04/21/2022

🌞Happy Thursday!! We are hosting @blessingsinabackpackfloydco Spirit Day today!! If you are supporting this cause, just mention Blessings or show us the flyer when ordering and we will donate 20% of your total.
⏰We are open from 12-9 today for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to place an order or reserve a table. We begin answering phones at 11:30. You may view our full menu under the MENU button on our FB page. Bread prices are available by phone or in store.
💥Thursday Specials:
~$1 Off all Pizzas w/3 or more toppings. This includes all of our Premium Pizzas!!
~Don't forget that we have added our Hot Veggie Sub, Muffaletta & Chicken Alfredo to our regular menu.
~Shrimp Alfredo $13
~Ruby Rose Chocolate Cannoli $3.50
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Blueberry or Cherry Chocolate Crumb Tarts $5 each
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Cinnamon Babka, Whole Grain, Brioche Loaves & Buns, Pesto, Focaccia, French Country. All breads are subject to availability, as are all menu items.
All prices are valid today only.
#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailybreads #dailyspecials #supportkids #blessingsinabackpackspiritday #spiritday

04/20/2022

French country boules. #artisannotexpensive

04/20/2022

🌞Happy Wednesday!!
Today is Mount Tabor PTO Spirit Day!! We are open from 12-9 for In-Car-Curbside-Pickup & Dine-In. Just say Mt. Tabor if you are supporting this event, or show us the flyer!! We will donate 20% of your total to the PTO!
☎️Call 812-725-0021 to Reserve a Table or place a Curbside order. We begin answering phones at 11:30. Reservations are extremely helpful! Calling in an order? We will meet you at your car at our convenient Curbside Pickup on Beeler St, right across from New Albany High School.
💥Today's Specials:
~$1 Off All Strombolis, including our Pretzel 'Boli!!
~Shrimp Alfredo w/Garlic Bread $13
~Blueberry Bread Pudding $6
~Blueberry or Cherry Tarts - $5 each
~Rose Cannoli is back!! $3.50 each. These will be available after 1:00pm today and continue through Mother's Day. Keep an eye out for the Mint Julip Cannoli, coming soon!!
~All cookies, brownies, Butterfinger Blondies & Original Cannoli available.
🍞🥖Breads: Baguettes, Moose Sourdough, Brioche Loaves & Buns, Pesto, Whole Grain, Cinnamon Babka, Focaccia. All remaining Dinner Rolls & Hot Cross Buns are $1 a pack!! All breads are subject to availability.

#whatsyourlegacy #momandpoppizzashop #familybusiness #dailyspecials #dailybreads #artisannotexpensive #mounttaborptospiritday #supportlocalsmallbusiness #supportkids

Address

1001 Vincennes St
New Albany, IN
47150

Opening Hours

Tuesday	12pm - 9pm
Wednesday	12pm - 9pm
Thursday	12pm - 9pm
Friday	12pm - 9pm
Saturday	12pm - 9pm
Sunday	3pm - 8pm

Telephone

+18127250021

Products

We offer a wide selection of fresh baked sweets, breads, and fresh salads, subs, pizza, east coast Stromboli and calzones, as well as real ricotta filled cannoli, made fresh to order.

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Legacy Pizza and Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Legacy Pizza and Bakery:

Videos

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Videos
Claim ownership or report listing

Nearby bakeries

Sweet Stuff Bakery
323 E Spring St
The Bean Stalk Urban Farm and Bakery
2516 E Elm St
Z's Cookie Cakes
47150
Kayla's Cakery
47150
Bread and Breakfast
47150
410 Bakery
140 E Main St
Williams Bakery
1051 N Clark Blvd, Clarksville
KCS Cakes
Palmyra 47164
Frosting On Top
Southern Indiana, Clarksville
El Mercadito Grocery
906 Eastern Blvd, Clarksville
Panadería y Pastelería el Mercadito
906 EASTERN BLVD, Clarksville
Auntie Anne's Pretzels Green Tree Mall
757 Lewis & Clark Pkwy E K-10, Clarksville
Panera Bread
1040 Veterans Parkway, Clarksville
Winnie's Decadent Desserts
3901 Booker Ave
AddieCakes Sweet Shoppe
Louisville 40211

Other Bakeries in New Albany

Jack's Bakery
4510 Charlestown Road Suite 300
Leaven Bakery
1515 East Market Street
Sweet Stuff Bakery
323 E Spring St
The Bean Stalk Urban Farm and Bakery
2516 E Elm St
LuLu B's Cookies
47150
Cobbler's Kitchen
47150
Danielle's Delights
47150
A J Anderson Designs
47122
Coffee Crossing
4212 Charlestown Rd
Bread and Breakfast
47150
Z's Cookie Cakes
47150
410 Bakery
140 E Main St

Show All

Comments

It's today, it's today!! Spread the word to Hazelwood staff and families!! Tell everyone not to forget to mention Hazelwood when ordering!!

If anybody is wondering where some of the best pizza in the area is, well this is the place. They are family owned and operated. They make fresh bread a desserts daily and they are to die for. I also have to mention the price... My gf and I ordered a large 3 topping which is a 16in 2 drinks an order of bruschetta bread sticks and an amazing lemon tart big enough to split 2 ways and all of that came to a total of 30 dollars. They are located in New Albany and well worth the quick drive. Please support local restaurants because as most of us know many are closing their doors for good. Family's are loosing their lively hoods. They offer curbside pick up and dine-in. They also take orders for homemade cheesecakes and other desserts!!! This place has just a warm environment that is so inviting. They also offer gluten free and vegan options

whyyy did it take me so long to try this place?? -- AMAZING 🍝Spaghetti Squash with oven roasted Shiitake mushrooms & meatballs with garlic focaccia bread. You're def missing out if you haven't had it, super easy curbside pickup 🤤

🍕🍕❤️❤️👍🏼👍🏼I ordered your Margherita pizza last night and it was delicious!!!! Will definitely be ordering from Legacy again! 🍕🍕🤗🤗💃🏻💃🏻

Not only is the pizza simply wonderful, their Pumpernickel bread is so delicious and they will slice it for free! LOVE their food

First time eating here. We got 2 pizzas and breadsticks. The pizza was just like the pizza I got when I was a kid in NJ. The cannoli was a treat. We will definitely be back.

Today, I found the, “best Italian food ever🙌🏽 pizza out of this 🌎....i’ll be back really soon✌🏽🤍❤️🙌🏽💋

Thanks Legacy Pizza for awesome pizza for our COVID-19 Saturday Date Night dinner (aka carry out and enjoy at home) 🍕👍👏🙏🏻😃

Just tried Legacy for the first time and WOW amazing!!!! We definitely will be back!!!!

Ordered Legacy Pizza last night and it was AWESOME, this is our go to pizza place. Decided to get the cinnamon rolls and they did not disappoint. Enjoying them for breakfast this morning.

Been reading reviews October 7 2020 Legacy Pizza will give 20% off order if mention Hazlewood Middle School.

My spaghetti squash was fabulous!!! Thank you.

05/01/2022

04/30/2022

04/29/2022

04/29/2022

04/28/2022

04/27/2022

04/26/2022

04/26/2022

04/25/2022

04/24/2022

04/23/2022

04/22/2022

04/22/2022

04/21/2022

04/20/2022

04/20/2022

Address

Opening Hours

Telephone

Products

Alerts

Contact The Business

Videos

Shortcuts

Category

Nearby bakeries

Other Bakeries in New Albany

Comments