Bagel Plaza

Bagel Plaza Bagel Plaza is the oldest bagel place on the south shore, serving up all original recipes and sandwiches made from scratch to the residents of Merrick, NY.

We were established in 1962 when bagels were a novelty, and we’ve kept up our top quality preparations to create the best New York bagels around. Bagel Plaza has 56 different bagels, bialys, and Challahs made from scratch daily. We carry a full line of smoked fish as well as flavored 15 different cream cheeses, and over 20 different salads, all made with Kosher ingredients. And make sure to ask ab

out our soup of the day! Have a big event coming up, such as a Bar or Bat Mizvah? We cater! So let us take care of the meal for your event to ease any stress. Your complete satisfaction is our top priority. Let our friendly and welcoming staff help you create a one of a kind bagel sandwich, or recommend the perfect bagel and cream cheese combination to satisfy your bagel cravings. Come grab a bite today!

05/29/2026

✨ Shabbat Shalom from all of us at Bagel Plaza. ✨

As the candles are lit and families gather around the table, we’re wishing our entire community a peaceful, joyful, and meaningful Shabbat. 💙

From fresh baked challah to your favorite bagels and spreads, we’re grateful to be part of so many family traditions each week. Thank you for allowing us to share in your Shabbat moments.

Wishing you and your loved ones a beautiful weekend filled with peace, family, and delicious food. 🕯️🥯🍷

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

From office lunches and team meetings to family gatherings and special events, let Bagel Plaza cater your next get toget...
05/27/2026

From office lunches and team meetings to family gatherings and special events, let Bagel Plaza cater your next get together 🥯✨

Enjoy crowd favorites like our Giant Party Bagel, fresh Salad Platters, colorful Fruit Platters, Pasta Bowls, Cookie Platters, Smoked Fish Platters, and so much more, all made fresh and perfect for sharing.

Whether you’re feeding the office or hosting a celebration, we’ve got something everyone will love.

Visit our catering menu for more information and full ordering details:
https://www.bagelplaza.com/catering-menu.php

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

05/22/2026

🇺🇸 Memorial Day Weekend is here — and before you head to the beach, the boat, a BBQ, or wherever the long weekend takes you, make your stop at Bagel Plaza. 🥯☕️

Grab a fresh bagel sandwich for the road, your morning coffee, and don’t forget the desserts, rugelach, cookies, and baked goods to bring along with you. Even if the weather may not be perfect beach weather, Long Islanders are always on the move Memorial Day Weekend — and we’ve got the fresh favorites to keep you fueled along the way.

Stop in before your plans begin and taste the Bagel Plaza difference. 💙

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

05/15/2026

🥯✨ The weekend is almost here… and the Shabbat table starts begins with Bagel Plaza. 💙

From fresh-baked bagels and silky nova to golden challah made with care, everything you need for a meaningful and delicious weekend is ready and waiting.

Whether you’re gathering with family, hosting friends, or simply slowing down and enjoying the moment, let Bagel Plaza help bring a little extra comfort to the table this Shabbat. ✨

Wishing you a peaceful, joyful, and delicious weekend.
Shabbat Shalom from all of us at Bagel Plaza. 💙

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

05/14/2026

🥯✨ There’s an art to doing things the old-fashioned way. 💙

Thinly sliced, silky nova lox — prepared with patience, precision, and the kind of craftsmanship that never goes out of style. Watching it come together is almost as satisfying as the first bite. ✨

Simple ingredients. Thoughtful preparation. Timeless flavor.
Sometimes, the quiet moments in the kitchen say it all.

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

05/12/2026

🥯✨ Some moments deserve a spread made with care. 💙

From Bar Mitzvah Kiddushes and Baby Namings to other family gatherings, Bagel Plaza catering is about more than just great food — it’s about helping bring people together during life’s most meaningful moments.

This reel features a recent catered Bar Mitzvah Kiddush that was especially close to our hearts — celebrating Zach, Yana’s son and Sam’s grandson. A beautiful day filled with family, tradition, and the kind of thoughtfully prepared spread we’re proud to be a part of.

