Clicky

Milk Sugar Love

Milk Sugar Love Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop is churning delightfully delicious ice cream, cakes and baked goods using all natural and organic dairy & local NJ produce.

We serve 12 ice cream flavors daily at the shop, with our top four available every day: Vanilla Bean, Salted Caramel, Classic Chocolate and Lemon Olive Oil. Our remaining flavors change daily according to what beautiful New Jersey produce we find to use at our local farmers markets. Follow us on Instagram, Twitter or Facebook to see what we are scooping! Our custom cakes start at $150 because we c

We serve 12 ice cream flavors daily at the shop, with our top four available every day: Vanilla Bean, Salted Caramel, Classic Chocolate and Lemon Olive Oil. Our remaining flavors change daily according to what beautiful New Jersey produce we find to use at our local farmers markets. Follow us on Instagram, Twitter or Facebook to see what we are scooping! Our custom cakes start at $150 because we c

Price Range: ££

Operating as usual

TOMORROW!PB Oreo is back in scoops and pints--- creamy Peanut Butter ice cream chock full of our own chocolate cream-fil...
03/24/2022

TOMORROW!

PB Oreo is back in scoops and pints--- creamy Peanut Butter ice cream chock full of our own chocolate cream-filled cookies.

It's our OG collab with @laughatmyfood and it's returning for the third time this year because you all love it so much.

PLUS watch out for the Thai Tea Mac Daddy tomorrow too!!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #handmade #local #smallbatch

Feels like spring out here!Stop by the shop for a scoop or three or order for pickup or delivery with @chownow and @uber...
03/15/2022

Feels like spring out here!

Stop by the shop for a scoop or three or order for pickup or delivery with @chownow and @uberEATS !

Carrot Cake, Alfajores 'n' Cream and Snickerdoodle stacked up for the win!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #smallbiz #local #allnatural #open #delivery

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   at Hamilton Park...🍦 CARROT CAKE - Cream cheese ice cream with pieces of our own carrot cake, ma...
03/11/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
at Hamilton Park...

🍦 CARROT CAKE - Cream cheese ice cream with pieces of our own carrot cake, made with coconut, raisins and spices

🍦 SNICKERDOODLE - Cinnamon ice cream swirled with our own crumbled Snickerdoodle cookies

Flavors go live on the website at 10am for delivery and pickup or swing by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy ice cream sandwich is made with two Fruity Pebble Macarons and Fruity Pebble ice cream and r...
03/07/2022

The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy ice cream sandwich is made with two Fruity Pebble Macarons and Fruity Pebble ice cream and rolled in Fruity Pebbles

Available for pickup, delivery or in-store purchase every day! And perfect for #nationalcerealday !

#MILKSUGARLOVE #handmade #local #smallbatch #sprinkles

The Birthday Sprinkle ice cream sandwich is made with two of our own Birthday Sprinkle all butter cookies, Vanilla ice c...
03/06/2022

The Birthday Sprinkle ice cream sandwich is made with two of our own Birthday Sprinkle all butter cookies, Vanilla ice cream and loads of rainbow sprinkles.

Available for pickup, delivery or in-store purchase every day!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #handmade #loca #smallbatch #sprinkles

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   at Hamilton Park...🍦 MASCARPONE CHERRY - Creamy mascarpone ice cream with candied sour cherries ...
03/04/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
at Hamilton Park...

🍦 MASCARPONE CHERRY - Creamy mascarpone ice cream with candied sour cherries

🍦 ORANGE ALMOND CAKE - Creamy orange ice cream with loads of almond cake pieces (don't sleep on this one---the cake is amazing!!)

Flavors go live on the website at 10am for delivery and pickup or swing by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

The March ScoopWe’re whipping up lots of flavors with cakes, cookies and of course marshmallows for the month of March a...
02/28/2022
Who Loves Marshmallows?!?

The March Scoop

We’re whipping up lots of flavors with cakes, cookies and of course marshmallows for the month of March at Milk Sugar Love!

