Bushel & a Peck Cookie Co. - Custom Buttercream Cookies

Bushel & a Peck Cookie Co. - Custom Buttercream Cookies Cookie treats inspired by my childhood memories & family recipes.

Guranteed to be a favorite at the dinner table & your next event! 🩷💛

DM me & lets bake up something special for you! 💝

✅ Licensed Baker
📍Jeffersonville, IN
💰Venmo, CashApp, PayPal

09/02/2026

🗣️Something has been on my mind a lot lately & I want your thoughts: AI & Customer Trust🗣️

I think we’re entering an era where being REAL is going to be one of the biggest competitive advantages a small business can have.

The other day I heard the term “trust economy” and I thought, what a great term to label our economy right now.

So what exactly is a “trust economy”?

Basically, it’s the idea that trust has become one of the most valuable things a business can offer to its customers.

To me, I think a trust economy is customers want to see the real person behind the business. They want to see the actual product. They want to know that the photos are real, the reviews are real and that the person taking their money is actually the person making what they ordered.

And honestly? I get it!

Especially when it comes to something handmade.

That’s one reason I’m intentional about showing you MY cookies. Not AI-generated cookies. Not a picture of a “perfect” cookie that doesn’t actually exist. Not something designed to make you think, “Oh, THAT’S what mine will look like.”

When you order from Bushel & a Peck, I want you to see the actual cookies I make. The actual colors. The actual designs. The actual buttercream.

Because I want you to know exactly who is on the other side of your order.

I’m not a big bakery. I’m not a factory. There isn’t a team of people or an algorithm making your cookies.

It’s just me, Haley.🥹

And I think that’s worth something.

Small business might not always be the cheapest or the most polished option. But you know who you’re supporting. And I think that matters more than ever.💝

And let me be honest, I don’t think AI is inherently bad. There are absolutely ways it can be useful for small businesses. For me personally, it helps me color match almost perfectly!

But I do think there’s a difference between using technology to help run your business and using it to create an illusion of a product or experience that doesn’t actually exist.

So let me ask you:

When you’re buying from a small business, what makes you trust them? Reviews? Product photos? Or something else I’m not aware of?

Tell me! I really want to hear your thoughts on this one!👇

🍪COOKIE TALK TUESDAY: HOW DO I DESIGN MY COOKIES?🎨I had someone ask me recently:“Do you use a projector to get your desi...
09/02/2026

🍪COOKIE TALK TUESDAY: HOW DO I DESIGN MY COOKIES?🎨

I had someone ask me recently:

“Do you use a projector to get your designs onto the cookies, or do you freehand them?”👀

I thought that was such a good question!

The answer is…it depends on the design!

For simpler designs, florals, shapes and details I’ve gotten comfortable with, I can freehand quite a bit of it. I didn’t take AP Art for nothing in high school.😂😅

For logos & characters that require precise designing, I use my projector to project designs I’ve already sketched out in Canva.

Even with my projector though, every line, dot, swirl, flower and little detail is piped individually. There isn’t a machine putting the icing on the cookie for me!😂

And honestly, one of my favorite parts of making custom cookies is taking a design someone has envisioned and figuring out how to translate it onto a cookie. Especially if it’s a royal icing design that I have to figure out how to translate to buttercream!

So now you know a little more about what happens behind the cookie designing stage at Bushel & a Peck.💝

What else have you always wondered about custom cookies? Drop your questions below!👇🏻🍪

💋The cookie set of my teenage dreams💄What a fun set this was to put together! As a makeup lover myself I thought this th...
09/01/2026

💋The cookie set of my teenage dreams💄

What a fun set this was to put together! As a makeup lover myself I thought this theme was so cute for a birthday! In my teens & early 20s I was obsessed with Sephora, but as I’ve gotten older I find myself more of an Ulta girlie.😋

If you wear makeup, do you shop at Sephora or Ulta?🤩💄

🍪BUSHEL & A PECK COOKIE CO. MENU & ORDERING INFO🍪Our menu with our new cookie flavors is here!💝Not sure which flavor to ...
08/31/2026

🍪BUSHEL & A PECK COOKIE CO. MENU & ORDERING INFO🍪

Our menu with our new cookie flavors is here!💝

Not sure which flavor to choose? Here’s your place to start!👇🏻

I currently offer three delicious buttercream cookie flavors:

🍪 ORIGINAL SUGAR
Our classic, buttery sugar cookie. The signature flavor that started it all!

🍫 CHOCOLATE VELVET ($3/per dozen upcharge)
A rich, decadent chocolate cookie with a subtle hint of espresso.

🍂 CINNAMON SUGAR ($3/per dozen upcharge)
A warm, cinnamon-sugar cookie with cozy seasonal spice. Available September–December!

📋 HOW TO ORDER
Ready to place an order? Send me a DM with:
• Your event date
• Number of dozen cookies needed
• Flavor(s)
• Theme/design you’re looking for

I’ll check my availability and get you a quote!☺️💝

A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to reserve your date, with the remaining balance due at day of pickup.

📍 Porch pickup: Jeffersonville, IN
🍪 Minimum order: 1 dozen

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, shower, graduation, holiday or just need an excuse for cookies, I’d love to bake something special for you.💝

Save this post for when you’re ready to order, and don’t hesitate to send me a message with any questions!🧁

🍫✨INTRODUCING CHOCOLATE VELVET✨🍫I told you I was releasing another flavor, and this one does not disappoint! A little ri...
08/30/2026

🍫✨INTRODUCING CHOCOLATE VELVET✨🍫

I told you I was releasing another flavor, and this one does not disappoint!

