CustomcookiesbyHailey

02/07/2026

Gender reveal cookies featuring the parents occupation! 💙🩷

01/11/2026

Check out this cute motocross set for Athena’s second birthday!

I forgot to snag a picture of this cute set, but the customer was sweet enough to send me one!

01/11/2026

A cute benson Boone set for the birthday girl!

12/16/2025

We thought gift cards could use a little bonus. 🍪🍕
For a limited time, grab a $20 (or more) B.C. Pizza gift card and score a pizza cookie, made just for us by CustomcookiesbyHailey.
Perfect for gifting, sharing… or keeping all to yourself.
We don’t judge.
📍 Howard City Location Only
🎁 $20+ Gift Card Purchase Required
⏳ While Supplies Last

12/12/2025

Last call for these to be ready next weekend!

12/03/2025

11/18/2025

Kiersten will be welcoming her sweet baby boy in just a couple months and she chose the sweetest little theme for her baby shower! 🌲❄️

11/12/2025

It’s that time of year!! Offering these again this year for Christmas! They will be $15 a set, one large customized cookie and your choice of a $10 Starbucks or biggby gift card. These will need to be fully paid for upon ordering and I will have them ready by your choice of the 13th/14th or 20th/21st.

04/28/2025

The perfect theme for a 1st birthday! 🩷

01/04/2025

Now these have got to be a favorite to date! The detail and cuteness is just too much!! 😍 ☃️