Batter Up Bakery

Batter Up Bakery Open Fridays and Saturdays, we offer a selection of handmade donuts, cakes, cupcakes, brownies, and cookies as well as seasonal and bake-to-order specialties.
(309)

To place an order or book a wedding tasting, click MESSAGE let us know what you need! Take me out to Batter Up Bakery to enjoy the aroma -- it's the scent of our commitment to quality baking with the best ingredients -- from scratch. We offer a selection of freshly baked cupcakes, cakes, cookies, brownies and handmade donuts, as well as seasonal and bake-to-order specialties (including gluten and

sugar free) and more! Batter Up Bakery is a team committed to quality. Our first and basic component is customer satisfaction, followed by an enthusiasm for using the finest, fresh ingredients to create a true from-scratch treat. We are dedicated to sourcing locally as much as we can. We use locally grown cage free eggs as well as seasonal fruits such as handpicked strawberries, blueberries, raspberries and apples. We use top of the line imported Belgian and European chocolates and more! Stop in for a hot cup of coffee or sweet/savory treat. Our service and quality is what brings our fans back to the game time after time!

Happy Saturday, fans! It's Dine and Donate for the Highland Humane Society today! We have the cutest dog and cat themed ...
08/29/2026

Happy Saturday, fans! It's Dine and Donate for the Highland Humane Society today! We have the cutest dog and cat themed treats in the case today. A portion of every sale will be donated to the humane society. We're also back with our last full peach weekend! We will have limited items next week so grab your favorites from the lineup while you can today! We have peach cinnamon rolls, peach scones, peach cobbler, peach crumble bars and peach fritters will be up shortly! AND our milk cooler is stocked! Fresh Swallow Hill Dairy milk is here!
We will be here until 12 noon to serve you or until we sell out!

Calling all Buckeye fans and peanut butter lovers! There’s nothing more Ohio than chocolate, peanut butter, and game day...
08/26/2026

Calling all Buckeye fans and peanut butter lovers! There’s nothing more Ohio than chocolate, peanut butter, and game day. To celebrate Ohio State's season opener, on September 5th we're offering a limited run of our scratch-made Buckeye-inspired treats. Perfect for watch parties, tailgates, and sharing with fellow fans!

Here's how it works:
-Only 30 order slots are available. (orders open: Aug 26 - Sept 2).
-$30 per order - you pick one option from the list below.
-Each option serves approximately 12 people.
-Pre-order and payment are required to reserve.
-Pickup Sat, Sept 5th between 7:00 AM and 11:00 AM.

Once all 30 slots are claimed, ordering will close (no later than 9/2).

Message our page to reserve your order or call & leave us a message (937-780-2253). We'll return your call to confirm.
*An order is not confirmed until payment is received.

Choose your favorite from the list below:

Buckeye Gourmet Cream Cake (6" double layer)
Rich dark chocolate cake
Creamy peanut butter donut filling
Decadent peanut butter buttercream
Topped with chocolate drizzle and homemade Buckeye candies

Buckeye Gourmet Cupcakes (1 dozen)
Rich dark chocolate cupcakes
Peanut butter frosting
Chocolate drizzle

Buckeye Blossom Peanut Butter Cookies (1 dozen)
Soft, chewy peanut butter cookies
Milk chocolate drizzle
Topped with a homemade Buckeye candy

Buckeye Long Johns (1 dozen)
Hand-cut, from-scratch yeast long john
Creamy peanut butter long john filling
Chocolate frosting

Scratch-made and game day ready for Ohio State's season opener! Don't wait, these Buckeye favorites won't last long! Go Bucks!

Introducing The Cake Lineup!We spend so much of our time baking, decorating and sending cakes out the door that we don’t...
08/24/2026

Introducing The Cake Lineup!

We spend so much of our time baking, decorating and sending cakes out the door that we don’t always get around to showing you what we’ve been working on. So every once in a while, we’re going to round up some of our recent favorites and give them their moment.

Here’s our latest Cake Lineup! What have you been baking? Post your pics in the comments!

HOT peach cinnamon rolls are up! Peach fritters are hot & ready and the blueberry sweet rolls are in the case now.
08/22/2026

HOT peach cinnamon rolls are up! Peach fritters are hot & ready and the blueberry sweet rolls are in the case now.

It's another soccer Saturday around here! Our cases are loaded and ready for you, fans!HOT peach fritters just came up, ...
08/22/2026

It's another soccer Saturday around here!
Our cases are loaded and ready for you, fans!
HOT peach fritters just came up, peach cinnamon rolls are in the oven, and we have a special bonus! We got a final round of blueberries so blueberry sweet rolls are back for a limited time.
We'll be here until 12 noon to serve you today!

Corner Market, LLC & Maplecrest Meats & More received fresh deliveries of mini cakes this morning! Fans, thank you for s...
08/21/2026

Corner Market, LLC & Maplecrest Meats & More received fresh deliveries of mini cakes this morning!

Fans, thank you for supporting all of our small businesses! It makes these business to business partnerships extra sweet!

How is back to school going, fans? Can we help you sweeten your Friday? Our case is loaded with back to school themed su...
08/21/2026

How is back to school going, fans? Can we help you sweeten your Friday? Our case is loaded with back to school themed sugar cookies & snack cakes, plus we have all of your regular favorites!

We are also launching our August Flavor Spotlight today: PEACHES! Fritters will start tomorrow (Saturday) but today we have peach scones, peach crumb bars, peach cobbler cookies, and more. We also have "Mom's Magic Peach Cobbler" made famous by our good friend, the Food H***y! (Check out her website for the recipe!)
Stop and see us, today! We will be here until 6pm to serve you!

August’s Flavor Spotlight is here, and we’re soaking up the last tastes of summer with PEACH! We source our peaches loca...
08/19/2026

August’s Flavor Spotlight is here, and we’re soaking up the last tastes of summer with PEACH! We source our peaches locally from Karnes Orchard and they are delicious!

Peach fritters, peach muffins, peach cookies, peach crumb bars, peaches and cream cake, and more are coming to Batter Up Bakery! If you’re a peach lover, this is your weekend to stop in and try something new or grab an old favorite.

Our Flavor Spotlight is all about turning what’s trending into something you can actually taste, and this month peach is getting its turn at the plate!

Oh, my heart. This season of life is just so bittersweet (but mostly sweet). Today I had the honor of creating a grazing...
08/15/2026

Oh, my heart. This season of life is just so bittersweet (but mostly sweet). Today I had the honor of creating a grazing table of desserts for sweet Mackenzie Mash- now Grabans- and her new husband, John.

I met Kenzie when she was 11 years old playing a "silly girl" in Beauty & the Beast, Jr. with my daughter, Alayna, at The Paxton Theater. Year after year the girls performed together, growing their friendship with each other and becoming a permanent fixture in our family. Fast forward 10 years to her engagement when I received the sweetest message, "Momma Mac... I'm getting married! Will you make my cake?!"

I've shed many tears today, full of nostalgia and love.
Kenzie and John, it was the sweetest honor to be a small part of your day, to bear witness to the love you share for each other and the Lord. Congratulations and all my love to you as your new family takes shape.

Address

40 E Main Street
Leesburg, OH
45135

Opening Hours

Friday 6am - 6pm
Saturday 7am - 12pm

Telephone

+19377802253

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Batter Up Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Batter Up Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category