Sweets by Shay

06/21/2026

Calling all Lady Gaga fans! ❤️🎤

I had so much fun creating this custom vintage-style cake, and the best part? I made the Lady Gaga topper myself! Every detail was customized to bring this theme together.

If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind cake for your next celebration, I’d love to create something just for you!

📩 Send me a message to book.
📍Milwaukee pickup only.

06/20/2026

🌌💜 Happy 11th Birthday, Drew Aamari! 💜🌌

This custom galaxy-themed cake was such a fun one to create! From the edible image to the galaxy-inspired details and glitter accents, every swirl was made with love. ✨🎂

Thank you for trusting Sweets By Shay to be part of such a special celebration!

Now tell me… what would you rate this cake from 1-10? 👀👇

📍 Milwaukee Pickup
📩 DM to book

06/13/2026

🚨 HELP ME SELL OUT! 🚨

I only have a few dessert cups left and I’d love your support! 🩷

🍓 Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake — 3 Left
🍌 Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cheesecake — 3 Left
🤎 Biscoff Cheesecake — 4 Left
🍪 Cookie Monster Cheesecake — 4 Left

✨ 10 oz Loaded Dessert Cups
💗 $12 Each

Even if you don’t need a dessert cup today, you can still help a small business by:

🩷 Sharing this post
🩷 Inviting your friends to follow my page
🩷 Tagging a dessert lover below
🩷 Following Sweets by Shay for future treats and specials

Every share helps me reach someone new, and I appreciate every bit of support! 🥰

📞 414-243-2113
📩 DM to order

06/11/2026

🚨 TODAY IS THE DAY! 🚨

Pre-orders are officially OPEN and I still have a few dessert cups available! 😍

🍓 Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake
🍌 Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cheesecake
🤎 Biscoff Cheesecake
🍪 Cookie Monster Cheesecake

✨ 10 oz Loaded Dessert Cups
💗 $12 Each
💗 2 for $22
💗 4 for $40
💗 6 for $55

🚗 Delivery available today and tomorrow after 6 PM for a $5 fee.

📍 Pickup available all day.
📩 DM for pickup location and to place your order.

💰 Payment accepted via Cash App or Zelle only.
📞 414-243-2113

⚠️ Limited quantities available. Once they’re gone, they’re gone!

06/10/2026

06/08/2026

🚨 MILWAUKEE, DON’T WALK… RUN! 🚨

The Dessert Cup Sale is officially LIVE! 😍

These 10 oz loaded dessert cups are packed with layers of cake, no-bake cheesecake, and all the flavor you can handle! 🤤

🍓 Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake
🍌 Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cheesecake
🤎 Biscoff Cheesecake
🍪 Cookie Monster Cheesecake

✨ $12 Each
✨ 2 for $22
✨ 4 for $40
✨ 6 for $55

⚠️ Limited quantities available!
⚠️ Once sold out, they’re SOLD OUT!

Comment your favorite flavor below 👇🏾 and DM to place your order!

📍 Milwaukee Pickup
📞 414-243-2113




❤️❤️❤️

06/08/2026

🚨 JUNE SPECIAL 🚨

Book during June for ANY 2026 date! 🎂✨

🎂 Cake Flavors: Vanilla • Chocolate • Strawberry • Red Velvet • Lemon • Funfetti • Marble

🧁 Cupcake Flavors: Vanilla • Chocolate • Strawberry • Red Velvet • Lemon • Funfetti

📅 Sale Ends June 30th
📲 DM or Text 414-243-2113

06/06/2026

🎂✨ JUNE SPECIAL IS HERE! ✨🎂

Book during the month of June and secure your event date ANYTIME in 2026!

🔥 2-Tier Cake Special — $275
🔥 8” Vintage Cake Special — $150
🔥 Dozen Custom Picture Cupcakes — $25

✔ Custom themes
✔ Pictures included
✔ Up to 2 colors included
✔ Limited-time savings

📅 Sale ends June 30th

A 50% deposit is required to book. Remaining balance is due 2 days before pickup.

📲 DM Sweets By Shay or text 414-243-2113 to reserve your date before spots fill up!