ToothAche Bakery & Catering

ToothAche Bakery & Catering We are a classic bakery with an urban flair. Tracee Lewis’ love for desserts set the foundation.

Tracee enrolled in school at Ivy Tech to study and perfect her craft and soon graduated in 2016 with her Baking and Pastry Arts degree and thus ToothAche Bakery was born. After creating her menu, she began taking items to the Miller Beach Farmer's Market and soon branched out to other market's in the area. During the markets off season, ToothAche Bakery continues to provide desserts to their loyal

customer base, cater various events, ship baked goods across the US and hosts pop-up bakeries in the local area.

Our infamous brownies are delicious, fudgy and SHIPPABLE!!!! That’s right, our brownies are delivered to your door! What...
08/25/2026

Our infamous brownies are delicious, fudgy and SHIPPABLE!!!! That’s right, our brownies are delivered to your door! What are you waiting on? Place your order today 💜💜💜

“As American as Apple Pie…”There’s no pie as classy and as well loved as a good old fashioned Apple pie. Made with hand...
08/24/2026

“As American as Apple Pie…”
There’s no pie as classy and as well loved as a good old fashioned Apple pie. Made with hand picked Granny Smith apples that are peeled and sliced by hand, our Apple pie is something to write home about! We offer lattice or crumble topped and it also can be made gluten free 💜💜💜

Cherry Pie is a classic flavor! We make our filling from scratch so don’t be surprised when you take a spoonful and the ...
08/21/2026

Cherry Pie is a classic flavor! We make our filling from scratch so don’t be surprised when you take a spoonful and the flavors slap your taste buds.
Available for our gluten-free customers as well 💜

To order: [email protected] or 615.784.3404

08/20/2026
With everyone doing cookies and cakes nowadays, I wanted to do something different. Living here in Nashville and working...
08/19/2026

With everyone doing cookies and cakes nowadays, I wanted to do something different. Living here in Nashville and working at a grocery store you see the need for all kinds of desserts…freshly baked, from scratched and reasonably priced.

So I’m doing pies! If you’re looking for that scratch crust, homemade fillings and delicious flavoring, ToothAche Bakery is your go to place!

I didn’t forget my gluten-free customers! Thanks to , I was able to make a great tasting gluten-free version of banana ...
08/13/2026

I didn’t forget my gluten-free customers! Thanks to , I was able to make a great tasting gluten-free version of banana pudding for my bonus kid to enjoy as well!

Ok, I’m just experimenting but uhm, this biscoff banana pudding hit hard! Biscoff has been around for a long time and I’...
08/12/2026

Ok, I’m just experimenting but uhm, this biscoff banana pudding hit hard! Biscoff has been around for a long time and I’m sure everyone, including myself was asking how many more “new items” can people make with that cookie butter…so I just wanted to try it and WOW. That is all.

The banana pudding cake is becoming so popular, I had to make it to go! If you’re looking for your own personal portion ...
08/11/2026

The banana pudding cake is becoming so popular, I had to make it to go! If you’re looking for your own personal portion or need a quick fix…done! Also, it travels well 😉

This is becoming one of the favorites! Banana Pudding cake 💜 Thanks Krystyn for the order!Cake: 6in yellow cake with ban...
08/10/2026

This is becoming one of the favorites! Banana Pudding cake 💜 Thanks Krystyn for the order!

Cake: 6in yellow cake with banana custard and bananas filling with whipped buttercream and garnished with banana cream and vanilla wafers.

08/01/2026

If you know me, I’m super big on organization. Come take a trip with me to

Address

Nashville, TN

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7am - 4pm
Wednesday 7am - 4pm
Thursday 7am - 4pm
Friday 7am - 4pm
Saturday 7am - 3pm

Telephone

+12197798347

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when ToothAche Bakery & Catering posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category