The Whimsical Cookie

06/03/2026

🍦 SCOOP THERE IT IS! 🍦

Our newest cookie drop is here and it’s giving all the sweet summer ice cream shop vibes! ☀️🍪

This week’s LIMITED EDITION flavors:

🍪 Cookie Butter Bliss
🥜 Butter Pecan Praline
🍌 Banana Split
🍫 Hot Fudge Sundae
🍓🍫🍦 Neopolitan

🎉 GIVEAWAY TIME! 🎉

To enter:

❤️ Like this post
📲 Share this post to help us spread the word
👯 Tag 2 friends who need cookies in their life

❤️
Winner will be announced Saturday!

📍37 Bank Street Suite 11, New Albany, IN

Which flavor are you grabbing first? 👇👇👇

✨Please remember only I will post the winner! I do not tell people in the comments they won or send DMs

06/03/2026

06/02/2026

Doughs we have made this morning for this week’s limited flavor drop!

Any guesses? Giving you the hint from Sunday too!

Watcha got? 👇👇👇

06/02/2026

This little kitchen has been working overtime lately. 💗

We spent today restocking, planning, and getting ready for another week at The Whimsical Cookie.

Every cookie that leaves our shop starts right here in this tiny space.

Thank you for keeping us busy. We don’t take it for granted.

06/01/2026

🍪 Have you tried one of our Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes yet?

We’ve been getting lots of calls and questions about cookie cakes lately, and more and more of you are discovering them as we’ve started keeping them in the case on weekends!

Made with our delicious chocolate chip cookie and decorated with signature buttercream, they’re perfect for birthdays, graduations, celebrations, or just because. 💖

We offer:
✨ 9-inch Cookie Cakes
✨ 13-inch Cookie Cakes
✨ Letter-Shaped Cookie Cakes
✨ Number-Shaped Cookie Cakes

Custom cookie cakes can be requested through our website at thewhimsicalcookie.com. Please note that all custom cookie cakes require a minimum of 24 hours’ notice and are available by pre-order only.

At this time, we are unable to customize a cookie cake while you wait in the store, so be sure to plan ahead for your special occasion!

Have an upcoming celebration? We’d love to make it a little sweeter. 🍪🎉

05/31/2026

Before the cookies hit the case, a whole lot happens behind the scenes. 🍪💕

Dough gets mixed. Dough gets balled. Cookies get baked. Boxes get packed. Orders get finished. And somehow our tiny kitchen team makes it all come together.

Then we unlock the door… and the cookie people show up. 🥹

Watching this hidden little cookie shop explode has been so much fun. Thank you for supporting our small business, sharing our posts, bringing your friends, and showing up week after week.

We can’t wait to do it all again this weekend. 💖

05/31/2026

🌟 Calling All Young Entrepreneurs! 🌟

The Whimsical Cookie is excited to participate in the Dream Big Youth Entrepreneur Walk in Downtown New Albany, and we’re looking for a kid entrepreneur to host at our location!

Do you know a young person with a business, creative idea, handmade products, baked goods, artwork, or another entrepreneurial venture they’d love to share with the community? We’d love to hear from them! Tell us who you know in the comments 👇👇👇👇

A baking-related business would be especially fun in our space, but it’s absolutely not required. We’re open to all kinds of young entrepreneurs who are excited to showcase their talents and products.

Interested? Email Amanda at [email protected] with a little information about the business and what they’d like to sell or showcase.

Let’s help encourage the next generation of dreamers, creators, and business owners! 💕

05/31/2026

I’ve been working on next week’s flavor drop, and let’s just say… I’m pretty excited about this one. 👀💖

Any guesses?