https://www.facebook.com/102217152499990/

Silly Goose Cookie Company

Home
United States
Middletown, NJ
Silly Goose Cookie Company

A home based cookie company located in River Plaza, Middletown, NJ Silly Goose Cookie Company is a home bakery. We are NOT a gluten free or nut free kitchen.

All products are produced in a home kitchen not subject to public health inspection that may also process common food allergens. Common food allergens that may be found in the kitchen include: eggs, dairy, wheat, peanuts and tree nuts.

04/06/2026

🪿 Cookie Menu for Friday, 4/10 🪿

I'm back and on spring break and I can't think of a better idea than baking this week! Let's get to it...

Brookie - a classic Silly Goose chocolate chip and chocolate chocolate chip cookie swirled together for the best of both worlds, loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips

Cookie Butter S'mores - a soft and chewy cookie infused with speculoos crumbs and milk chocolate chips, stuffed with a marshmallow and drizzled with cookie butter and more speculooos crumbs

Italian Rainbow - a soft almond cookie stuffed with seedless raspberry jam and Italian rainbow cookie pieces, topped with semi-sweet chocolate stripes and a rainbow cookie piece

Chocolate Chip with M&M's - a classic Silly Goose chocolate chip cookie upgraded with milk chocolate M&M's

Cookies are priced at 4/$14, 6/$20 or 8/$24. Pick-up Friday, April 10 from 3:30-6 pm, delivery also available with an 8 cookie minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Cash or Venmo. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪

03/02/2026

Cookie Menu and Announcement for Friday, March 6

After this cookie menu, I'll be taking on a role with a school district while continuing to run Silly Goose part-time. My cookies aren't going anywhere - just becoming a little more exclusive. Menus may be less frequent, but the quality, love and flavor you know will stay exactly the same. Thank you endlessly for supporting this dream, cheering me on through every bake and sticking with me as things evolve. I hope to see as many of you as I can this Friday before I take some time to adjust to the new schedule. Now let's get to the menu...Silly Goose Best Sellers!

Oatmeal Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Chip
Lemon White Chocolate
Strawberry Shortcake
S'mores
Kitchen Sink
Chocolate Hazelnut Churro

Cookies are priced at 4/$14, 6/$20 or 8/$24. Pick-up Friday, March 6 from 3:30-6 pm, delivery also available with an 8 cookie minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Cash or Venmo. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪

02/16/2026

Let's get ready to ruuuuuuuumble! Battle of the chocolate chip cookies round 3 is here! Each box comes with 5 cookies, each individually wrapped and labeled, and scorecards.

Meet the contenders:

🍪 Levain Copycat - baked at a high temp for minimal spread and loaded with milk chocolate chips

🍪 Silly Goose - the classic with semi-sweet chocolate chips

🍪 Bon Appétit - made with brown butter and chopped semi-sweet and dark chocolate

🍪 Alton Brown "The Chewy" - made with bread flour for extra chew and loaded up with semi-sweet chocolate chips

🍪 Sarah Kieffer Pan-Banging - thin and crispy made popular by the method of banging the pan down several times during the bake to achieve the rippled effect and leaves with chopped semi-sweet chocolate chunks

Each box is $20 or 2/$35, pick-up Friday, February 20 from 3:30-6 pm. Delivery also available with a 2 box minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Cash or Venmo. Thanks and have a sweet week!

02/06/2026

SOLD OUT!🏈 Football Chocolate Chip Cookie Trays 🏈

Only 4 left for Saturday pick-up or delivery! $20

Comment below to claim yours!

02/02/2026

Cookie Menu for Friday, February 6

🪿NEW🪿Dubai Cookie - a rich and fudgy chocolate cookie stuffed with a pistachio cream and cornflake filling, topped with creamy milk chocolate and chopped roasted salted pistachios ($1 upcharge)

Cookie Dough - a soft brown sugar cookie topped with cookie dough buttercream, safe-to-eat cookie dough balls and mini chocolate chips ($1 upcharge)

Fluffernutter - a melt in your mouth peanut butter cookie bursting with marshmallow fluff

Chocolate Chip - the Silly Goose classic loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips

Cookies are priced at $4 each, 4/$14, 6/$20 and 8/$24. $1 upcharge applies to each Dubai or Cookie Dough order due to the high cost of ingredients. Pick-up 3:30-6 pm on Friday, February 6. Delivery also available with an 8 cookie minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪

01/27/2026

Cookie Menu for Friday, January 30

9" cookie cake - A Silly Goose classic chocolate chip cookie cake with any message you like. Celebrate a birthday, offer congratulations or root for your favorite sports team $18

