Red Rooster Cookie Jar

Red Rooster Cookie Jar From the classroom to the kitchen after 25 years! Traded in lesson plans for recipes.
(3)

Retired middle school Spanish teacher, turned baker, ready for a new adventure! Pursuing a passion, Red Rooster Cookie Jar makes cookies from scratch the old school way, wooden spoon and all...Just like you would make if you had the time!

Our cookies are getting local love in Lady Lake — and we’re not crumb-ing around! Fresh from our hand-stirred kitchen, e...
06/03/2026

Our cookies are getting local love in Lady Lake — and we’re not crumb-ing around! Fresh from our hand-stirred kitchen, every bite tastes like homemade hugs. Whether you’re sending sweets down the street or across the country, we deliver and ship. Taste the praise for yourself at https://wix.to/3ZDP9oc 🍪🎉

Order now and make someone’s day — who will you surprise?

107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201

📣Sourdough Delivery Day!Fresh loaves arriving today from The Alchemist's Oven, perfectly crisp crust, but yet incredibly...
06/03/2026

📣Sourdough Delivery Day!

Fresh loaves arriving today from The Alchemist's Oven, perfectly crisp crust, but yet incredibly soft on the inside for the sourdough goodness you love. Stop by before they're gone - these beauties never stay on the shelf for long!

107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

Indulge in our exquisite selection of signature cakes designed to satisfy your deepest dessert cravings. Experience the ...
06/02/2026

Indulge in our exquisite selection of signature cakes designed to satisfy your deepest dessert cravings. Experience the warmth of our cinnamon crumb, the bright zest of our lemon crumb, or the nostalgic touch of our old-fashioned spice cake. For the ultimate treat, try our legendary ooey, gooey butter cake that melts in your mouth with every bite. Visit us today to bring home your favorite. https://wix.to/IEDsIjO

107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201

Oh honey...this week's is CINNA-SATIONAL! It's truly RUM-BAILEY-ABLE! It's serving full-blown CHURRO-MAGIC with a side...
06/01/2026

Oh honey...this week's is CINNA-SATIONAL! It's truly RUM-BAILEY-ABLE! It's serving full-blown CHURRO-MAGIC with a side of sass. BAILEY'S CHURRO is a French vanilla cookie baked with cinnamon chips, Baileys' and Rumchata then double dusted in cinnamon powdered sugar! They will be available starting on 6/1 in our bake shop located at 107 East Lady Lake Blvd.

M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com/today

📣CINNAMON ROLL ALERT📣The ovens are warming...The icing is waiting for its cue...And the cinnamon rolls are making their ...
05/30/2026

📣CINNAMON ROLL ALERT📣

The ovens are warming...
The icing is waiting for its cue...
And the cinnamon rolls are making their Saturday comeback!

Soft. Gooey. Swirled with brown sugar, cinnamon, and real butter and they will be dripping with icing soon like they mean business. Around 9:30 this morning the Red Rooster Cookie Jar bakery will get SWEET real fast!

107 East Lady Lake Blvd
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com/today

😍

It's FriYAY... which means tomorrow is CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY. 🐓The dough is rising tonight... The brown cinnamon sugar ...
05/29/2026

It's FriYAY... which means tomorrow is CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY. 🐓
The dough is rising tonight... The brown cinnamon sugar is ready.... The icing is waiting... and tomorrow morning the jumbo rolls will be coming out hot, gooey, buttery, and dripping in icing. 😍

Fair warning:
These beauties don't sit around long. 👀
See y'all tomorrow at Red Rooster Cookie Jar bakery!

107 East Lady Lake Blvd
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com/online-ordering

We bake like Grandma—if Grandma used the fanciest butter. Fresh cookies, rustic breads, and seasonal delights like our c...
05/28/2026

We bake like Grandma—if Grandma used the fanciest butter. Fresh cookies, rustic breads, and seasonal delights like our cookie of the week - ORANGE DREAMSICLE, made from scratch with no preservatives. Hand-stirred, oven-kissed, and ready to delight your taste buds. 🍪🥖🌸
Swing by our Lady Lake shop at 107 East Lady Lake Boulevard for pickup — orders and delivery available. Visit https://wix.to/eBCgh9z to order now! 🚗✨

M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201

I’m team Danish whisk. 🍪✨Hand-stirring cookie dough isn’t just nostalgic — it keeps cookies tender, lets you feel when t...
05/27/2026

I’m team Danish whisk. 🍪✨

Hand-stirring cookie dough isn’t just nostalgic — it keeps cookies tender, lets you feel when the mix is just right, and saves you from a mess of cords and flying flour. Here in humid Florida, a gentle stir helps avoid flat, sad cookies (no mini hurricanes in the oven, please).

Use a sturdy wooden spoon or a Danish whisk and take it slow. You’ll get even chips, chewy centers, and the kind of cookies your grandma would wink at. Plus — bonus arm workout. Who needs the gym when you’ve got dough? 🥄💪

Ready to stir up some magic? Tell me: wooden spoon or whisk — which team are you?

107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201

Serving "main squeeze" energy. Totally "zest-worthy". Sweet, creamy, and proof that anything is "pop-sicle" with enough ...
05/26/2026

Serving "main squeeze" energy. Totally "zest-worthy". Sweet, creamy, and proof that anything is "pop-sicle" with enough sugar and attitude. Out here making every other dessert melt under pressure. Meet our ORANGE DREAMSICLE baked with orange juice and cream cheese chips, then dipped in orange cream Yum Crumbs. They will be available starting on 5/26 in our bake shop located at 107 East Lady Lake Blvd. 🍊
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

This Memorial Day, we pause to remember and honor the brave men and women who gave everything for our freedom. From all...
05/25/2026

This Memorial Day, we pause to remember and honor the brave men and women who gave everything for our freedom. From all of us at Red Rooster Cookie Jar bakery, thank you to those who served, sacrificed, and are forever remembered.

Today the bake shop is closed so that we may gather with grateful hearts, full tables, and the freedom to share sweet moments because of them.

107 East Lady Lake Blvd.
T-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

Address

107 E. Lady Lake Boulevard
Lady Lake, FL
32159

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 11am - 3pm

Telephone

+13522040201

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Red Rooster Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category