A little richer. A little more indulgent. And definitely not your average sugar cookie.🤎🤤

Meet Chocolate Velvet: a soft, buttery chocolate cookie with a deep cocoa flavor and just the right touch of sweetness. It’s the perfect cookie for the chocolate lovers.🍪

And the best part? Chocolate Velvet is officially a permanent flavor at Bushel & a Peck Cookie Co.! 🎉

But…this isn’t the only thing happening around here. 👀

Our NEW menu drops TOMORROW EVENING!💝✨
New flavors, updated ordering information and a couple other exciting things I’ve been working on behind the scenes are finally ready to share.

So if you’re wondering what’s coming next…come back tomorrow.💝

🍫Chocolate Velvet: available with a $3/dozen flavor upcharge.

🎓🦷A smile worth celebrating!🦷🎓Throwback Thursday to this sweet dental school graduation set!🥹✨Congratulations, Doctor Sy...
08/28/2026

🎓🦷A smile worth celebrating!🦷🎓

Throwback Thursday to this sweet dental school graduation set!🥹✨

Congratulations, Doctor Sydney!🥳🦷 Your hard work, dedication and countless hours of studying have officially paid off!

And of course…the best part of graduation is having something sweet to celebrate with!🍪💝

🐶HAPPY NATIONAL DOG DAY!🐾Naturally, I had to celebrate with sharing one the cutest cookies I’ve ever done.☺️🐶Today I wan...
08/26/2026

🐶HAPPY NATIONAL DOG DAY!🐾

Naturally, I had to celebrate with sharing one the cutest cookies I’ve ever done.☺️🐶

Today I want to see the real stars of the show… YOUR DOGS!🐕💝

Drop a photo of your pup in the comments! I want to see all the good boys, good girls, spoiled babies, troublemakers and everything in between. 😂

And yes, I’ll be sharing my own spoiled boy in the comments too!🐾

🍪WELCOME TO COOKIE TALK TUESDAYS!🍪I’ve been wanting to start a little weekly series where I can share the things that ha...
08/26/2026

🍪WELCOME TO COOKIE TALK TUESDAYS!🍪

I’ve been wanting to start a little weekly series where I can share the things that happen behind the cookie making. Like decorating tricks, cookie facts, baker confessions and maybe a few opinions along the way.😂

So…welcome to COOKIE TALK TUESDAYS!💝

And for our very first topic, let’s talk about something that seems simple but can actually make a BIG difference when decorating:

🎨BUTTERCREAM vs. ROYAL ICING: COLORING🫟

One of my larger learning curves I went through when I started decorating cookies with buttercream was learning how buttercream behaves with food coloring. Because buttercream has a naturally creamy pale yellow base (hello, butter!), colors can sometimes look a little softer or more muted than they do in royal icing.

Royal icing, on the other hand, starts out much whiter, so colors can often appear brighter and more true-to-color.

And here’s the fun part…the color you see when you first mix your icing isn’t always the color you’ll end up with!👀

Colors such as primary colors & black/brown deepen and develop as the icing sits, which is why I always decorate my lighter in color cookies first. This gives the darker colors time to develop!

So if you’ve ever wondered why your cookie baker asks, “What shade of pink?” instead of just “Pink?”… now you know.😂🌸

What should we talk about next Tuesday?👇🏼

Drop your buttercream cookie questions below!🍪💝

🚂🍪A little trip down memory lane with this birthday set!❤️💙💛💚When designing this cookie set, I wanted the cars to have t...
08/25/2026

🚂🍪A little trip down memory lane with this birthday set!❤️💙💛💚

When designing this cookie set, I wanted the cars to have that nostalgic look of the little toy cars we all used to play with on those wooden tracks as kids.🥹🍪

From the fire trucks and construction ‘digger’ to the traffic lights and “HONK BEEP CHOO CHOO” signs, this whole set was SO much fun to bring to life!

Happy Birthday, little buddy!🎉💙🚗

🍂YOU PICKED OUR NEW FLAVOR…AND I MADE IT!🍂And after taste testing these today, I don’t know how this flavor doesn’t beco...
08/24/2026

🍂YOU PICKED OUR NEW FLAVOR…AND I MADE IT!🍂

And after taste testing these today, I don’t know how this flavor doesn’t become a best seller this fall.🤤

✨CINNAMON SUGAR IS HERE!✨

You guys knew exactly what you were asking for because you picked a GOOD one.🤎

Cinnamon sugar is a buttery sugar cookie infused with warm cinnamon and cozy fall spices, topped with my signature fluffy vanilla buttercream. Basically, fall in cookie form.🍂🍪

This flavor is going to be PERFECT for all of your fall get-togethers!🍁 Whether you’re throwing a spooky Halloween party, hosting Thanksgiving, celebrating a fall birthday or just want a cozy treat to share, Cinnamon Sugar will be the perfect fall treat to share with your family & friends!🤎

Because this is a specialty flavor, Cinnamon Sugar will be $3/dozen more than my original sugar buttercream cookies.

BUT WAIT…I didn’t stop at one new flavor. And yes, I know I sound like an infomercial right now.😂

You picked one new flavor.🫵🏻

Annnd…I picked one new flavor.😉

And the flavor I chose is going to be a PERMANENT addition to the cutout cookie flavors menu.

But you’ll have to wait just a little longer to find out what it is…👀🍫

🍁🍂Cinnamon Sugar will be available September–December ONLY, so get your fall orders in ASAP!🍁🍂

Stay tuned for flavor #2!👀

Address

Jeffersonville, IN
47130

Telephone

+18593245480

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bushel & a Peck Cookie Co. - Custom Buttercream Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bushel & a Peck Cookie Co. - Custom Buttercream Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category