Lilly Creek Sourdough

Directions Website

Lilly Creek Sourdough A local cottage bakery making sourdough bread & other goodies in Menomonee Falls, WI 🍞✨

With fall baking in full swing and the holidays around the corner, I wanted to do a little reintroduction since there ha...
10/08/2026

With fall baking in full swing and the holidays around the corner, I wanted to do a little reintroduction since there have been some new faces around here. 😊

My name is Kim and I’m the baker behind Lilly Creek Sourdough.

I operate under Wisconsin cottage food court ruling and run a bakery out of the entryway of my home in Menomonee Falls! I have a 3-deck bread oven that lets me bake up to 12 large loaves at a time and a huge mixer that allows me to mix up to 23 loaves at a time.

I typically offer 2-3 pick up days a month and I open ordering about a week before pick up day. Customers place their order online and come pick up at my house on the designated day. You don’t have to worry about your order sitting outside for hours at a time. I run every order out to my customers upon arrival. It’s pretty slick! 😎

Whether you’ve been ordering from me since the beginning or just recently found my page, thank you for being here and supporting my cottage bakery. I have the most kind and generous customers. Can’t wait to bake for you! 🍞🍪

Pumpkin lovers! It’s time! 🤩🎃 Next week, I will be offering pumpkin loaves two ways: a lightly spiced pumpkin sourdough ...
10/07/2026

Pumpkin lovers! It’s time! 🤩🎃

Next week, I will be offering pumpkin loaves two ways: a lightly spiced pumpkin sourdough and a pumpkin chocolate chip sourdough. Both were so delicious but that pumpkin chocolate chip…🤤

English muffins will be back next week as well. Ordering opens tomorrow at 9am for pick up on Thursday, October 15.

October Bake Schedule 🍂🧡I will be taking this week off but then I’ll be back at it the next three Thursdays. Let me know...
10/05/2026

October Bake Schedule 🍂🧡

I will be taking this week off but then I’ll be back at it the next three Thursdays. Let me know what bread flavors you want to see in October!

Sold out!! 70 bread and 29 bags of English muffins. Thank you, Menomonee Falls! 🫶🏻🫶🏻
10/03/2026

Sold out!! 70 bread and 29 bags of English muffins. Thank you, Menomonee Falls! 🫶🏻🫶🏻

120 English muffins done and it’s on to bread next! Getting ready to bake bread at this time of day feels so weird. 😂 We...
10/02/2026

120 English muffins done and it’s on to bread next! Getting ready to bake bread at this time of day feels so weird. 😂

We are excited and ready for a full day of baking so we can bring sourdough goodies to the Falls Harvest Fest tomorrow! Hope to see you there. 🫶🏻🫶🏻

🍁Maple Pecan Granola🍁 I’ve been a biiiig granola girl lately and have been making it weekly for my family. I will have a...
10/01/2026

🍁Maple Pecan Granola🍁

I’ve been a biiiig granola girl lately and have been making it weekly for my family. I will have a few bags at the Menomonee Falls Downtown Falls Harvest Fest this Saturday from 10am-4pm at Mill Pond Park.

It’s baked slowly with pure organic maple syrup, pecans, pumpkin seeds, and sunflower kernels. It’s the perfect crunchy bite for these cool Fall days. 🫶🏻

Prep work has begun for Falls Harvest Fest this weekend. For my savory loaf, I’ll have a Three Cheese sourdough with Sha...
09/30/2026

Prep work has begun for Falls Harvest Fest this weekend. For my savory loaf, I’ll have a Three Cheese sourdough with Sharp cheddar, creamy Gouda, and salty Parmesan!! 🧀🧀🧀

I’ll also have classic and apple cinnamon sourdough loaves along with English muffins!

No pre-orders for next week! Instead, we are super excited to be a vendor at Menomonee Falls Downtown Falls Harvest Fest...
09/26/2026

No pre-orders for next week! Instead, we are super excited to be a vendor at Menomonee Falls Downtown Falls Harvest Fest next Saturday! 🍁🍂

Come see us at this fun downtown event. My husband and I will be slinging sourdough. I’ll post menu items throughout the week! 🥰

Extras available for pick up today!! Pick up is 2:30-5:30pm. 🍂🍂Sold out!! Comment or message to claim.
09/24/2026

Extras available for pick up today!! Pick up is 2:30-5:30pm. 🍂🍂

Sold out!!

Comment or message to claim.

🍎🍏Cinnamon Apple 🍏🍎Available next week! A simple loaf made with freeze-dried apples and mini cinnamon chips. I get my ci...
09/19/2026

🍎🍏Cinnamon Apple 🍏🍎

Available next week! A simple loaf made with freeze-dried apples and mini cinnamon chips. I get my cinnamon chips from the Bulk-Priced Food Shoppe because they are great quality and perfect for baking. Since they are mini they melt nicely into the dough and have better overall distribution for a cinnamon-y flavor in each bite. 😋

Address

Menomonee Falls, WI
53051

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lilly Creek Sourdough posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category