MARCH 4

Mascarpone Cherry
Creamy mascarpone ice cream with candied sour cherries
Allergens: Milk

Orange Almond Cake
Creamy orange ice cream with almond cake pieces
Allergens: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts (almonds)

MARCH 11

Carrot Cake
Cream cheese ice cream with pieces of our own carrot cake, made with coconut, raisins and spices
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Coconut)

Snickerdoodle
Cinnamon ice cream swirled with our own crumbled Snickerdoodle cookies
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Eggs

MARCH 18

Malted Marshmallow
Malty ice cream chock full of tiny, multi-colored marshmallows (just like that cereal we all loved growing up!)
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Soy

Mint Chip
Minty, light green ice cream with dark chocolate chips
Allergens: Milk, Soy

MARCH 25

PB Oreo
It's back...for the 3rd time this year! Classic Peanut Butter ice cream filled to the brim with our own chocolate cream-filled cookies
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Soy, Peanuts

Thai Tea Mac Daddy Ice Cream Sandwich
Thai Tea ice cream sandwiched between two orange colored French Macarons
Allergens: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Almonds)

Visit our website to place your orders for delivery or pickup! New flavors launch Fridays at 10am so mark your calendar to make sure you snag the specialty pint (or two!) of your choice.

Click here for an update from !

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   .at Hamilton Park...🍦 SALTED CASHEW - Sweet Cream ice cream with dulce de leche and salted cashe...
02/25/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
.at Hamilton Park...

🍦 SALTED CASHEW - Sweet Cream ice cream with dulce de leche and salted cashews

🍦 RICOTTA PISTACHIO - Ricotta ice cream with candied pistachios

I paired them with Guava Cream Cheese and Mascarpone Cherry (currently in the case right now too!) in this Pink Vanilla @thekonery cone!

Flavors go live on the website at 10am for delivery and pickup or swing by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

ALFAJORES 'N' CREAM is back in stock --- sweet cream ice cream with ripples of Dulce de Leche and pieces of our own coco...
02/24/2022

ALFAJORES 'N' CREAM is back in stock --- sweet cream ice cream with ripples of Dulce de Leche and pieces of our own coconut cookie.

Available in pints and scoops in the shop or for delivery and pickup with @chownow and @uberEATS !

#MILKSUGARLOVE #Delivery #pickup #open #dulcedeleche

We've got @parlorcoffee Cold Brew ready for you at the shop plus fresh baked cookies and tons of scoops and ice cream sa...
02/23/2022

We've got @parlorcoffee Cold Brew ready for you at the shop plus fresh baked cookies and tons of scoops and ice cream sandwiches! #MILKSUGARLOVE #coldbrew #spring #local #smallbiz

We've got some fantastic flavors in scoops and pints this weekend---Drop on by to try them all (or order for delivery th...
02/19/2022

We've got some fantastic flavors in scoops and pints this weekend---Drop on by to try them all (or order for delivery through @ubereats !

🌟Coconut Magic

🌟Guava Cream Cheese

🌟Key Lime Pie

🌟Cookies 'n' Cream

#MILKSUGARLOVE #Delivery #icecream

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   ...a taste of summer at Hamilton Park...🍦 KEY LIME PIE - Lime ice cream with lime cream and salt...
02/18/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
...a taste of summer at Hamilton Park...

🍦 KEY LIME PIE - Lime ice cream with lime cream and salted graham pieces

🍦 COCONUT MAGIC - Coconut ice cream with Magic Bar bites (think the best of salty sweet with graham crust, almonds, dulce de leche and coconut)

Swing on by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   ...at Hamilton Park...🍦 RED VELVET DREAM - Cream Cheese ice cream swirled with our own Red Velve...
02/11/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
...at Hamilton Park...

🍦 RED VELVET DREAM - Cream Cheese ice cream swirled with our own Red Velvet cake

🍦 RASPBERRY ROSE - Raspberry ice cream with just a hint of rose water and a sprinkling of dark chocolate chips

PLUS extra Red Velvet Cakewiches, Mega Cookies and adorable cupcakes available for immediate pickup!

Swing on by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

Happy Friday and welcome to a new month of Friday Flavors!πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   ...at Hamilton Park...🍦 Vanilla Toffee...
02/04/2022

Happy Friday and welcome to a new month of Friday Flavors!

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
...at Hamilton Park...

🍦 Vanilla Toffee Walnut Blondie - Vanilla ice cream with Toffee Walnut Blondie bites (think chewy blondie goodness made with brown sugar, toasted walnuts and toffee crunch)
🍦 LEMON RASPBERRY CRUMB - Lemony ice cream with Raspberry Bar bites (think a jammy masterpiece made with brown sugar shortbread, raspberry jam and a crumb topping)

Swing on by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

The February ScoopAre you ready to hear about this month’s specialty flavors, two new flavors dropping every Friday at 9...
01/31/2022
New Flavors to Love

The February Scoop

Are you ready to hear about this month’s specialty flavors, two new flavors dropping every Friday at 9am?? Take a look at what we have in store for February and plan accordingly so you can get a hold of a pint or scoop when your favorite new flavor comes out!

