Shelly's Cookies

Shelly's Cookies A home bakery based in Interlaken, NY, making decorated sugar cookies, traditional and specialty cookies, brownies, double-crust fruit pies, and cupcakes.

Delivery can be arranged locally (Interlaken, Ovid, Lodi, Willard areas) for a small fee, and orders can be shipped within New York State only.

50th anniversary cookies for a custom order.
09/01/2026

50th anniversary cookies for a custom order.

08/31/2026

Shelly's Cookies would like to thank everyone that came out to the fair and purchased our baked goods. It was a very successful first year for us and we will be back next year! Thanks again.

Pretty pink baby shower cookies.
08/09/2026

Pretty pink baby shower cookies.

Camping cookies for a little camper.
08/04/2026

Camping cookies for a little camper.

Some cute little monkey cookies for a birthday girl.
07/31/2026

Some cute little monkey cookies for a birthday girl.

Special customer order. All decorated by hand. Not perfect, but customer loved them!
07/26/2026

Special customer order. All decorated by hand. Not perfect, but customer loved them!

07/17/2026

Black raspberry pie orders are closed. Thank you to everyone that ordered!

Now taking orders for fresh, made to order black raspberry pies. I have a limited amount of berries, so they will go fa...
07/16/2026

Now taking orders for fresh, made to order black raspberry pies. I have a limited amount of berries, so they will go fast!

She's the cherry on top cookies for an order today. Pretty cute.
06/29/2026

She's the cherry on top cookies for an order today. Pretty cute.

Pink princess cookies for an order this weekend.
06/29/2026

Pink princess cookies for an order this weekend.

Address

County Road 139
Interlaken, NY
14847

Telephone

+16075324856

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shelly's Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shelly's Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category