The Cookie Coop

The Cookie Coop Hi, I’m Mallory, your neighborhood cookie lady! Message me for all your custom cookie needs and inquiries
Located in Milmay
NJ Cottage Food Operator

VALENTINE’S DAY presale is OPEN for ordering ! I have options perfect for everyone on your list 🤍💋🤍💋Last day to order is...
02/01/2026

VALENTINE’S DAY presale is OPEN for ordering ! I have options perfect for everyone on your list 🤍💋🤍💋

Last day to order is Friday 2/6. Pick up options are 2/11 and 2/12 in Milmay 08340. Message me if you need another date or with any other questions. All cookies come boxed with a tag and ribbon. Supplies are limited so don’t miss out !

Option 1- $6
Option 2- $6
Option 3- $6
Option 4- $3 each (1 mini with 1 cookie card)
Option 5- $3 (1 mini with cookie card)
Option 6- $6
Option 7- 3 minis for $6 or 6 minis for $12
Option 8- $3 (1 mini with cookie card)
Option 9- $16 (4 pack jumbo cinn buns)

Thank you all for more than I could ever have imagined in 2025. Quick PSA- I will actually be saying No this year to pre...
12/31/2025

Thank you all for more than I could ever have imagined in 2025. Quick PSA- I will actually be saying No this year to preserve my sanity 🤪 so get on my schedule asap! Blessings to all for a safe and healthy 2026! ✨

Tomorrow is the last day to place an order ! Thank you to everyone who has ordered already 🎄🎅🏻🎄🎅🏻🎄🎅🏻
12/14/2025

Tomorrow is the last day to place an order ! Thank you to everyone who has ordered already 🎄🎅🏻🎄🎅🏻🎄🎅🏻

Christmas cookie presale is OPEN for ordering ! I have options perfect for everyone 🎄🎅🏻☃️ Last day to order is Monday 12...
12/08/2025

Christmas cookie presale is OPEN for ordering ! I have options perfect for everyone 🎄🎅🏻☃️ Last day to order is Monday 12/15. Pick up options are be 12/21 and 12/22 in Milmay 08340. Message me if you need another date or with any other questions. All cookies come boxed with a tag and ribbon. Supplies are limited so don’t miss out !

Option 1- $6 (set of 3 minis)
Option 2- $5
Option 3- $3 (1 mini with cookie card)
Option 4- $5
Option 5- $5 (set of 3 minis)
Option 6- $5

This pup’s gotta fly!
11/11/2025

This pup’s gotta fly!

These sweet cookies are on a plane with my mom to celebrate this milestone birthday ! Glad I could add a little ✨extra✨ ...
10/17/2025

These sweet cookies are on a plane with my mom to celebrate this milestone birthday ! Glad I could add a little ✨extra✨ to the party

Ask me about edible images for your next order

If you know me, you know it’s officially fall in my house! I’ve been waiting all year to post these gorgeous pumpkins 🍂🍂...
09/04/2025

If you know me, you know it’s officially fall in my house! I’ve been waiting all year to post these gorgeous pumpkins 🍂🍂

Small, but sweet back to school presale going on NOW until Monday, Aug 25! Pick up options will be Aug 31, Sept 1, and S...
08/19/2025

Small, but sweet back to school presale going on NOW until Monday, Aug 25! Pick up options will be Aug 31, Sept 1, and Sept 2 in Milmay 08340. Message me if you need another date or with any other questions. All cookies come boxed with a tag and ribbon. Supplies are limited so don’t miss out !

Option 1 (set of 3 minis)- $5
Option 2 (1 mini with cookie card)- $3
Option 3- $5
Option 4- $5
Option 5- $5
Option 6- $5

If this is not the CUTEST little Chewbacca I have ever seen I don’t know what is
07/30/2025

If this is not the CUTEST little Chewbacca I have ever seen I don’t know what is

Did I sing hakuna matata all night doing this set 😝
07/22/2025

Did I sing hakuna matata all night doing this set 😝

Can anyone guess this theme ?!
07/15/2025

Can anyone guess this theme ?!

Evan is red, white, and TWO ! Wishing a happy 2nd birthday to my sweet boy 🧁
07/03/2025

Evan is red, white, and TWO ! Wishing a happy 2nd birthday to my sweet boy 🧁

Address

Milmay, NJ
08340

Telephone

+16092872901

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Coop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cookie Coop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category