Casey's Cakes

Casey's Cakes Casey's Cakes, formally Casey's Creations, is a well established, small business, bakery. Located in

Good morning everybody thank you so much for coming to the market last night! For those wondering if there’s leftovers… ...
05/30/2026

Good morning everybody thank you so much for coming to the market last night! For those wondering if there’s leftovers… Come into the shop we have some fresh items baked this morning and ready for you! 9700 W. Smith St., Yorktown Cocoa & Cream Collective is where you’ll be able to find a cozy seat where you can order an espresso and bacon egg and cheese croissant! We have very delicious breakfast sandwiches made to order! We also have savory scones with your choice of bacon or sausage, and cheese. We have fresh cinnamon rolls, Key lime Macarons, gluten friendly apple cider donuts, peach danishes, cream cheese danishes, sourdough bread, bagels, bacon egg & cheese pasties, blueberry, cheesecake cookies, chocolate chip cookies, brownies, chocolate cookie dough cake slices, funfetti cake slices, lemon blueberry cake slices, cannoli, ding dongs, apple dumplings, and cheesecakes! We will be here until 4 PM today.

All set up and ready to go at the Yorktown Farm & Artisan Market! We’ll be here until 7:30!
05/29/2026

All set up and ready to go at the Yorktown Farm & Artisan Market! We’ll be here until 7:30!

Guess who will be at the market with all of your favorites! Today is the first Friday of the Yorktown Farm & Artisan Mar...
05/29/2026

Guess who will be at the market with all of your favorites! Today is the first Friday of the Yorktown Farm & Artisan Market market! We’ll be there 4:30-7:30 in our usual spot under Cocoa & Cream! I’ll be there personally tonight to kick off the season!
We’ll have peanut butter cookie sandwiches, chocolate cookie dough cake, lemon blueberry cake, buckeyes, nobakes, apple cider donuts, cinnamon rolls, brownies, apple dumplings and more!!

The first cookie class that I’ll be hosting at Cocoa & Cream Collective! This is happening this Saturday before Mother’s...
04/24/2026

The first cookie class that I’ll be hosting at Cocoa & Cream Collective! This is happening this Saturday before Mother’s Day so it’s a perfect gift for Mom! Get your tickets there’s only 20 spots available. 

Good morning everyone! I haven’t posted in a while, but just wanted to say come on in to Cocoa & Cream Collective today,...
04/09/2026

Good morning everyone! I haven’t posted in a while, but just wanted to say come on in to Cocoa & Cream Collective today, and grab some goodies! I’ll be in the kitchen if you want to say hello 😃

Last week was so amazing at Cocoa & Cream Collective! It was our first week open and the turn out was unimaginable! We c...
03/02/2026

Last week was so amazing at Cocoa & Cream Collective! It was our first week open and the turn out was unimaginable! We could hardly keep items stocked in the case due to high demand.
Did you know that we use all from scratch ingredients in everything we make? No mixes, no outsourcing. It’s all made with 100% high quality ingredients. We crack each egg and weigh each gram of flour.
We’re already conjuring up new ideas for this week! We’ll be open this Thursday-Sunday! Time to prep 😎 we hope to see you soon!

02/15/2026

Even though we aren't open quite yet, we have a few Valentine doggie treats you can win!

To enter, visit our online menu, https://cocoaandcream.com/order, and place in the comments the first thing you plan to order when we are open.

We will select 3 winners of the oversized doggie Valentine tonight!

Happy Valentine’s Day! Here’s an updated list of what I have available today
02/14/2026

Happy Valentine’s Day! Here’s an updated list of what I have available today

Tomorrow is Valentine’s Day and I heard you still need some dessert! Bittersweet post! This is the very last bit of my ...
02/13/2026

Tomorrow is Valentine’s Day and I heard you still need some dessert!
Bittersweet post! This is the very last bit of my offerings as Casey’s Cakes. I did not offer Valentine’s Day this year because we are moving into the new bakery, but I did want to have a little something extra to offer.

1 sugar cookie decorating kit with 6 heart cookies, sprinkles and frosting $20
1 strawberry cheesecake $45
This is it, nothing else will be made out of Casey’s cakes, kitchen. You can find my things at Cocoa & Cream Collective where I will be the lead baker, starting in a few weeks 🥰

02/08/2026

I may regret this post later 🙈🤣 but this coming week is my last week as Casey’s Cakes! My last orders as a business I’ve had for 13 years. If you’d like to add to the chaos and get on my books, I’ll be welcome it! To my husband- if you’re reading this, I’m sorry. Look away. 🤣❤️
Be sure to follow me on my new journey as the lead baker of Cocoa & Cream Collective ❤️

Address

Muncie, IN
47302

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm

Telephone

+17653512280

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey's Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Casey's Cakes:

Shortcuts

Share

Category