The Sweetest Things - Cookies by Missy

The Sweetest Things - Cookies by Missy The Sweetest Things by Missy started as a hobby. I kept fine tuning my recipe to hold shapes, stay a little softer, and taste great.

My love of baking and art merged several years ago when I got a couple tips, bags, bottles and cookies together in my kitchen to make some Valentine's conversation hearts for a friend's daughter. The art work....well that is a forever changing lesson!

08/23/2026

To my wonderful customers,

For the past 17 years, I have had the absolute honor of being a small part of your lives—your milestone events, birthday parties, holidays, and family gatherings. I’ve watched so many of your families grow: baking cookies for kids from their very first birthdays all the way to their high school graduations. I’ve made cookies for baby showers and watched those babies grow into teenagers, and I’ve even watched teenagers grow up, get married, and welcome children of their own. Sharing in your joy and watching your families flourish through the years has meant more to me than words can say.

This is one of the hardest decisions I have ever had to make, but moving forward, I will no longer be taking new custom cookie orders. Please rest assured that I will be filling all orders that are currently booked.

Between working full-time, participating in community events, and baking cookies, life has become very full. Most importantly, I need to dedicate my time and focus to caring for my mother. As much as I love this business, something has to be put aside for the time being.

While new custom orders are closing, I will still consider doing holiday events as time and our situation allow. Please continue to follow The Sweetest Things by Missy so that you don't miss out if I am able to do a pop-up or holiday sale!

Thank you all so much for your incredible support, loyalty, and love over the last 17 years. I deeply appreciate your grace and understanding as I step into this next season to focus on my family.

With so much gratitude and love,

Missy❤️

Happy Birthday Harper! She is Bad two the Bone!
07/12/2026

Happy Birthday Harper! She is Bad two the Bone!

The last of the Grad season cookies, and they are my beloved Shawnee Indians! Congratulations Kobe! The future is bright...
06/13/2026

The last of the Grad season cookies, and they are my beloved Shawnee Indians! Congratulations Kobe! The future is bright!

Congratulations Alexis! I loved doing these colors!
06/07/2026

Congratulations Alexis! I loved doing these colors!

06/04/2026

Yes!!! We got the band! Freedom Fest 2026 - Shawnee High School stadium! June 27th! Follow Shawnee Township Events for information!🥰

Congratulation Joshua and the entire Shawnee Class of 2026! ❤️🖤❤️🖤
05/30/2026

Congratulation Joshua and the entire Shawnee Class of 2026! ❤️🖤❤️🖤

I remember holding this child when she was just new to this world. Now this young lady has the world at her feet! Happy ...
05/28/2026

I remember holding this child when she was just new to this world. Now this young lady has the world at her feet! Happy 16th Birthday Rebekah!

Address

Lima, OH
45806

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sweetest Things - Cookies by Missy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category