February 4

Vanilla Toffee Walnut Blondie
Vanilla ice cream with Toffee Walnut Blondie bites (think chewy blondie goodness made with brown sugar, toasted walnuts and toffee crunch)
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy, Tree Nuts (Walnuts)

Lemon Raspberry Crumb
Lemony ice cream with Raspberry Crumb bites (think a jammy masterpiece with brown sugar shortbread, raspberry jam and brown sugar crunch)
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Eggs

February 11

Raspberry Rose
Raspberry ice cream with a hint of rose and tiny flecks of dark chocolate
Allergens: Milk, Soy

The Red Velvet Cakewich (pictured above)
Cream Cheese ice cream sandwiched between two pieces of our own fluffy and flavorful red velvet cake
Allergens: Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy

February 18

Key Lime Pie
Lime ice cream with lime cream and salted graham pieces
Allergens: Milk, Eggs, Wheat

Coconut Magic
Coconut ice cream with Magic Bar bites (think the best of salty sweet with graham crust, almonds, dulce de leche and coconut)
Allergens: Milk, Soy, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Almonds)

February 18

Salted Cashew
Sweet Cream ice cream with with buttered, salted cashews and Dulce de Leche
Allergens: Milk, Tree Nuts (Cashews)

Ricotta Pistachio
Ricotta ice cream with candied pistachios
Allergens: Milk, Tree Nuts (Pistachios)

Valentine's Day is almost here!

Don't forget to place your orders on our website now for our Valentine’s Day menu which includes an amazing *NEW* Snack Cake in Red Velvet with Cream Cheese frosting. It's perfect for a small celebration or for a cozy night in!

Click here for an update from Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop!

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   ...at Hamilton Park...🍦 PB OREO - Peanut Butter ice cream with our own chocolate cream-filled co...
01/21/2022

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
...at Hamilton Park...

🍦 PB OREO - Peanut Butter ice cream with our own chocolate cream-filled cookies (our OG collab with @laughatmyfood )
🍦 MINT CHIP - Minty, light green ice cream with dark chocolate chips

Swing on by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

Happy Friday and hurray for new flavors!πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—   ...at Hamilton Park...🍦 LEMON MERINGUE - A light lemony ...
01/14/2022

Happy Friday and hurray for new flavors!

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—
...at Hamilton Park...

🍦 LEMON MERINGUE - A light lemony ice cream with Lemon Cream, Toasted Meringue and Salted Graham Crumb
🍦 CREAM CHEESE GUAVE - This flavor has quickly become my absolute obsession---rich, Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava Jam

Swing on by for a special scoop and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

To cold out to leave the house?? No worries, we deliver! You can order on our website through ChowNow or starting today,...
01/09/2022

To cold out to leave the house??

No worries, we deliver! You can order on our website through ChowNow or starting today, look us up on uberEATS!!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #handmade #icecream#smallbiz #womanowned #smallbatch #jerseycity #hoboken #bakery #pastry #sevenlayer #local #newjersey #jerseycity #eats #delivery #uberEATS #chownow

We're hiring!For all locations, all positions.And now it's easier than ever to apply directly on our website on the care...
12/27/2021

We're hiring!

For all locations, all positions.

And now it's easier than ever to apply directly on our website on the careers page by filling out our online questionnaire.

Find the direct link in our stories and apply today!
#MILKSUGARLOVE #hiring #apply #open

Milk Sugar Love is closed 12/24 and 12/25 --- Happy Holidays and we'll see you Sunday, 12/26!#MILKSUGARLOVE #holidayhour...
12/24/2021

Milk Sugar Love is closed 12/24 and 12/25 --- Happy Holidays and we'll see you Sunday, 12/26!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #holidayhours

ICE CREAM FOR LUNCH!Any delivery or pickup order of $20 or over from 11am to 3pm Tuesdays through Thursdays will get a F...
12/21/2021

ICE CREAM FOR LUNCH!

Any delivery or pickup order of $20 or over from 11am to 3pm Tuesdays through Thursdays will get a FREE ICE CREAM SANDWICH!

πŸ’–Go to milksugarlove.com
πŸ’–Place your order
πŸ’–Make sure to add your ice cream sandwich of choice to your cart
πŸ’–Apply code LUNCH21 at checkout!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #deal #free #icecreamsandwich

DID YOU KNOW that if you sign up for our loyalty program, you can earn a FREE PINT of ice cream?!Yes that's right, sign ...
12/16/2021

DID YOU KNOW that if you sign up for our loyalty program, you can earn a FREE PINT of ice cream?!

Yes that's right, sign up in store or online, buy any 10 pints and get a pint of your choice for free.

