https://www.facebook.com/1100768343312007/

Leahlicious Pies & Baked Goods bakery

Home
United States
Indianapolis, IN
Leahlicious Pies & Baked Goods bakery

36+ Homemade Butter crust pies 🥧 😋 Plus a variety of other regular and Gluten Free baked goods! I have been baking/cooking since I was a little girl.

I was taught well by my Great Grandma, Grandma, Aunt and most of all my mom. November of 2015 I advertised on Facebook that I would be selling pies. Every year for Thanksgiving my family always have a variety of pies to eat that are homemade. So I thought maybe other people would like homemade pies for Thanksgiving. And of'course who wouldn't want a homemade butter crust pie?! :)

After I hit the

post button on Facebook I thought maybe a few people would be interested.............well I was wrong! So every Thanksgiving through till Christmas I am very busy with pie season :)

10/20/2025

Hello everyone!! Thanksgiving pie 🥧 orders are FILLED!!

My orders fill very fast- so don’t hesitate!! 😊
My limit has been FILLED!

We have Regular pies, Gluten Free and Sugar Free available.

GF stands for Gluten Free- price is listed below.

SF stands for Sugar Free- price listed below.

All my pies are made with a Butter Crust and Unbleached flour. (Unless it is GF- then I use GF flour.)

My pies are numbered 1-36, let me know which number/s you would like.

Pick-up will be Wednesday, November 26th at Suburban Christian school. Not sure of the timeframe, yet. Likely in the morning.
Will keep you posted.

Thank you! 😊❤️

1-Sugar Cream $20

2- Snickerdoodle $20 (GF $25)

3- Lemon Custard $20 (GF $25)

4- Carrot cake pie with thin layer of cream on top $20 (GF $25)

5- Chocolate chip cookie $20 (GF $25)

6- Chocolate fudge ‘plain, toffee bits or nuts’ inside $20 (GF $25)

7- Chocolate espresso pecan $20 (GF $25)

8- Funfetti (sweet sugar cookie taste with white chocolate, chocolate chips and sprinkles) $20 (GF $25)

9- Peanut Butter Fudge with salted peanut butter caramel on top $20 (GF $25)

10- Caramel Apple Cheesecake $20 (GF $25)

11- Pumpkin with plain or cinnamon crust $20 (GF $25)

12- Pumpkin with Hazelnut swirl $20 (GF $25)

13- Double crust Plain Apple $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

14- Apple with a Pecan glaze double crust $25 (GF $30)

15- Berry double crust $25 (GF $30- SF $30)

16- Peach Double crust $25 (GF $30- SF $30)

17- Peach Crisp $25 (GF $30- SF $30)

18- Cherry double crust $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

19- Cherry Crisp $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

20- Strawberry double crust $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

21- Strawberry crisp $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

22- Strawberry/Rhubarb double crust $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

23- Strawberry/Rhubarb crisp $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

24- Blueberry double crust with plain or lemon crust $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

25- Blueberry crisp $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

26- Blackberry double crust $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

27- Blackberry crisp $25 (GF $30-SF $30)

28- Key Lime with a Macadamia Nut crust $25
(GF $30)

29- Lemon Meringue $25 (GF $30)

30- Coconut Cream with Italian Meringue $25 (GF $30)

31- Chocolate with Meringue or cream topping $25 (GF $30)

32- Butterscotch with Meringue $25 (GF $30

33- Peanut Butter with a cream topping $25 (GF $30)

34- Pecan- $25 (GF $30)

35- Bourbon Pecan with chocolate on the bottom $25 (GF $30)

36- Macadamia Nut Butterscotch cookie pie $25 (GF $30)

04/07/2025

Accepting very limited Easter orders……order now. 🐣😊 (FILLED- No more orders)

Offering Pies, Pastry and 1 variety of cake.

