Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC

Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC Offering homemade made-to-order custom designed sugar cookies. Hi and Welcome! My sugar cookies are 100% homemade in my home based kitchen. Thank you~
Dawn

Prices are quoted on design & detail. Cookies start at 48.00 per dozen with an up charge for painting of gold/silver and/or extreme detail. Each cookie is individually heat sealed to ensure freshness & safety. I’m currently booking cookie orders 4 plus months in advance & will book out to one year in advance. 50% deposit will hold your booking date. All cookie orders are pick-up only from our Mic

higan City home. At this time, I am only accepting cash payment & PayPal. Please message me with any questions -
I look forward to creating something special for you.

It’s Pride Month..Love is love
06/02/2026

It’s Pride Month..Love is love

Many of you inquired as to where or who painted my sign. Here you go, Emigh (pronounced Amy), does a wonderful job. Sh...
05/31/2026

Many of you inquired as to where or who painted my sign. Here you go, Emigh (pronounced Amy), does a wonderful job.
She can paint a sign to match your cookie order!

I am now taking bookings for July & August

Thank you all for showing up! You never disappoint! I am going to be closing up at about 12:45 PM. If you are coming b...
05/30/2026

Thank you all for showing up! You never disappoint!
I am going to be closing up at about 12:45 PM. If you are coming by, please comment below and let me know.
Thank you

Come see me today! 3801 Lexington Rd Michigan City8-?CupcakesMini cakesBrowniesCake push popsButtercream floralsButter...
05/30/2026

Come see me today!
3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City
8-?
Cupcakes
Mini cakes
Brownies
Cake push pops
Buttercream florals
Buttercream sandwich cookies
Royal icing cookies
Mini cookies
Cake Jars

Phew….I’m almost done! Another long day…..16 plus hours x 3 days in a row…….I’ll sleep good TOMORROW night! See you t...
05/30/2026

Phew….I’m almost done! Another long day…..16 plus hours x 3 days in a row…….
I’ll sleep good TOMORROW night!
See you tomorrow at the pop up!
8 am to ?
3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City

Many of you may remember my granddaughter, Emily who has helped me in the kitchen before! She’s growing up quickly and ...
05/29/2026

Many of you may remember my granddaughter, Emily who has helped me in the kitchen before! She’s growing up quickly and she is here tonight helping me assemble the cookie board!

See you tomorrow from 8-?
3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City

These are SO cute…..mini suitcases filled with 4 mini cookies. See you tomorrow under the white tent Cookies/cakes/cupc...
05/29/2026

These are SO cute…..mini suitcases filled with 4 mini cookies.

See you tomorrow under the white tent

Cookies/cakes/cupcakes and more POP UP
8-?
3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City

This coincides with our neighborhood garage sale. Please be prepared to park and walk and bring a cooler if you are planning to walk the neighborhood after stopping by the pop-up. 

Okay all you mini cake fans….as you know I don’t like making cakes…..If you want a cake here’s a heads up….I made 3 all ...
05/29/2026

Okay all you mini cake fans….as you know I don’t like making cakes…..If you want a cake here’s a heads up….
I made 3 all chocolate mini cakes & 8 all vanilla cakes.
There is a price increase on most items made with buttercream….
These are 16.00 each

Available tomorrow at 8 am, under the white tent in my driveway!
3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City

Trying something new……cake push ups! A select few will be available tomorrow (5-30-26) under the white tent in my drive...
05/29/2026

Trying something new……cake push ups! A select few will be available tomorrow (5-30-26) under the white tent in my driveway during my Cookies, Cupcakes & More pop up.

This coincides with our neighborhood garage sale. Come grab yourself a sweet treat and take a walk around our neighborhood to see what kind of treasures you may find.

Please be prepared to park and walk as the streets get crowded. Bring a cooler if you are planning on shopping the garage sales after making a purchase.

3801 Lexington Rd
Michigan City
Village Green Subdivision
8-?

When a friend stops by to check on me…..you feed her a cookie!
05/28/2026

When a friend stops by to check on me…..you feed her a cookie!

Address

3801 Lexington Road
Michigan City, IN
46360

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Custom Cookies by Dawn, LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share