Link in stories!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #loyalty #rewards #smallbiz

COQUITO MAC DADDY ice cream sandwiches are still available at Hamilton and for delivery too!πŸŽ„Two classic almond French M...
12/15/2021

COQUITO MAC DADDY ice cream sandwiches are still available at Hamilton and for delivery too!

πŸŽ„Two classic almond French Macarons
πŸŽ„ Coquito ice cream (think coconut, cinnamon and rum goodness)
πŸŽ„Dulce de Leche center 🀯

Tag us in your pics with #MILKSUGARLOVE

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž  NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—    πŸŽ„ PEPPERMINT STICK COOKIES 'N' CREAM - Pink Mint ice cream with candy cane crunch and tons of o...
12/10/2021

πŸ’—πŸ€πŸ€Ž NOW SCOOPING πŸ€ŽπŸ€πŸ’—

πŸŽ„ PEPPERMINT STICK COOKIES 'N' CREAM - Pink Mint ice cream with candy cane crunch and tons of our handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies
πŸŽ„ CINNAMON HONEY GRAHAM - Honey ice cream chock-full of our own cinnamon honey graham pieces

Available in pints in scoops at Hamilton Park (the Heights is closed for the winter)! Swing on by for some scoops and share your sweet snaps with us using #MILKSUGARLOVE

GIFT CARDS are back!! PLUS don't forget about our Hot Cocoa Bombe gift set: One dark chocolate Cocoa Bombe, one giant mu...
12/09/2021

GIFT CARDS are back!!

PLUS don't forget about our Hot Cocoa Bombe gift set: One dark chocolate Cocoa Bombe, one giant mug, one dunkable hand-decorated sugar cookie!

#MILKSUGARLOVE #open #icecreaminwinter #gifting #holiday

We are open today at Hamilton Park! We'll be slinging scoops and packing pints Tuesdays through Sundays 11am - 9pm this ...
12/07/2021

We are open today at Hamilton Park!

We'll be slinging scoops and packing pints Tuesdays through Sundays 11am - 9pm this winter (and also sending out your local delivery orders from our website milksugarlove.com !).

#MILKSUGARLOVE #open #icecreaminwinter

Our mug gift set is now available at Hamilton Park! It includes:πŸŽ„One festive dark chocolate cocoa bombeπŸŽ„One giant 15oz M...
12/04/2021

Our mug gift set is now available at Hamilton Park! It includes:

πŸŽ„One festive dark chocolate cocoa bombe
πŸŽ„One giant 15oz Milk Sugar Love Mug
πŸŽ„One hand decorated sugar cookie, perfect for dunking in the hot cocoa!

Order yours for pickup or delivery at milksugarlove.com (it's under our MERCH category!) or drop by and pick it up in-store.

#MILKSUGARLOVE #holiday #hotcocoabombe #gifting

Address

19 McWilliams Pl
Jersey City, NJ
07302

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

(201) 984-0530

Services

  • Catering
  • Kids
  • Takeout
  • Walkins

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Milk Sugar Love posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Milk Sugar Love:

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Jersey City

Show All

Comments

if you ever decide to branch out again please consider coming to Hackettstown
Just parked 5 blocks away to walk to your Palisade spot ready to buy 3 pints but it was closed! πŸ₯΅
The ice cream is great but I can really say the same about their customer service. The ladies behind the desk would probably be better off selling make up or some vein product at the mall.
Wish you guys had a location in Toledo, OH. I love ice cream. We don't have enough shops like this here.
When does you JC Heights store ope?❕
When will the Heights location open?
So cool to run into you! The business looks awesome and the ice cream was delicious!
So cool to run into you! The business looks awesome and the ice cream was delicious!
So cool to run into you! The business looks awesome and the ice cream was delicious!
So cool to run into you! The business looks awesome and the ice cream was delicious!
So cool to run into you! The business looks awesome and the ice cream was delicious!
Jersey City Arts and Philosophy lovers! Support local artists as we raise funds to realize a fascinating theater production, "Prologue", coming this September at the Jersey City Theater Center "Prologue" is a mixed-media performance created as a composition of moments – snapshots into the life and thought of French philosopher, activist, and mystic, Simone Weil (1909 – 1943). Donations are tax-deductible, and can also get you tickets to the performance and other perks. Most importantly, you will be supporting local artists (playwright, director, and visual artists in the project are all Van Vorst neighbors!) Click on the link below to learn more and to offer your contribution: https://fundraising.fracturedatlas.org/prolo…/campaigns/2015 Thank YOU!