Cake It Or Leave It LLC

Cake It Or Leave It LLC •Registered Home-Based Cottage Bakery
•Lake Wales, FL | Serving all of Polk County
•Farmers Markets | Preorder Online
•Philippians 4:13 | Matthew 6:26
(2)

05/29/2026

Y’all, we wanted to share a quick reminder after receiving one of the sweetest voicemails today. 🩷

Today, we received a voicemail from a sweet lady who drove all the way from Vero Beach looking for us after hearing about us on Morning with Grady. 😭

Unfortunately, she discovered something many people don’t know yet: Cake It or Leave It LLC is a home-based cottage bakery. We bake right from our home kitchen, which means we don’t have a storefront for walk-in customers.

Everything we make is baked fresh and made to order. We don’t keep shelves stocked with desserts waiting to be sold. When an order comes in, that’s when the baking begins. 🍪

The fact that someone would make that drive just to find us truly blew us away, and we’re incredibly grateful for all the love and support.

One day, we hope to have a storefront of our own. Until then, we’ll keep baking from home, one order at a time. 🩷🍪

Darling & James
Cake It or Leave It LLC

📞 (863) 614-0400

05/29/2026

We got a pretty cool surprise this morning. ☕🍪

Our Cake It or Leave It LLC mug made an appearance during Sheriff’s Morning Coffee, and hearing Sheriff Grady Judd talk about our cookies absolutely made our day.

When someone takes a sip of coffee, sees your mug, remembers your cookies, and starts talking about how good they are… that’s a win in our book. ❤️

Thank you for the support Polk County Sheriff's Office. We truly appreciate it!

EDIT: The ordering link is officially LIVE 👏😭Use code: TFT-3.50 at checkout 💅Order here: https://cakeitorleaveitllc.com/...
05/28/2026

EDIT: The ordering link is officially LIVE 👏😭
Use code: TFT-3.50 at checkout 💅
Order here: https://cakeitorleaveitllc.com/menu-order/
________________________________________

THREE FIFTY THURSDAY 🍪✨

Stuffed cookies & cookie cups will be $3.50 EACH when you buy a HALF DOZEN or more 👏

Ordering link will be posted TOMORROW 👀
Pickup will be FRIDAY in Lake Wales or Winter Haven 💕

Today, we honor and remember the brave souls who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom ❤️🤍💙🇺🇸
05/25/2026

Today, we honor and remember the brave souls who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom ❤️🤍💙🇺🇸

Still smiling over this one 🥹When we first started Cake It or Leave It LLC, we never imagined our little home bakery wou...
05/24/2026

Still smiling over this one 🥹

When we first started Cake It or Leave It LLC, we never imagined our little home bakery would one day receive a letter like this.

We recently had the honor of creating custom stuffed cookies along with custom cookies printed with the Lake Wales Police Department badge and the Chief’s photo for Police Week… and today we received this beautiful appreciation letter from the Chief of Police himself.

And honestly… it just meant a lot.

Not because we were looking for recognition, but because moments like this remind us how far we’ve come. From late nights baking in our kitchen, to being trusted to create something special for our community… it’s a feeling we can’t fully explain 💕

Thank you again to everyone at the department for allowing us to be part of such a meaningful week. We truly appreciate the kindness, support, and love shown to our small business.

Also… seeing our cookies mentioned on official police department letterhead was definitely not on our 2026 bingo card 😭🍪🚔

✨ FUDGEZILLA IS BEING DISCONTINUED ✨See? We’re giving y’all closure.Not pulling a disappearing act like somebody’s dusty...
05/22/2026

✨ FUDGEZILLA IS BEING DISCONTINUED ✨

See? We’re giving y’all closure.
Not pulling a disappearing act like somebody’s dusty ex 😭🍫

After this Sunday, Fudgezilla will officially be gone from the menu.

Yep… the thick, fudgy, chocolate-loaded cookie that had some of y’all hiding cookies from your own family members is clocking out 😂💔

And before next week rolls around and our phone starts fighting for its life:
“Y’all got any Fudgezilla left?”
“No.”
“But can y’all make JUST TWO?”
ALSO NO 😭

This is your warning NOW so nobody can say we disappeared without saying anything 😂🍪

🗓️ Last day: THIS SUNDAY
💵 $5 each
📍 Pickup in Lake Wales

📲 Text (863) 614-0400 to place your final Fudgezilla orders 🍫

05/21/2026

YALLLLLL 😭🔥

At this point, these cookies basically packed their bags and started disappearing on their own 😂👏

Here’s what we got left:

🍫 5 S’mores
🍫 5 Nutella
🥜 4 Peanut Butter
🍪 3 Oatmeal Raisin
🍫 1 Double Chocolate

That’s ITTTTT 😮‍🔥

Stuffed cookies are $5 each and pickup is in Lake Wales 📍
We can also deliver to ILE if orders are over $50 👏🤍

Text to order: (863) 614-0400

Message us before somebody else beat you to your favorites because that lonely Double Chocolate hanging on by a thread right now 😭

✨ DESSERT OF THE MONTH ✨Yeahhhhh… our Carrot Cake Jar came in acting REAL confident this month 😮‍🔥🥕🤍Layers on layers of ...
05/21/2026

✨ DESSERT OF THE MONTH ✨

Yeahhhhh… our Carrot Cake Jar came in acting REAL confident this month 😮‍🔥🥕🤍

Layers on layers of soft, moist carrot cake with smooth cream cheese frosting packed into every single bite. Sweet, rich, perfectly spiced, and looking fineeeee while doing it 😭👏

This ain’t one of them dry little sad carrot cakes either.
She moist. She creamy. She got flavor. She got personality. She the main character this month 💅😂

Our 8oz jars are $8 each and honestly?
You might wanna grab two… because one for “later” somehow disappears real fast 👀😭

📍 Cake It or Leave It LLC
🌐 cakeitorleaveitllc.com
📞 (863) 614-0400

Unfortunately, Bite Nite for May 21st has been canceled 😭💔BUT Crafted Sundays is STILL ON 😌💗So, if you were planning on ...
05/20/2026

Unfortunately, Bite Nite for May 21st has been canceled 😭💔
BUT Crafted Sundays is STILL ON 😌💗

So, if you were planning on getting your Cake It or Leave It LLC fix this week… don’t wait till Sunday because these flavors might not survive that long 👀🍪

✨ Stuffed Cookies Available NOW: $5 each
• Oatmeal Raisin
• Double Chocolate
• Nutella
• Cotton Candy
• S’mores
• Peanut Butter

✨ Cookie Cups: $5 each
• Cookies N Creme
• Red Velvet
• Strawberry Crunch
• Apple Crisp
• Carrot Cake
• Snickers

✨ Cake Jars: $5
• Carrot Cake 🥕🍰

And then catch us again at Crafted Sundays:
🗓 May 24th
⏰ 12 PM – 4 PM
📍 Eagle Ridge Mall – Lake Wales, FL

There’ll be other amazing local vendors there too, so come shop small, snack a little, and support local businesses 💕

Address

Oleander Road
Lake Wales, FL
33898

Opening Hours

Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm

Website

https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029Vae8dFrJJhzOqQjkKU0M

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cake It Or Leave It LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cake It Or Leave It LLC:

Shortcuts

Share