Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop

Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop Miss Molly's is a cozy neighborhood cafe that specializes in fresh, seasonally inspired meals and sc
(416)

Little reminder that we’re always happy to warm up your bakery item for you.We have a small oven behind the counter that...
05/29/2026

Little reminder that we’re always happy to warm up your bakery item for you.

We have a small oven behind the counter that makes things like our rosemary biscuit, mushroom swiss & caramelized onion hand pie, and apple almond galette even better warm. Just ask when you order 🙂

Good food is important, but good people are what make a place feel special.A few of our front of house team members — so...
05/26/2026

Good food is important, but good people are what make a place feel special.

A few of our front of house team members — some newer faces, some who have been with us for a couple of years now — and all a big part of what makes Miss Molly’s what it is. We’re lucky to head into summer with such a great group behind the counter each day ☀️

Our Spring Crumb Club winner is here: the Blueberry Cheesecake Cornmeal Galette 🫐Blueberry filling and a lemony cheeseca...
05/19/2026

Our Spring Crumb Club winner is here: the Blueberry Cheesecake Cornmeal Galette 🫐

Blueberry filling and a lemony cheesecake layer tucked inside our crunchy cornmeal all-butter pie dough, finished with a cream cheese glaze. It’s now available daily in the bakery case.

If you’d like to be part of choosing future seasonal specials like this one, Summer Crumb Club signups are now open:
missmollyscafe.com/the-crumb-club

Mother’s Day weekend special 🌸Our Chocolate Raspberry Cupcakes are here for the weekend — rich chocolate cake topped wit...
05/09/2026

Mother’s Day weekend special 🌸

Our Chocolate Raspberry Cupcakes are here for the weekend — rich chocolate cake topped with fresh raspberry Italian meringue buttercream, finished with a fresh raspberry and delicate florals.

Each cupcake is packaged individually, making them an easy little gift to bring to brunch, dinner, or to someone who deserves something sweet.

Available in the cafe all weekend while they last.

Nearly 300 teachers fed this week across Wauwatosa and Milwaukee.It was a busy few days of prep, packing, and deliveries...
05/08/2026

Nearly 300 teachers fed this week across Wauwatosa and Milwaukee.

It was a busy few days of prep, packing, and deliveries—but not something we take lightly. Showing appreciation for educators who give so much of themselves every day is something we’re proud to be part of. Happy Teacher Appreciation Week!

Grateful for the trust from our local schools 🤍

Mother’s Day is next weekend! 💗If you’re planning ahead, we’ve got you—brunch at home, cakes, and a few thoughtful extra...
05/03/2026

Mother’s Day is next weekend! 💗

If you’re planning ahead, we’ve got you—brunch at home, cakes, and a few thoughtful extras, all made from scratch.

Pre-orders close Monday, May 4.
Pickup is Saturday, May 9.

Order here: missmollyscafe.com/holidays

We’re looking for a part-time Production Baker to join our team.This is a great fit for someone with professional bakery...
05/01/2026

We’re looking for a part-time Production Baker to join our team.

This is a great fit for someone with professional bakery experience who enjoys early mornings, working with their hands, and being part of a kitchen that values doing things the right way.

2–3 days/week (Monday required)
7:00am start (earlier shifts available)

You’ll be helping with wholesale bake-off and daily production—cookies, muffins, scones, biscuits, pie dough, and more.

We’re a from-scratch cafe that values high standards, consistency, and a strong team environment.

Learn more and apply through the link in our bio.

Mother’s Day pre-orders are officially live 🌿This year’s menu was designed by moms — for moms — so trust us, we kept it ...
04/18/2026

Mother’s Day pre-orders are officially live 🌿

This year’s menu was designed by moms — for moms — so trust us, we kept it simple, thoughtful, and actually enjoyable.

Whether you’re planning the day yourself or sending this as a gentle hint… we’ve got you covered.

Spring Lemon Berry Cake — $55
Lemon cake, elderberry syrup, berry mascarpone, vanilla buttercream

Mother’s Day Brunch for Six — $120
Choice of quiche, fresh fruit, strawberry mint salad, and housemade muffins

Strawberries & Cream Galette Bundle — $45
Buttery crust, fresh strawberries + mascarpone, served with a quart of housemade vanilla custard

Cinnamon Rolls (6) — $20
Soft, fresh baked, finished with cream cheese frosting

🌸 Pickup: Saturday, May 9 | 10am–2pm
No pickup on Mother’s Day
Orders close Monday, May 4 at 5pm

Order at: www.missmollyscafe.com/holidays

⚡️ UPDATE ⚡️Power is back on—we’re opening at 9am! Breakfast, lunch, and beverages are all up and running. Pastry case w...
04/14/2026

⚡️ UPDATE ⚡️

Power is back on—we’re opening at 9am!

Breakfast, lunch, and beverages are all up and running. Pastry case will be a little light to start, but we’ll be baking and restocking as the morning goes on 🍪
____________________________________________

⚠️ Delayed Opening Today ⚠️

After that crazy storm last night, we’re currently without power and will be opening later than usual today.

We don’t have an exact time just yet, but we’re keeping a close eye on things and will update you as soon as we can!

Fingers crossed we’ll be up and running for lunchtime 🤞

Thanks so much for your patience—we’ll keep you posted!

Good food starts with good people — and you can see it in every step.From prep to pastry, it all comes down to the team ...
04/10/2026

Good food starts with good people — and you can see it in every step.

From prep to pastry, it all comes down to the team behind it.
Grateful for the care they bring to the kitchen every single day.

Shoutout to Sarah, our head pastry chef 🤍

Brie, almond & berry handpies — in the case every day.

Address

9201 W. Center Street
Milwaukee, WI
53222

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7:30am - 2pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 2pm
Thursday 7:30am - 2pm
Friday 7:30am - 2pm
Saturday 7:30am - 2pm
Sunday 7:30am - 2pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share