Milk Sugar Love

Milk Sugar Love Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is churning delightfully delicious ice cream, cakes and baked goo Come on by and discover Milk Sugar Love!
(265)

We serve 12 ice cream flavors daily at the shop, with our top four available every day: Vanilla Bean, Salted Caramel, Classic Chocolate and Lemon Olive Oil. Our remaining flavors change daily according to what beautiful New Jersey produce we find to use at our local farmers markets. Follow us on Instagram, Twitter or Facebook to see what we are scooping! Our custom cakes start at $150 because we c

reate them just for you and your special event. You bring us your ideas and we design, bake and build the cake of your dreams, with your choice of flavors of course! The final price depends on how many people you need to serve and how much detail your design of choice includes. Custom cakes and wedding cakes can be either covered in buttercream or fondant, whichever you prefer. In addition to our ice creams and cakes, we’re baking up other sweet treat favorites like macaroons, cupcakes, tarts, cookies, ice cream sandwiches and more.

05/11/2026

How we make our home made ice cream sandwiches! 🍪 🍦

Get mom a cone or a cup! Or both!
05/10/2026

Get mom a cone or a cup! Or both!

🎉SUPER BOWL GIVEAWAY🎉Our friends at are helping us give away 50 FREE PINTS OF ICE CREAM📆February 8, 2pm-10pm📍Milk Sugar...
02/08/2026

🎉SUPER BOWL GIVEAWAY🎉

Our friends at are helping us give away

50 FREE PINTS OF ICE CREAM

📆February 8, 2pm-10pm

📍Milk Sugar Love
1319 Memorial Drive
Asbury Park

Any flavor! One per guest!
Counts towards your pint loyalty points!

Grab a hot chocolate while you’re here and snag that free pint!

01/29/2026

COFFEE AND PASTRIES

📆January 31 10am-2pm

📍Milk Sugar Love
1319 Memorial Drive
Asbury Park

Enjoy fresh-baked goodies from and limited edition coffee drinks from us at Milk Sugar Love, including this

TIRAMISU LATTE
Handmade Chocolate Syrup
Espresso + Milk
Mascarpone Cold Foam
Baby Tiramisu Slice!!!!!

See you Saturday!

01/22/2026

Burgers, Shakes &45s

January 24 3pm-6pm
Milk Sugar Love
1319 Memorial Drive
Asbury Park

Sizzling Smash Burgers by
Great tunes by and
classic ice cream shop treats like Malts, Shakes, Floats and Egg Creams from

An Egg Cream is an old-school ice cream shop favorite that contains no eggs and no cream 😂

It's ice cold milk, chocolate syrup, and seltzer, stirred vigorously together to create a beautiful, foamy, refreshing drink.

🎉PRE-ORDERS ARE LIVE!🎉KING CAKESTwisted sweet dough filled with Cinnamon Brown Sugar, baked, glazed and dusted with spri...
01/16/2026

🎉PRE-ORDERS ARE LIVE!🎉

KING CAKES
Twisted sweet dough filled with Cinnamon Brown Sugar, baked, glazed and dusted with sprinkles

Available for pickup in Asbury Park OR Jersey City on Feb 15, 16 or 17!

VALENTINE’S DAY
Pre-order for pickup on February 13 in Asbury Park OR Jersey City.

Treats include:

💖 Individual Heart-Shaped Fudge Brownies

💖 Classic Baby Tiramisu (this is an actual Tiramisu, not ice cream!!)

💖 Dark Chocolate Shortbread Heart-Shaped Samdwich Cookies

💖 Giant Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake (which you can personalize with a name of your choice!)

All treats come boxed and tied with a red bow for the holiday.

Pre-orders end Feb 8 for both menus so place your orders today!

12/18/2025

Have you followed the treasure map to all these local, small businesses yet for all your holiday shopping?

Redeem an offer at each stop by 12/21 for a chance to win a prize!









Address

19 McWilliams Place
Jersey City, NJ
07302

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Milk Sugar Love posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Milk Sugar Love:

Shortcuts

Share