NEW Gluten-free brownie cookies pack of 12, fudgy and sweet made with Ghirardelli cocoa and dark chocolate chips. (Not suitable for gluten allergies, this is a naturally gluten free recipe and is NOT prepared in a gluten free kitchen) $15

Football Cookie Tray - 24 mini chocolate chip cookies served in a football tray and packaged up and ready to go $20

Pick-up Friday, January 30 from 3:30-6. Sorry no Middletown deliveries available this week. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning. Cash or Venmo. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪❄️

01/20/2026

Menu for Friday, January 23rd

QUICK BREAD WEEK!

After cookies, quick breads are my favorite thing to bake. Are they breakfast, a snack or dessert? The answer is YES.

Pumpkin Bread - lightly spiced to allow the pumpkin flavor to shine through, this soft and fluffy bread is topped with a generous amount of cinnamon sugar for a sweet crunch

Zucchini Bread - made with warm spices, brown sugar and freshly grated organic zucchini this quick bread is topped with a crunchy turbinado sugar

Banana Bread - your choice of plain or with chocolate chips, this quick bread is made with plenty of fresh bananas and greek yogurt resulting in a perfectly moist loaf

Each loaf is just over 1 lb. and packaged ready for gifting (or not 😉) $9 each, 2/$16 or 3/$21. Cash or Venmo. Delivery available with a 2 loaf minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Pick-up Friday, January 23 from 3:30-6 pm 🍞

Also offering 🏈 Football Cookie Trays🏈 24 mini chocolate chip cookies served in a football tray all packaged up and ready to go $20 each

01/12/2026

Cookie Menu for Friday, Jan 16
🪿Favorites Week🪿

Oatmeal Cream Sandwich - 2 soft and chewy molasses and cinnamon spiced oatmeal cookies sandwiched with sweet marshmallow buttercream

Strawberry Shortcake - a soft and cakey strawberry cookie topped with sweet marshmallow buttercream and strawberry shortcake crumble

Lemon White Chocolate - a soft and chewy lemon cookie made with fresh lemon zest and white chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar

Chocolate Chip - the Silly Goose classic loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips

Cookies are priced at $4 each, 4/$14, 6/$20 or 8/$24. Pick-up Friday, January 16 from 3-6 pm. Cash or Venmo. Delivery also available with an 8 cookie minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪

12/21/2025

SOLD OUT - Thank you!!

🎄Christmas Box 🎄

Celebrate Santa's arrival with Silly Goose! A very merry assortment: 6 chocolate chip with m&m's, 6 snickerdoodles, 6 chocolate crinkles, 4 vanilla bean confetti, 3 frosted sugar cookies, 3 s'mores sandwich cookies and a Rudolph brownie. $32 each, cash or Venmo. Pick-up Tuesday, December 23 after 12 noon. Sorry, no deliveries this week. Merry Christmas! ❤️💚

12/15/2025

🎄Holiday Party Box 🎄

This Friday's menu is a simple one, a box of sweet treats to bring along to all the gatherings, to gift, or simply for a sweet treat for a cozy weekend at home ❤️💚 12 M&M chocolate chip and 12 festive vanilla bean confetti cookies $20 each or 2/$35, pick up Friday 12/19 after 2 pm. Delivery also available with a 2 box minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Cash or Venmo. Thank you!

🎄🎅Christmas Special boxes will be posted soon for pick up 12/23 🎅🎄

12/08/2025

Cookie Menu for Friday, December 12

Gingerbread Cookie Butter - a warmly spiced cookie made with molasses, ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg, stuffed with cookie butter and drizzled with white chocolate and sparkly sugar

Chocolate Whoopie Pie - two HUGE rich chocolate cake cookies filled with sweet marshmallow buttercream

Christmas Kitchen Sink - a Silly Goose classic sweet and salty cookie made festive for the holiday, a brown sugar cookie loaded with caramel, potato chips, pretzels, chocolate chips, red and green M&M's and a sprinkle of flaky salt

Cookies are priced at $4 each, 4/$14, 6/$20 or 8/$24. Pick-up Friday 3:30-6 pm. Delivery also available with an 8 cookie minimum, limited to the south side of Middletown only. Gregory School orders will be delivered Friday morning, no minimum necessary. Cash or Venmo. Thanks and have a sweet week! 🍪

Address

Hubbard Avenue
Middletown, NJ
07701

Telephone

+17324922855

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Silly Goose Cookie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Middletown?