Shelly's Cookies

Shelly's Cookies A home bakery based in Interlaken, NY, making decorated sugar cookies, traditional and specialty cookies, brownies, double-crust fruit pies, and cupcakes.

Delivery can be arranged locally (Interlaken, Ovid, Lodi, Willard areas) for a small fee, and orders can be shipped within New York State only.

Fresh baked pies going out for delivery this morning. Happy Memorial Day everyone!
05/25/2026

Fresh baked pies going out for delivery this morning. Happy Memorial Day everyone!

Yummy treats that went out for an order this week.
05/23/2026

Yummy treats that went out for an order this week.

How cute are these little guys! They will be landing at The Burdett Exchange tomorrow.
05/14/2026

How cute are these little guys! They will be landing at The Burdett Exchange tomorrow.

Updated cookie options and pricing for 2026! Contact me here, or via phone or email, with any questions.
05/11/2026

Updated cookie options and pricing for 2026! Contact me here, or via phone or email, with any questions.

05/08/2026

We’re gearing up for the annual parade, happening June 20th! We’ll need lots of candy, if you’re able to donate, we’d greatly appreciate it! Monetary donations will be used to buy candy, and if we have enough, buy some little toys to toss out which were a big hit last year (a pack of 100 tiny dinos is less than $10!). Also we’re looking for an old patio umbrella, if anyone has one they don’t want, we’d take it! We have a fun prop in mind!

Limited time only! Get your Mother’s Day decorated sugar cookies from Shelly's Cookies at Hearth & Harvest tomorrow, May...
05/07/2026

Limited time only! Get your Mother’s Day decorated sugar cookies from Shelly's Cookies at Hearth & Harvest tomorrow, May 8th!

Some cute little jungle baby animal cookies for a birthday.
04/21/2026

Some cute little jungle baby animal cookies for a birthday.

Now taking cookie orders for Teacher Appreciation (5/5/26), Nurse Appreciation (5/6/26) and Mother's Day (5/10/26). Con...
04/19/2026

Now taking cookie orders for Teacher Appreciation (5/5/26), Nurse Appreciation (5/6/26) and Mother's Day (5/10/26). Contact me via facebook, messenger, or email at [email protected].

12/25/2025

Shelly's Cookies would like to wish you all a very Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Time to assemble some Christmas cookie boxes!
12/14/2025

Time to assemble some Christmas cookie boxes!

Address

County Road 139
Interlaken, NY
14847

Telephone

+16075324856

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shelly's Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shelly's Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category