Pecan Pastry $10

Blueberry/Lemon 3- layered cake with cream cheese icing $40

Pickup will be April 19th in the morning 10am-12pm, at Suburban Christian school (county-line road, past Community South Hospital, between 31 and 1-35).

Pies are butter crust and made with Unbleached flour.

GF stands for Gluten Free, all GF pies are an additional $5. Upon requests only.

If any further questions dont hesitate to contact me. 😊 Thank you!

Pies are numbered, 1-35.

1- Sugar Cream $18 GF

2- Snickerdoodle $18 GF

3- Lemon Custard $18 GF

4- Carrot cake pie with thin layer of cream on top $18 GF

5- Chocolate chip cookie $18 GF

6- Chocolate fudge ‘plain, toffee bits or nuts’ inside $18 GF

7- Chocolate espresso pecan $18 GF

8- Funfetti (sweet sugar cookie taste with white chocolate, chocolate chips and sprinkles) $18 GF

9- Peanut Butter Fudge with salted peanut butter caramel on top $18 GF

10- Caramel Apple Cheesecake $18 GF

11- Pumpkin with plain or cinnamon crust $18 GF

12- Pumpkin with Hazelnut swirl $18 GF

13- Double crust Plain Apple $25 GF

14- Apple with a Pecan glaze double crust $25 GF

15- Berry double crust $25 GF

16- Peach Double crust $25 GF

17- Peach Crisp $25 GF

18- Cherry double crust $25 GF

19- Cherry Crisp $25 GF

20- Strawberry double crust $25 GF

21- Strawberry crisp $25 GF

22- Strawberry/Rhubarb double crust $25 GF

23- Strawberry/Rhubarb crisp $25 GF

24- Blueberry double crust with plain or lemon crust $25 GF

25- Blueberry crisp $25 GF

26- Blackberry double crust $25 GF

27- Blackberry crisp $25 GF

28- Key Lime with a Macadamia Nut crust $25 GF

29- Lemon Meringue $25 GF

30- Coconut Cream with Italian Meringue $25 GF

31- Chocolate with Meringue or cream topping $25 GF

32- Butterscotch with Meringue $25 GF

33- Peanut Butter with a cream topping $25 Gf

34- Pecan- $25 GF

35- Bourbon Pecan with chocolate on the bottom $25

02/09/2025

Valentine’s Day is literally right around the corner! ❤️❤️❤️

I am offering Purple colored boxes, everything inside is Heart-Shaped! (Limited Orders- Filled!!) Pick up will be February 14th, at Suburban Christian School. Pickup is from 3:30-4pm.

Inside the boxes you will receive 24 items.
$65 a box.
(These boxes can be Gluten Free, but the cost would be $75.)

Filled Hand pies-
2- Apple
2- Peach
2- Blueberry with Lemon glaze on top
Brownies/Cookies-
6- Brownies with chocolate icing
6- Sugar cookies with red or pink glaze and gold
sprinkles on top
6- Chocolate chip cookies with white/
chocolate drizzled on top with valentine sprinkles

OR just a Pink box full of:

12- Heart-shaped Sugar cookies with red or pink icing/gold sprinkles $36 a box (Gluten Free- $42)

ALSO offering Cheesecakes $45 (serves 12+)
(Limited Orders)

1. Raspberry/ White chocolate
2. Lemon Cheesecake with Blueberries
3. Peanut Butter with chocolate ganache
4. Plain with either (Cherry, Berry or Blueberry pie
filling on top)

All Cheesecakes can be made Gluten Free, those would be $50.

Thank you!

12/22/2024

To the Christmas orders- 😊🌲🎅🏻

Pickup is tomorrow from 2-4pm at Suburban Christian School. In between 31 and 1-35… not far from Community Hospital on county line road.

Come to entrance B-1. That is main entrance.

The other entrance is blocked off for construction.