From hand-sliced nova and fresh-baked bagels to house-made salads, fish platters, challah, cookies, and more — everything is crafted in small batches with the quality, care, and tradition that define Bagel Plaza catering. ✨

Thank you to Lauren Gallery for capturing these special moments so beautifully.

🥯 Call ahead or stop in to plan your next gathering
📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455 | 🌐 bagelplaza.com

💐 Happy Mother’s Day from all of us at Bagel Plaza! 💐Today, we’re sending lots of love to our incredible co-owner, Yana,...
05/10/2026

💐 Happy Mother’s Day from all of us at Bagel Plaza! 💐

Today, we’re sending lots of love to our incredible co-owner, Yana, and the Asatur Matriarch, Marina. Your strength, love, and dedication to family are an inspiration to everyone around you.

We also want to wish a very Happy Mother’s Day to all the amazing mothers, grandmothers, and mother figures in our community. Thank you for everything you do to make our families and communities stronger each and every day.

Wishing you a day filled with love, laughter, and plenty of delicious bagels. 💙🥯

🥯💐 Happy Friday! Hosting Mother’s Day brunch at home this year? Make it easy—and unforgettable—with everything you need ...
05/08/2026

🥯💐 Happy Friday! Hosting Mother’s Day brunch at home this year? Make it easy—and unforgettable—with everything you need from Bagel Plaza.

From hand-sliced nova lox and fresh tuna salad to our signature whitefish and full appetizing spread, you’ll have the centerpiece covered. Add in fresh baked challah, cookies, pastries, and of course our classic bagels, and you’ve got a brunch Mom will truly appreciate.

Everything is made fresh in small batches with the kind of quality and care that sets Bagel Plaza apart—because moments like this deserve the best. Also, ask about our special Mother’s Day Packages, ranging from $79 to $189 plus tax, depending on the size of your get together.

📞 Call ahead to place your order or stop in early to pick up your favorites. Let us help you bring it all together this Mother’s Day. Shabbat Shalom.

📍1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick
📞 (516) 378-3455

05/05/2026

🌸💐 Mother’s Day Brunch, Done Right at Bagel Plaza 💐🌸

Skip the stress this year and treat Mom to a full, thoughtfully prepared brunch spread—made fresh, packed with flavor, and ready to enjoy at home. See the following link for all the details:https://bagelplaza.com/dev/images/2026-mothers-day.pdf

🥯 Household Brunch (Serves 4) – $79 + tax
• 6 bagels
• ½ lb nova scotia lox (thinly sliced)
• ½ lb plain cream cheese
• ½ lb tuna salad (or tuna veggie)
• ½ lb egg salad
• ½ gallon orange juice
• ½ lb signature mixed rugelach

🥯 Small Family Brunch (Serves 6–8) – $139 + tax
• 13 bagels
• ¾ lb nova scotia lox
• ½ lb plain cream cheese
• ½ lb scallion cream cheese
• 1 lb tuna salad
• ½ lb whitefish salad
• 1 lb egg salad
• ¾ lb signature mixed rugelach

🥯 Extended Family Affair (Serves 8–10) – $189 + tax
• 18 bagels
• 1 lb nova scotia lox
• 1 lb plain cream cheese
• ½ lb scallion cream cheese
• 1 lb tuna salad (or tuna veggie)
• 1 lb whitefish (smooth or chunky)
• 1 lb egg salad
• 1 lb signature mixed rugelach

👉 All packages are not plattered.

From our hand-sliced nova to our small-batch salads and freshly baked bagels, this is the kind of brunch Mom will actually remember.

📞 Pre-orders are strongly encouraged—call now to reserve: (516) 378-3455
📍 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick

Make it easy. Make it special. Make Mom proud. 💙

Address

1704 Merrick Road
Merrick, NY
11566

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 2pm
Tuesday 6am - 2pm
Wednesday 6am - 2pm
Thursday 6am - 2pm
Friday 6am - 2pm
Saturday 6am - 2pm
Sunday 6am - 2pm

Telephone

+15163783455

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Plaza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Plaza:

Shortcuts

Share

Category