Bagel Pantry

Bagel Pantry Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Bagel Pantry, Bagel Shop, 545 Middlesex Avenue, Metuchen, NJ.

Operating as usual

Bagel Pantry Hours:Mon-Sat 5 am-5pm Sun 5am-3pmTakeout, parking lot pick-up& delivery available. Pay over phone also an ...

Bagel Pantry Hours:
Mon-Sat 5 am-5pm
Sun 5am-3pm

Takeout, parking lot pick-up
& delivery available. Pay over phone also an option. 732.632.3100

FREE bagels after 2 pm for
anyone out-of or in need of
bread pick them up at our sister shop,
Olive Press Eatery,
21 Pearl St Metuchen

Stay safe everyone, thank you!


If you or someone you know is looking for a job we are looking for counter help. Experience is not necessary but it is a plus..... thanks


If you happen to be out working during this storm and you need to satisfy your bagel fix stop in we're open. P.S Be careful and take it slow....




Great news! Power has been restored to our area and the Bagel Pantry in Metuchen will be open on Saturday Novemeber 3 @ 5am-6pm. Hope you and yours are well, see you soon!


We hope all our community is safe after this devastating storm. Remember your neighbors and those who are not capable of attaining necessities. Kudos to emergency personnel, firefighters and those unsung heroes who are taking care of others. We hope to see you all soon

Bagel Pantry

Bagel Pantry


545 Middlesex Avenue
Metuchen, NJ

Opening Hours

Monday 5am - 6pm
Tuesday 5am - 6pm
Wednesday 5am - 6pm
Thursday 5am - 6pm
Friday 5am - 6pm
Saturday 5am - 5pm
Sunday 5am - 3pm


(732) 632-3100


Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Pantry posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Pantry:


Nearby bakeries

Other Metuchen bakeries

Show All


This is the second time I've tried to order Avocado toast and this place...
First time I ordered the loaded avocado toast, my boyfriend was told they don't know what that is.

This time I ordered an omelette and basic avocado toast.

I got this on top of my omelette, Along with buttered toast.

My boyfriend and I will not be back.
Bagel Pantry - Bagel Pantry is my happy place. Crispy, chewy bagels and the chance of scoring a hot bagel out of the oven is a great start to my day.
Bagel Pantry: The BEST bagels ever! YUM!
Bagels at Bagel Pantry

Other Metuchen bakeries (show all)

Manhattan Bagel Bagel One Deli and Mexican Food La Bagel Sam I am Bagels Liberty Bagel Cafe Bagel City Cafe & Grill, Edison Charlie's Bagel and Deli Colonia Bagel Supreme Bagel Supreme - Colonia Knot Just Bagels Manhattan Bagel Bagel Bazaar Piscataway Rahway Bagels Bagel Supreme - Clark East Bagel Supreme