Thank you to all who ordered! 🥰

Kristen Baynai

Hannah O’Friel

Jon Boone

Jennifer Lemaire

Kelly Koch

Kendee

Gaye Dickey

Teresa Sego

Sheila Cochran

Jeanne Hartley

Marki Nix

Stacy Hall

Bridget Foy

Jane Naugle

Michele Muller

Abbie Poissen

Jen Gugle

Renee Peyton

Lois Flora

12/07/2024

Orders FILLED! Anyone interested in ordering for Christmas. 🎄

Pickup will be December 23rd from 2pm-4pm at Suburban Christian school, between 31 and 1-35, down the road from Community South Hospital.

Let me know if you would like to order. Thank you!

Offering-

Pecan pastries $10 each

Buckeyes- $10 a dozen (an order is a dozen) Can be made with Rice Krispies in it or without. And naturally Gluten Free.

Pecan Tea cookies $10 a dozen (an order is a dozen) They are pictured below with red and green icing.

Gluten Free- Pecan Tea Cookies $12 a dozen (an order is a dozen)

Pies are numbered from 1- 35.

All GF pies stand for Gluten Free, and they are $5 more.
All SF pies stand for Sugar Free, and they are $5 more.

1- Sugar Cream $18

2- Snickerdoodle $18 GF

3- Lemon Custard $18 GF

4- Carrot cake pie with thin layer of cream on top $18 GF

5- Chocolate chip cookie $18 GF

6- Chocolate fudge ‘plain, toffee bits or nuts’ inside $18 GF

7- Chocolate espresso pecan $18 GF

8- Funfetti (sweet sugar cookie taste with white chocolate, chocolate chips and sprinkles) $18 GF

9- Peanut Butter Fudge with salted peanut butter caramel on top $18 GF

10- Caramel Apple Cheesecake $18 GF

11- Pumpkin with plain or cinnamon crust $18 GF

12- Pumpkin with Hazelnut swirl $18 GF

13- Double crust Plain Apple $25 GF SF

14- Apple with a Pecan glaze double crust $25 GF

15- Berry double crust $25 GF SF

16- Peach Double crust $25 GF SF

17- Peach Crisp $25 GF SF

18- Cherry double crust $25 GF SF

19- Cherry Crisp $25 GF SF

20- Strawberry double crust $25 GF SF

21- Strawberry crisp $25 GF SF

22- Strawberry/Rhubarb double crust $25 GF SF

23- Strawberry/Rhubarb crisp $25 GF SF

24- Blueberry double crust with plain or lemon crust $25 GF SF

25- Blueberry crisp $25 GF SF

26- Blackberry double crust $25 GF SF

27- Blackberry crisp $25 GF SF

28- Key Lime with a Macadamia Nut crust $25
GF

29- Lemon Meringue $25 GF

30- Coconut Cream with Italian Meringue $25 GF

31- Chocolate with Meringue or cream topping $25 GF

32- Butterscotch with Meringue $25 GF

33- Peanut Butter with a cream topping $25 Gf

34- Pecan- $25 GF

35- Bourbon Pecan with chocolate on the bottom $25 GF

11/19/2024

Hello to the ones who ordered Thanksgiving pies this year!! 🥰

Pickup will be Wednesday, 27th from 10am-12:00pm.

Location is Suburban Christian school- Entrance B-2.
(The school is on County line road between 31 and 1-35, down from Community South hospital. I would give an address but unfortunately it takes you to the wrong location. Just put in the schools name and it will take you to the right location 😊)

If you are unable to pick up the pie/s at this timeframe, please find someone to pick it up for you. Unfortunately with my schedule, this is the best time for me. Sorry for any inconvenience.

