Cheeky Thumbprints

Cheeky Thumbprints Welcome to Cheeky Thumbprints! I make homemade customizable thumbprint style cookies made to order!

Custom assortments are always a great option for your holiday events!
11/16/2025

Custom assortments are always a great option for your holiday events!

New flavor drop! Coconut cream cookies 🥥
08/01/2025

New flavor drop! Coconut cream cookies 🥥

07/28/2025

Welcome to Cheeky Thumbprints!

I make custom thumbprint style cookies. Soft and buttery, unique seasonal cookie flavors along with tried and true favorites and a delicious variety of fillings! You’re welcome to mix and match flavors or try one of our favorite staples!

-$20 for one dozen cookies
> For large orders (over 4 dozen), a deposit is required and will amount to half of the total cost.

*one cookie flavor per dozen*

Cookie Menu:

-Almond Raspberry (almond cookie coated in almonds and filled with raspberry preserves)

-Strawberry Coco-nut (plain cookie filled with strawberry preserves and coated with almond and coconut)

-PBJ (peanut butter cookie filled with strawberry/grape jam)

-Lemon curd (lemon zested shortbread cookie filled with lemon curd {or seasonal fruit curd} and sprinkled with powdered sugar

-Peanut butter blossoms (peanut butter cookie with Hershey kiss center)

-Nutella (chocolate or vanilla cookie coated in hazelnuts and filled with Nutella)

-Dulce de leche (homemade milk caramel filled shortbread cookies coated in coconut/sugar)

☀️ SEASONAL MENU ☀️

☕️ chai latte (chai spiced shortbread cookie filled with creamy white chocolate)

🎃 pumpkin pie (sugar coated shortbread cookie with pumpkin pie filling)

🥧 apple pie (cinnamon sugar coated shortbread cookie with apple pie filling)

♥️ cranberry curd (sugar dusted shortbread cookie filled with cranberry curd)

Thank you! 😊

New flavor sneak peak 👀 Homemade Dulce de Leche filled shortbread thumbprint 🤤
05/01/2025

New flavor sneak peak 👀 Homemade Dulce de Leche filled shortbread thumbprint 🤤

Peppermint Chocolate Blossoms 🎄
12/13/2024

Peppermint Chocolate Blossoms 🎄

New fall flavor drop! 🎃 Pumpkin Chai Latte
09/20/2024

New fall flavor drop! 🎃 Pumpkin Chai Latte

Find our cookies out in the wild this week at Roast & Refuel in Muncy! They’ll have matcha latte, peanut butter blossom...
08/11/2024

Find our cookies out in the wild this week at Roast & Refuel in Muncy!
They’ll have matcha latte, peanut butter blossom and lemon curd cookies available this week starting Monday, August 12th!

Address

Muncy, PA
17756

Telephone

+17188640077

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cheeky Thumbprints posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category