Thank you!! Thank you!! ❤️

Here is the list of people that ordered:

Aubrey Helmns- 2

Nikki Asbury- 2

Carmel Krynock- 2

Janice Lynn- 3

Dawn Hough- 2

Judy Scott- 1

Deidre Hancock- 5

Bill Cross- 3

Danita Castor- 5

Denise Rodenhuis- 4

Sarah Hill- 2

Lisa Smith- 2

Lisa Hudson- 2

Madeline Duncan- 7

Jennifer Lemair- 4

Melissa Johnson- 2

Kelly Miller Keedy- 1

Melanie Bradley- 3

Tim- Melissa Towne- 2

Jenny Poore- 1

Ally Nashte- 2

Michelle Banister- 2

Lois Flora- 2

Stephanie Donley- 3

Teri Dunbar- 7

Abbie Poissen- 2

Ashley Watts- 3

Andrea Bauschek- 3

Kelly Koch- 3

Hannah O’Friel- 1

Renee Peyton- 1

Twili McKenzie-2

Jane Naugle- 2

Michelle McCune- 2

Tiffanie McKenzie- 1

Amanda Cox- 1

Lisa Bowman- 2

Teresa Sego- 2

Lori Boone- 1

Beka Thomas- 2

10/16/2024

Orders- FILLED! Hey y’all!! It’s that time of year again! Thanksgiving pie 🥧 orders! I have quite a bit of orders already in so I can only…….FILLED!

ACCEPT- the first 15 PIES 🥧 …..yes that’s right, the first 15 pies! Pie orders FILLED!

My orders fill fast- so don’t hesitate. 😊

GF stands for Gluten Free- which is an additional $5 more for the pie.

SF stands for Sugar Free- which is an additional $5 more for the pie.

All my pies are made with a Butter Crust and Unbleached flour.

My pies are numbered 1-37, let me know which number/s you would like.

Pick-up will probably be Wednesday, November 27th at Suburban Christian school. Not sure of the timeframe, yet. Will keep you posted.

Thank you! 😊❤️

1- Sugar Cream $18

2- Snickerdoodle $18 GF

3- Lemon Custard $18 GF

4- Carrot cake pie with thin layer of cream on top $18 GF

5- Chocolate chip cookie $18 GF

6- Chocolate fudge ‘plain, toffee bits or nuts’ inside $18 GF

7- Chocolate espresso pecan $18 GF

8- Funfetti (sweet sugar cookie taste with white chocolate, chocolate chips and sprinkles) $18 GF

9- Peanut Butter Fudge with salted peanut butter caramel on top $18 GF

10- Caramel Apple Cheesecake $18 GF

11- Pumpkin with plain or cinnamon crust $18 GF

12- Pumpkin with Hazelnut swirl $18 GF

13- Double crust Plain Apple $25 GF

14- Apple with a Pecan glaze double crust $25 GF

15- Berry (Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries and Raspberries) double crust $25 GF SF

16- Peach Double crust $25 GF SF

17- Peach Crisp $25 GF SF

18- Cherry double crust $25 GF SF

19- Cherry Crisp $25 GF SF

20- Strawberry double crust $25 GF SF

21- Strawberry crisp $25 GF SF

22- Strawberry/Rhubarb double crust $25 GF SF

23- Strawberry/Rhubarb crisp $25 GF SF

24- Blueberry double crust with plain or lemon crust $25 GF SF

25- Blueberry crisp $25 GF SF

26- Blackberry double crust $25 GF SF

27- Blackberry crisp $25 GF SF

28- Key Lime with a Macadamia Nut crust $25
GF

29- Lemon Meringue $25 GF

30- Coconut Cream with Italian Meringue $25 GF

31- Chocolate with Meringue or cream topping $25 GF

32- Butterscotch with Meringue $25 GF

33- Peanut Butter with a cream topping $25 Gf

34- Pecan- $25 GF

35- Bourbon Pecan with chocolate on the bottom $25 GF

36- Macadamia Nut Butterscotch cookie pie $25

37- Cinnamon Roll apple pie with cream cheese topping $28 GF

Address

Indianapolis, IN

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Leahlicious Pies & Baked Goods bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Leahlicious Pies & Baked Goods bakery:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Indianapolis?